
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Reddit Reviews
100% agree. I have a *FIFTEEN* year old used indie and it is like brand new. People are shocked when I tell them the age of the stroller. The glides like a dream, folds easily, has a built-in bassiner function, is fully washable, and is compatible with my car seat of choice. And the company still stocks parts for it.
I have a used Bumblerider. It is a model that was discontinued in 2012. I'm its fourth owner. It looks and functions like a brand new stroller.
If you can find one, I got a fourth-hand bumblerider indie and it is a beast. Curbs, mud, gravel roads. I havdn't used it in snow yet but the previous owner tells me it rolls great. Even though this stroller is over a decade old, it rides like new and the company still sells compatible parts for it. I got the car seat adapter and the keyfit35 fits very securely. Once baby out grows the seat we'll still have the stroller for years and will probably be able to pass it on to a 5th family when we're done with it.
I'm in rural AB and am the fourth owner of a 15 year old indie. Thing is a beast. At 15 years old it looks brand new and it handles great on grass and gravel. I haven't used it in snow yet, butbthe previous owner tells me it works great. All of the parts, even for a 2010 model, are availlable on the company website. Unfortunately, it is a US brand so tariffs may be an issue. I wish I'd bought a new seat adjustment belt and bug net before those came into effect. It isn't parent facing, but there is a little window on top so you can look down at them. I really appreciated that I could pop a 6lb newborn in without any attachments or worry.
If you can get one, the Bumblerider Indie is a beast. Giant wheels. I've taken it off-road through mud and rocks and two feet of snow and it goes. On pavement it is super smooth. And it lays flat which is great for newborns and naps. The one I have is over a decade old and looks brand new. Downsides - there is no parent facing mode, it folds but not very compact (I think thay's the case with all joggers though), and the storage basket isn't huge (we still manage a full grocery shop with it, but I have to use a backpack diaperbag to free up space).
+1 Can't go wrong with a Bumbleride. We got a 12 year old one second hand. Thing is a tank and the company sells replacement parts even for our decade out-of-date model. They hold their value well, so you can sell ans upgrade to a double when the time comes, or you can get a ride-along skateboard attachment.
Bumbleride Indie or Era are nice to push in any condition and even a bigger kid fits nicely. Full recline in both of these.
You don’t need a travel system, lots of car seats are compatible with different strollers. We got a Bumbleride indie stroller and a chicco car seat (keyfit? The 30 I think). The car seat has really good reviews and safety ratings and I’d say it’s a great one for the price. Love the stroller so far. Where I live almost everyone has a Bob but I wanted something a little smaller and lighter but still all terrain. We’ve taken it on fairly rugged walking paths and lots of uneven sidewalks and I’m so pleased. It’s easy enough for me to load in and out of my vehicle and it doesn’t feel too enormous to take in stores but it’s a nice smooth ride and super easy and comfy to push so it’s a nice middle ground imo. That’s my rec! I’d also advise to start by choosing your stroller and then looking at compatible car seats. You’ll use the stroller for longer than you will the infant carseat and there are huge differences between strollers depending what you’re looking for. You can find a highly-rated good quality car seat that is compatible with almost any stroller, so start with the stroller and narrow the car seat selection down that way. You’ll use can buy lots of things used but def get the car seat new! It’s one of the few things you def shouldn’t buy secondhand.
Yes, I have an old one and I've upgraded it over the years with new parts and car seat adapter. Recently, I bought the buggy board because my new baby needs it and the toddler loves riding behind (haven't used the board attachment in snow yet, but it's durable and made using skateboard materials).
Bumbleride indie or speed! Theyre a super nontoxic and eco friendly brand! [bumbleride](https://bumbleride.com)
I lovvvved the indie! It was rugged but maneuverable
I got my high end strollers second hand! With the first we got a Bumbleride Indie for trails and beaches for $90!— and it’s still amazing 4 years later, we even replaced tires on it. Then I got a used uppababy Cruz for $150 and it’s been amazing as well. FWIW I bought a small travel stroller new (YoYo Zen2) that folds down to carry on airplanes and while we do use it for that, the storage is awful (doesn’t fit anything) and the price was outrageous for how little we actually like it. 😆 Established brands in strollers are worth it imo.
I have the bumbleride indie and we love it! We got it for a deal from rebel or goodbuy gear because it was new but slightly scratched. I live in an area where I can walk to the library, grocery store etc from our house. So we love just strolling out the door with the indie. We also have really bumpy sidewalks around so we needed the air tires and I do some very light jogging with it as well. The cork handlebar is awesome. It has an adapter for a variety of car seats but we never ended up using that because my baby hated the stroller until she was almost 6 months and we just did baby wearing on our walks. Also, the indie and I think the era recline flat so they are safe for less than 6 month olds without any adapter. We ended up with the Chicco keyfit 35 cleartex car seat because I just couldn't justify paying for the fancy Nuna ones even if they are lighter. And it's fine! However the indie is huge and heavy! We ended up getting a small zoe travel stroller (they have one made with recycled fabric!) as well because if we are traveling anywhere the indie takes up a ton of space. We got our zoe from one of those returned/open box websites as well and it was a great deal. I personally really like having two options, one big full size and one super packable travel stroller, but I know that isn't for everyone. I do highly recommend searching all the open box type websites for deals, or of course looking for used strollers if you live in a city or non-rural area. The "greenest" thing is not buying new in my opinion (and it saves $$)
Yes! I do a lot of walking on sidewalks paved with historic brick and they a bumpy! The bumble ride is amazing, and the company is exactly what I want to support. We also have a zoe for travel or small spaces and that is great as well.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Airplane overhead bins

Top pick
Bugaboo - Butterfly Series
Best for Grocery shopping

Top pick
UPPAbaby - Vista V2
Best for Jogging

Top pick
Thule - Urban Glide 3 Series
Best for Non-toxic materials

Top pick
Bumbleride - Era
Best for Public transit commuting

Top pick
Joolz - Aer+
Best for Snowy sidewalks

Top pick
Thule - Urban Glide 3 Series





