Ninja

Max XL Air Fryer (AF161)

Ninja Max XL Air Fryer (AF161)

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#122 in

Air Fryers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score60% positive
3
1
1

Top Pros

Top Cons

No summary available.

Last updated: Jul 4, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconporp_crawl
21 days ago

The 5.5qt thing sounds big, but it's more tall than broad. It's still plenty big. Despite any of the accompanying materials, yes, you want to keep stuff 1 layer thick. Ideally with space in between. For stuff like fries and onion rings, yeah, toss them (people say 2x, 3x is better. 4x, though, isn't - given the total frying time). You might be able to get 1.5 layers in and still get ok results. Chicken wings. \[edit: doing this, I get some internal bubbles leading to very delicate shatter crispy bubbles. Big stretches of shattering crispy skin on the remaining 80-90%. Not much gets not-crispy, even if a wing flat or drumstick has been sitting at room temp for an hour or two. "*Recrisp"* is a setting my air fryer has, and it's designed for refreshing crispy stuff\] Baking powder does make the skin *potentially* crispier by changing the pH/making it a little more alkaline. The suggestion for *powder* is before acceptance of potato starch as the premier coating. That suggestion is predicate on no additional dry coating. Baking powder is fine even with a dry coating. Not great. You need to use potato starch. It is superior because of it's inherent properties based on its structure as a starch. Potato starch is not the best for everything, but it is the best for dry battered air fried chicken wings. Dry wings with clean paper towel(s). Fish sauce is a secret ingredient - no "fishiness" comes through. You can use Accent (er, Ac'cent, I guess they're calling themselves now) which is MSG. Or just go get and use unabashed straight-up MSG. Baking soda - I do end up using a full (but flat) tablespoon per pound. The amounts you will see may be very different (much less). I don't sense any negative tastes/alkalinity. You do need some moisture/liquid in order to evenly spread the baking soda. Sprinkle some water from your fingertips from a bowl of clean water directly onto the wings in your mixing bowl, if you need to. Aromatics of your liking (including ground pepper, your call on variety. garlic. onion. paprika?). Salt. Let sit for a while/whatever. Before you load up the air fryer, toss each piece in potato starch. If you're bold, you can pour some potato starch in a sealable tupperware-type container, drop in your split wings. Seal, shake. Shake excess off. Place in basket/whatever. Spray with a fine mist of oil, the finer the better, - just enough to un-white the potato starch on the surface. Flip each piece, and finely spray the other side. For "regular"/larger sized wings, Air fry (400F) 10 min. Colour will be skeptical. Flip. 8 minutes Air fry. Colour should be closer. Flip. 2 minutes Max Fry (the maximum temp/fan speed yours can go. Having a "crisper" type surface on the bottom through all this helps lots). Take out, let sit for a couple of minutes before consuming/tossing in sauce.

Reddit IconGurlie_J_Girl
7 months ago

Ninja just introduced this face-lift version. I have the original, prior model, and as others have stated, I use this constantly without failure. Very happy purchase

Reddit Iconsoundfan88
about 1 month ago

I've gotten TONS of use out of a Ninja Max XL 5.5qt since 2023. I love this thing. I use it several times a week for things like potatoes, salmon, frozen broc, chicken, sometimes steak. But, I'm finding that I could occasionally use a little bit larger surface area (e.g., large chicken cutlets sometimes can push it). I've never needed it to be any taller. Visibility isn't super important but it might be nice to see what's going on and not interrupt cooking. Wondering if anyone's been in a similar spot, what they went with, and how they like it? Thanks!

Reddit IconAdventurous-Bee-5477
7 months ago

Ahhh the AF100 I remember you at the start of my 'whats a good airfryer to buy journey' :). Im getting an airfryer with Qantas points so its $0 and one i can get online via Qantas points is the ninja 5.2l. From another post their 5l airfryer can cook half a pizza... so yeah that might do so I portion control and pizza lasts.

Reddit Icon90s_vibe
10 months ago

So I have two air fryers. Both are ninjas. One is single and one is dual. I do agree the single is better. It's really convenient to have three air fryers when making something like air fryer chicken, roasted veggies & fresh french fries. I can make all three at the same time and eat at the same time. Super convenient. Also if making wontons and spring rolls. I have a pretty busy job, a young child & a husband who doesn't cook. So for me worth it to have all. I also have enough space in my kitchen.

Reddit Iconnst138
12 months ago

Als ich mit meinem Partner zusammengezogen bin haben wir uns direkt eine Ninja geholt (keine ahnung welches Modell genau, hat aber nur ein Fach und Max crisp funktion) Anfangs war ich skeptisch, ABER es ist schon ganz geil. Am meisten machem wir darin TK sachen. Letztens hatten wir einen Kuchen drin gemacht mit den speziellen Backpapierdingern, hat auch gut geklappt. Das einzige was ich unfassbar nervig finde ist, sie jedes mal sauber zu machen. Da find ich den Ofen alle paar monate sauber machen amgenehmer, aber was die schnelligkeit betrifft ist der air fryer um welten besser. Vorallem weil wir einen recht alten ofen haben, der die Hitze manchmal doof verteilt. Das einzige was wir noch aktiv im Ofen machen sind aufläufe oder TK Pizza

Top Air Fryers on Reddit

1
Ninja Foodi Dual Zone Series

Ninja

Foodi Dual Zone Series

86% positive of 228 users

Dual zones for smart cooking, but baskets are small.

2
COSORI Turbo Blaze 9-in-1 6QT

COSORI

Turbo Blaze 9-in-1 6QT

91% positive of 125 users

Quiet, easy to clean, but lacks a viewing window.

3
Ninja Foodi Air Fry Oven Series

Ninja

Foodi Air Fry Oven Series

82% positive of 233 users

Flips up to save space, but shallow and air fries poorly.

4
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Series

Breville

Smart Oven Air Fryer Series

78% positive of 303 users

Oven replacement; spacious, but air frying and cleaning divide users.

5
Typhur Dome

Typhur

Dome

93% positive of 72 users

Self-cleaning and quiet, but expensive with shallow interior.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs