
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Top Pros
Top Cons
Reddit Reviews
I have the HVUL1 for mainly canoe camping in Ontario and backcountry hiking. I use the included footprint most of the time but even without, I’ve not had any durability concerns. Obviously check the group for sharp rocks and stuff before you pitch. I’ve had to tape the bug netting because my eyeglasses have a sharp corner that caught and ripped it. I’ve broken a zipper before pulling way too hard on the main rain fly zip. That said, it’s ideal for me and I don’t have any concerns about durability. It’s a tool that will experience regular wear and tear. I like double wall and don’t have the budget yet for dyneema. One note- if you can get an old model of the copper spur, before the new HyperBead fabric, I’d try for that. Anecdotes say the removal of PFAS makes the new material less effective, but I’m unsure myself.
I have the 1-person copper spur and love it. It’s just so simple and so reliable. The shorter “bikepacking” poles may seem silly but it makes the tent very Packable. I’ve ditched the over-engineered stuff sack it came in though, takes up unnecessary space and weight. I also own a larger MSR tent in the hubba line and they are honestly also great and pretty equivalent in terms of ease and quality (can’t speak to the new bike pack version)
Tents I have used - REI Half Dome 1p - Fine, decent quality for the price but kind of heavy and bulky and the poles are long. It almost always kept me dry though. Big Agnes Cooper Spur 1p - The bikepacking version with short poles. A nice tent but quite expensive. Better than the REI tent in every way but still kind of bulky. Very roomy inside with a big vestibule. Durston X-mid 1 - Excellent tent! I like everything about it. Very usable for how light and small it is and it stood up to heavy weather in Scotland, Wales, etc with no problems. I have the early version which requires stakes, if I were buying one now I would get the free-standing version for more versatility. Oh, I am 6'1" and had enough room in all these tents. Though the Durston got a little snug at times with the diagonal layout I still prefer it.
We've been using the Copper Spurs going back to when they were introduced in 2008. We currently have the 1P and 2P at our house. We've used them in all sorts of weather here in the central Rockies. No problems.
Yup, there were certainly places where I could put my one person Copper Spur in where a 2p couldn't. I should add, given your comment, if you like some solo time, a 1p tent that you can tuck in a stealth spot is pretty nice.
I don’t get 2p tents. I’m not a small man and love my Copper Spur 1p. Easier to find a good spot, and I’m not taking up space that others could use.
Another vote for BA, but the 1p
Am I the only one who does not share a tent with my wife? She carries a Big Agnes 1p and I carry the 2p for that luxury condo on the trail. This works great and with two light tents, is very manageable and gives us our space on a trip where it is nothing but the two of us.
I switched from a Big Agnes 1P to an Xmid Pro 2P last year and I haven’t looked back. I love it! Like you, I always have my trekking poles and I grew wary of always having a separate tent pole. Also, my 1P tent was ridiculously small. My Xmid sleeps colder since it’s a single wall tent, so I bought a second quilt (much warmer) so that I can continue backpacking year round and keep warm overnight.
I have had problems pitching my Big Agnes on hard dirt so I ran long sturdy sticks through my BA pitching loops and I put rocks on the ends of the sticks.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Backpacking

Top pick
Durston - X-Mid 2
Best for Beginner camping

Top pick
Gazelle Tents - T4 Hub Tent Series
Best for Comfort-focused car camping

Top pick
Gazelle Tents - T4 Hub Tent Series
Best for Hot and humid weather camping

Top pick
Durston - X-Mid 2
Best for Rain and wind

Top pick
Durston - X-Mid 2
Best for Snow and wind

Top pick
SlingFin - Portal 2





