Sorry to see Eureka! go. They built solid tents for reasonable prices. I'd put my Timberline 4-person up anything that cost twice as much, especially in a windstorm.
I happened on an REI tent-testing session at a local airport some years ago. The testers were tying various tents onto a flatbed trailer, then driving up and down the runway ar speeds varying from 20-50 mph. Testers sat inside the tents to measure deflection and wind noise. If I remember correctly, a North Face got the best score.
I have a couple of Eureka timber lines 2 and three men really light excellent fiberglass poles elastic. Floor vent. I’ve had them for years. They always succeed.
I know that Eureka is no longer in the tent business, but their Timberline 2 tent \[with stiff alum poles\] holds up well under very high wind conditions. I couldn't as a college kid afford a 4-season tent, so for winter snowshoe backpack trips {N. VT and Adirondacks\] I used my first Timberline 2. My newer Timberline 2 \[15 yrs. old\] is still my goto tent if storm conditions are expected \[now coastal PNW\].
The lower profile A-shaped tent resists high winds better than my other dome-type tent.
I can't comment on the Snow Peak, my sense is that their stuff is high quality but also trendy - expensive. I'm sure their Titanium cup would last forever, but $37 for a coffee cup is a bit rich.
I am familiar with Eureka tents and used a Timberline 2 for decades. It was heavy compared to modern hiking tents, but it survived everything from bushwack hiking in the Green Mountains to snowshoe hiking in the Adirondacks. When I could no longer maintain the waterproofing on the fly; I bought another one, and if stormy weather is expected \[PNW coast\], I still use the T2.
I originally bought the Timberline 2 for backpacking in rugged terrain during Fall/Winter seasons in northern VT and NY. The simple A-frame style is superior to most designs in high wind or snowy conditions, but most folks today demand more space and comfort.
As a retiree, with creaky bones, who can no longer manage hiking, I now normally use an Alps 3-man dome tent or a Core 4 cabin-walled tent. These two are not as rugged as the Timberline, but are spacious and inexpensive.
I drive an F150 with a full 8' canopy so I keep the Timberline is case of full-storm weather. The Pacific coast can have wicked winds and sheeting rain during the colder months.
Y/W. Way back in the 1980s I used to snowshoe hike in Vermont \[Green Mountains\] and NY \[Adirondacks\]. I could never justify the cost of a 4-season tent, so I used my Eureka Timberline 2.
I really like the YTs by these two and I believe that they give honest reviews.
I use 3 tents. Two are for summer - fair weather camping but my best tent is the Alps Mountaineering Taurus Outfitter 4-person tent. It is ruggedly built, has aluminum poles, a full fly, and easily manages rainy/windy coastal PNW camping. I consider it a 3.5 season tent.
For more headroom, Alps makes a 5-person version of the Taurus Outfitter that might fit your needs.
[ALPS Mountaineering Taurus Outfitter 5 Tent 5 : Target](https://www.target.com/p/alps-mountaineering-taurus-outfitter-5-tent-5/-/A-1010270911#lnk=sametab)
I don't know how Alps does it. 4 years ago, when my Eureka Timberline 2 faded, I bought the Alps Meramac 3 for $109. My Eureka was more than twice that 15 yrs. ago, but the Meramac has already lasted for 4 years and is in perfect condition.
I have a Core Cabin Wall 4-person for glamping but when I bought the Taurus 4 Outfitter I didn't know that the 5-person had stand-up headroom. 3 tents is more than enough but I regret that I didn't buy the Taurus 5 Outfitter.
they have them in stock at some small stores still. You can find them for less than $100 used on websites, so I think it just depends on your definition of a fair deal. I have three, one is 33 years old and it’s the only one I bought new.
Skiberrjr
