Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#747 in

Camping Tents

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score60% positive
3
1
1
Last updated: Jun 24, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconBobcattrr
5 months ago

Sierra Trading is a good outdoor equipment store that sells last years models etc. I found The North Face Tadpole SL2 that is $300, looks to be excellent. Yes, 2 person is my minimum, allows me to keep my sleeping bag away from condensation when that happens, keep pack and shoes inside + your wet coat when it’s pouring. I suggest you start at federal or state campground with hiking that give you a “home base” to come back to. Go for a couple nights, you will quickly learn what makes sense for you, plus it’s not likely to ruin it so bad you give up. Get a warmer sleeping bag than you expect is my other beginning advice.

Reddit IconConfident-Shake-4684
7 months ago

For about 15 years this North Face Tadpole has been my main tent for backpacking. It’s insanely stable and dry in a storm, it’s perfect for a one- or two-nighter with my son, and it has a lot of sentimental value to me. (I’ve repaired the pole and re-sealed the tent since this photo was taken) For trips with my son or for bad weather trips, it will remain my go-to tent until it falls apart. But it’s also pretty heavy, at ~5+ lbs. I’m looking for a tent that would make for a good, lightweight option for when I want to cover some ground solo, something I can toss in a small pack with a lightweight setup for summer backpacking when I’m trying to keep mileage up and weight down. Is there anything that fits the bill for: -under $250 (not opposed to a used tent) -semi-freestanding -large 1p or small 2p -under 3lbs -not reliant on trekking poles (I don’t often use them) -good weather resistance is a plus but not a requirement

Reddit IconF00TS0re
23 days ago

I have an MSR Hubba Hubba Bike pack that’s is inner first pitching. Before that I had a North Face tadpole, again inner first pitch. And before that another TNF Tadpole. Right back to about 1993. I have hundreds of night camping on trails and the number of times it’s rained heavily when pitching is tiny. A bit of mild drizzle isn’t an issue as you can put them up in a coupe of minutes. Poles ready, fly ready, inner out, poles in, fly over top is a couple of minutes. Then peg it out. Ok I might sometimes pitch a bit earlier or later dependant on the weather. Sometimes I’m at a campsite and can pitch under shelter or nearby tree and then move it as both were free standing. I then pack inner/outer separately the next day if it’s raining and dry fly when I get a chance.

Reddit Icongroundfaller
7 months ago

I backpacked with a Tadpole for many years. I mostly really loved the tent. It was super stable and sturdy. I swapped it out for an MSR Hubba Hubba over 10 years ago. Modern tents are lighter but a lot more expensive. I thought the Hubba Hubba wouldn't last....yet it has. The tent material is going strong. The lighter weight poles have taken a beating in some very strong winds. It is still super functional if only a little differently shaped than when I first bought it. I think the weight savings of most quality modern tents is a huge upgrade...if your pockets are deep enough. Gear comes with some pretty big sticker shock these days. It may not be light, but some days I miss the old army surplus stores that were once a staple for backpacking. That is until I heft my current much much much lighter pack.

Reddit Iconjaxnmarko
10 months ago

My Durston is light and roomy. I started in the 60s. Paring it down isn't easy and sometimes means saying goodbye to old gear friends. I like my Featherstone Granite II, for a self-standing. My first of my own was a Eureka Timberline, the old Boy Scouts tent. NOT light. Somewhat claustrophobic. Much depends on how big you are. I used a Northface Tadpole for a while too.

about 2 months ago

6. Big old REI that is awesome and roomy, Moss Triton beauty bomber of a tent, Durston x-mid 2, old reliable Kelty X frame, Featherstone Granite 2P- lotsa mesh, OneTigris Backwoods Bungalow 1st version. Gone are: Gave my NF Tadpole to my son in law. Great tent but too small. Old Eureka Timberline passed away after a long life. A dome melted by a careless friend. A stolen Kelty Cricket tadpole design.

Reddit IconRoyal_Link_7967
7 months ago

I just bought my 3rd tadpole 23. It’s been my little sanctuary in so many foreign places. I had to eBay the last one and it was listed as “vintage”. wtf. I still haven’t fallen in love with anything else in that genre. The did just come out with a single wall tadpole that’s very light, comparatively

Top Camping Tents on Reddit

1
The North Face Wawona 6

The North Face

Wawona 6

85% positive of 133 users

Spacious vestibule, strong in storms, but rainfly tricky solo.

2
Gazelle Tents T4 Hub Tent Series

Gazelle Tents

T4 Hub Tent Series

88% positive of 144 users

Fastest setup, durable, but bulky and awkward door.

3
Durston X-Mid 2

Durston

X-Mid 2

83% positive of 149 users

Ultralight, spacious 2P, but not for very strong winds.

4
Durston X-Mid 1

Durston

X-Mid 1

81% positive of 108 users

Budget ultralight 1P, spacious, but large footprint.

5
Naturehike Mongar 2 Backpack Tent (Nylon)

Naturehike

Mongar 2 Backpack Tent (Nylon)

89% positive of 72 users

Budget 2P, spacious for price, but not for 4 seasons.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs