Solid tent choices on your list. The Marmot Catalyst is probably your best bet for durability + versatility. REI Half Dome is also worth looking at in that price range.
That said - if you're just starting out and not sure how often you'll camp, consider renting for your first few trips before buying.
I made the mistake of buying a tent before my first trip. Turned out it was way too heavy for backpacking and too small for car camping. Ended up buying a second one anyway.
I love my marmot catalyst for everything except air circulation. Tho it’s Large enough for 2 large sleeping bags (and our 20lb dog), it really builds up condensation under the rainfly since it has no top air vent. I’d definitely get a 3+ person tent for your needs. Your pup will appreciate the extra space
Marmot tents are a great buy. They’re not the lightest, but the bang-for-buck value is outstanding. I got a 2p on clearance for $125 back in 2010 and used it for 5+ years before upgrading it and using as a loaner tent.
If you’re actually backpacking, check the weights, as some are kinda heavy. Also note that some come with the footprint, so factor that into your weights, as well.
Sierra Trading Post has been a great to get some gear as we get away from family/group sleep and into Scouting and solo/one person per tent trips and need more gear. Sleep bags and pads, etc are quite discounted but you have to be flexible. Just got a Marmot 2P tent 60% off ($120) and Northface 20 degree bag for $45 this year. I have 3 kids, we camp for 2-3 weeks each sunmer at a beach in CT and have it down-pat. We also winter camp in freezing temps and have pieced together gear out of necessity and experience. Trial and error is huge. So many people come past our site and comment on how handy our setup is but it just took dozens of trips to figure it out.
Things I always bring: pop up gazebo. Tarps. Bungie cords. Extra tent pegs, cord, those mats people use by pools (ground cover outside tent and water goes thru, easily rinseable and pack away quick). If it rains you can make all sorts of shelter options with that to keep the fun going. Bungees are a no brainer to adapt to anything and make it work. Like duct tape. I use 20lb propane tank. Splitter hose to a single burner for coffee or castiron pan and other hose to a 17” griddle. Wind guards came after some trial and error. Stainless bbq pans to manage prepped and finished food. Easy cleanup.
We have a foldable wagon that helps. Can even tow wood around on a bike in it. Everyone camps differently. Anyone who tells you you are doing it wrong is an idiot. Take what you see and make it work for you. Be flexible! Be prepared to find a better way next time! Have fun. It is the best with kids. My kids are their own people out there and it is heaven.
a2moki
