Mr. Coffee

12 Cup Simple Brew Coffee Maker

Mr. Coffee 12 Cup Simple Brew Coffee Maker

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#52 in

Drip Coffee Makers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score71% positive
5
1
1
Last updated: Jun 20, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconflyingfish_trash
9 months ago

I’ve had the cheapest, simplest Mr Coffee one button coffee maker for 14 years now. It works as it should, it’s lasted a long time, it was like 20 dollars. Looks like it’s still between $22-$30. Probably can’t go wrong with any one button/switch 12 cup brewer but the cheap option is genuinely a good option. Ninja, OXO, plenty of other decent names. She definitely doesn’t need a $230 moccamaster if she isn’t already grinding fresh beans and worried about specific water temp and optimal extraction.

Reddit IconOutinDaBarn
6 months ago

You really can't beat a good simple Mr. Coffee. I currently have a [Ninja](https://www.walmart.com/ip/Ninja-12-Cup-Programmable-Coffee-Maker-Glass-Carafe-Stainless-Steel-CE250/997508948?wl13=1955&selectedSellerId=0&wmlspartner=wlpa) it has a dial for how much coffee you want and 2 buttons to make it run,

Reddit IconGoinStraightToHell
3 months ago

Mocha Master if you want to spend the money on a good cup of coffee. Standard Mr Coffee if you want a good daily driver.

Reddit Iconadriellee
7 months ago

I used a Mr Coffee 12 cup for years and it broke on me the other day. I ended up buying a Ninja Dual Brew for $100. It’s awesome, I love it. You can make a full pot of coffee or you can use the single cup function (Keurig style). I bought a reusable k cup so I’m not wasting plastic and I can use my own fancy beans. I mostly make one cup at a time - it brews the coffee so fast and it’s so good! You can also just have it brew hot water for tea super fast.

Reddit IconBeWonderfulBeDope
9 months ago

Ditto Mr Coffee 12 cup is going strong 4yrs later

Reddit IconGingerSnap_123
7 months ago

We have had the absolute cheapest Mr Coffee drip 12 cup pot for 7+ years. I keep saying I’m going to upgrade us to something fancier when it breaks, but it’s too simple to break!

Top Drip Coffee Makers on Reddit

1
Moccamaster (Technivorm) KB Series

Moccamaster (Technivorm)

KB Series

83% positive of 792 users

Durable, repairable, excellent coffee; pricey, lacks timer.

$311 onwards Amazon
2
Moccamaster (Technivorm) CD Series

Moccamaster (Technivorm)

CD Series

85% positive of 130 users

Durable, simple, great coffee; pricey, fragile carafe pours poorly.

$381 onwards Amazon
3
Moccamaster (Technivorm) Cup-One

Moccamaster (Technivorm)

Cup-One

81% positive of 125 users

Durable, easy, great single-cup coffee; pricey for value.

$172 Amazon
4
Moccamaster (Technivorm) GCS

Moccamaster (Technivorm)

GCS

85% positive of 67 users

SCA-certified, extremely durable; pricey, fragile parts, uneven spray.

$359 Amazon
5
Fellow Aiden Precision Coffee Maker

Fellow

Aiden Precision Coffee Maker

79% positive of 107 users

Versatile, customizable, smart; but unreliable, flimsy, unintuitive.

$319 Amazon

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs