
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Top Pros
Top Cons
Reddit Reviews
I have an elixir 2 and hubba nx 1 and rarely use them. Subpar tents where you’re paying for the brand name. I have a xmid 1 solid which I much prefer but it’s by no means a 4 season tent. Maybe look at the new Fjern Stormgrotta when it’s back in stock. It looks like it can take a beating and you can’t beat it for £160.
Hi, I’m new to Reddit (first post), so sorry if this doesn’t follow some rule I don’t know. TLDR: I need a new tent that fits the requirements at the bottom, any advice, I’m thinking of the Nallo 2 by Hilleberg. Life story: I am a semi-beginner to camping (sub 40 nights in a tent) and even newer to wild camping (though quite experienced at walking/navigation etc) I am looking to get properly into it. I managed 2 successful trips this summer (total of 3 nights). However, I attempted to go up more recently in stronger winds (partially as a test). My tent is an MSR elixir 2. Unfortunately it was no where near strong enough for the wind, and despite being pitched well, a pole bent and the whole tent collapsed in on itself. While it popped back up again after the gust, it was no longer standing properly and also was now weaker to future wind. I therefore decided to abort and walked the few kilometres back to my car. While I never felt that I was in danger (always had an easy escape option) I want to be able to camp in high winds. I therefore am looking for a decent tent (happy to spend a decent amount of money) that can survive whatever the UK can throw at it. I am presently thinking of a hilleberg Nallo 2, but am undecided. Requirements: - able to take anything the uk has to throw at it - reasonably light (ideally less than 3kg) - actually a 2 man (not like 1 and a tiny person) Thankyou in advance for any help :)
The MSR Elixer 3 would work and has a unique yet intuitive pole design that is incredibly strong in high wind. I have an Elixer 2 and it has held up without fail in many wind and rain storms.
I like my msr elixir 2, it packs very small if you squeeze it in. It is usually too expensive but it often goes on sale on one website or another
MSR Elixir 2 person version. I have one and I love it. I also have a very experienced friend (has done 8k and 7k summits, and trekked pretty much all over the world) who claims that this is the best overall tent for mountain hiking. It ticks all your requirements. MSR has many rather similar models. I also have Hubba Hubba and we like it, but it's not higher altitudes - it is lighter but less sturdy (different pole setup) and colder (more mesh).
I have MSR Elixir and I think this is suitable. Trekking tents are always a compromise - weight vs space vs strength. We are going to Sarek in February / March. What is your destination...? The more visited trails (Kungsleden, Helags-Sylarna area) have the luxury of retreating to a STF cottage in case of a serious storm or incident.
MSR Elixir has double pole structure and is thus rather sturdy in winds. Double entrance comes handy in blizzards. The setup is reasonably easy. It is not very lightweight though. I have done Abisko-Nikkaluokta three times in winter. Here is some advice: \- Take more time than suggested. 8 days is ideal in my opinion. More than that and you will get bored with the snow. Less than that and you cannot do the interesting side trails. \- Start from Katterjokk or Riksgränsen, not Abisko Tourist station, and spend your first two days in the valley west from Kungsleden, at the border of Norway and Sweden. Why so? Less crowed. No snowmobile track. Much more serene. \- Do a detour to Nallo. Either from Alesjaure (Alesjaure - Vistas - Nallo - Sälka) or from Tjäktja (Tjäktja - Nallo - Sälka). \- Do a detour to Tarfala, from the Kebnekaise base station. \- Explore options to summit Kebnekaise - I have not been at the summit in winter, but it should be possible, the Kebnekaise mountain station would know. \- Spend one night in a STF house with sauna. This is part of the Lappish experience that you cannot get in tents. Unna Allakas, Vistas, Sälka have saunas IIRC. Part of the fun is making the firewood yourself and heating the place up. The main route (Abisko - Singi - Nikkaluokta) has become so popular that skiing on it does not do the neighbourhood proper justice. Side valleys give you the real feeling. No snowmobile tracks, no large guided groups, just you.
At near 5kg this is pretty heavy for wild camping especially if you’re gonna be hiking with it. Decathlon make good budget friendly stuff but I’d say this is more suited to car camping, festivals etc. For solo camping in good weather I just use a bivvy. Mine is 1.2kg and doesn’t feel claustrophobic with the raised head space. https://www.nevisport.com/snugpak-stratosphere-bivvi-shelter?gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=20334258410&gbraid=0AAAAAD_XdalevZOR0GFvh2642oHxaKgAw&gclid=Cj0KCQjwwZDFBhCpARIsAB95qO1D6e_tNtbHdBsf899yk7RZLdhO3-PIUDZhlHRgp19F6Jf4bOPqYBgaAl6XEALw_wcB#color_code=Olive&size_legacy=One+Size I have the msr elixir 3 for rainy weather or when camping with a friend. Here’s the elixer 2 if you can stretch your budget; https://www.cotswoldoutdoor.com/p/msr-elixir-2-tent-D1314062.html?colour=98&utm_source=google&utm_medium=ad-set-clearance&utm_campaign=CWO-PPM-UK-CLEARANCE-ASSET-GROUP&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=19716304771&gbraid=0AAAAAD7-iQBGMIjRwCxBq5hgeTivPiG1t&gclid=Cj0KCQjwwZDFBhCpARIsAB95qO2HzWU_jsvqV58MoU6Jc8_onkFhdqfl2HD5MsKasYNNzxPHvxivuswaAk9nEALw_wcB
Hmm. I just got the msr elixir 2 and it’s been great. I live in Cambodia but used it in the Himalayan foothills. So it’s been great for higher altitude between 3000m to 4000m as well as the humid climates of south east Asia.
Your tent alone is 17 kg. The way you are describing it now you'd be carrying much much more than feasible, or have you walk twice. I would go for several smaller tents, with a tarp in the middle for a living room. You'd be more flexible, also in finding flat spaces, can change one tent when the kids are growing, and it would be lighter. Look at secondhand msr elixir, for instance, 2 and 3p, you'd be looking at around 9 kg for three tents, add a tarp (and groundsheet) for 2 more, and the price would be similar.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Backpacking

Top pick
Durston - X-Mid 2
Best for Beginner camping

Top pick
Gazelle Tents - T4 Hub Tent Series
Best for Comfort-focused car camping

Top pick
Gazelle Tents - T4 Hub Tent Series
Best for Hot and humid weather camping

Top pick
Durston - X-Mid 2
Best for Rain and wind

Top pick
The North Face - Wawona 6
Best for Snow and wind

Top pick
SlingFin - Portal 2





