That's part of the problem, you are basing your decision based on feel, vrs experience. Everyone has their own criteria for a shelter and that's fine. Pick what works for you. Users are simply stating that Hilleberg makes one of the best tents and like with many products, quality comes with a price tag reflective of that quality.
Honestly if you’re looking to pack up to 2kg and have that budget, you might want to consider the Anjan 2 from Hilleberg. It may stretch your budget a bit but could be the last tent you ever buy. No ragrets.
If "hurricane force winds in the high arctic" is part of the discussion, maybe get a yellow label Hilleberg? Anjan is pricy, but hovers around 4 lbs and can handle a serious beating.
Alternatively, look at pyramids from Mountain Laurel Designs. They are quite light, set up with trekking poles, but the shape lends itself well to dealing with wind and difficult weather (including snow load).
I really love Hilleberg and Nordisk. Hilleberg anjan is good option, also enan or Niak. Look at their yellow label. They are a lot stronger than a lot of these US tents, also they have very high resale value. Also they pitch inner and outer together. It’s probably a different design than you are used to. But it’s great, and very durable!
The gold standard is probably the Hilleberg Anjan
But that is a lot of money and if you don't camp as much then maybe its not worth it. Also, as it is a tunnel tent, it is excellent in bad weather but it is not free standing.
Nemo Daggeror dragonfly are great for the money
I use a Anjan personally, but I use Nemo when I guide trips
arumrunner
