Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#290 in

Camping Tents

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score67% positive
4
1
1

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Apr 26, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconSkiberrjr
8 months ago

Sorry to see Eureka! go. They built solid tents for reasonable prices. I'd put my Timberline 4-person up anything that cost twice as much, especially in a windstorm. I happened on an REI tent-testing session at a local airport some years ago. The testers were tying various tents onto a flatbed trailer, then driving up and down the runway ar speeds varying from 20-50 mph. Testers sat inside the tents to measure deflection and wind noise. If I remember correctly, a North Face got the best score.

Reddit IconThumpAndSplash
7 months ago

Closest thing you’ll find in modern offering is probably a “Eureka Timberline 4?” We used em in scouts and they’re very similar looking to this. 

Reddit IconAny_Inspection9286
7 months ago

If you like this tent just snag a Eureka Timberline and be happy with a much better tent.

7 months ago

True but being the standard issue boy scout tent for a very long time means six billion of them exist which makes them much easier to find.

Reddit IconAR_geojag
3 months ago

Eureka Timberline tents are great, very durable. For tent stakes, I have gone to using 8" timberlick type lag bolts. Use an impact driver to install and remove. Unless you are right on a rock, they work great. I also have a few 4" in the bag.

Reddit IconConfident-Shake-4684
5 months ago

I love this thing. Saved up for it and bought it on sale as a gift for my wife before she was my wife. It has served us admirably (and will for as long as I can keep repairing it)

Reddit Icond_squared0330
9 months ago

Alps Mountaineering offers similar value and BSA discounts. Facebook marketplace is full of smoking deals on Eureka tents. I just got a Timberline for $30. It was missing one of the end poles. $16 from eBay got me two of them.

Reddit IconG8rBob
7 months ago

Same, I’ve had mine since 1995ish and it’s held up great!

7 months ago

Same - have the green as well! I discovered that tent bc my dad actually had the same one for years, too. It’s a classic.

Reddit Iconhikerjohnd
5 months ago

I wanted a Tadpole so much. I just couldn’t afford it. I ended up with a Eureka Timberline. But in my mind, the Tadpole was a ‘real’ backpacker’s tent.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: