Mr. Coffee

12 Cup Simple Brew Coffee Maker

Mr. Coffee 12 Cup Simple Brew Coffee Maker

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#44 in

Drip Coffee Makers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score67% positive
4
1
1
Last updated: Apr 20, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconflyingfish_trash
7 months ago

I’ve had the cheapest, simplest Mr Coffee one button coffee maker for 14 years now. It works as it should, it’s lasted a long time, it was like 20 dollars. Looks like it’s still between $22-$30. Probably can’t go wrong with any one button/switch 12 cup brewer but the cheap option is genuinely a good option. Ninja, OXO, plenty of other decent names. She definitely doesn’t need a $230 moccamaster if she isn’t already grinding fresh beans and worried about specific water temp and optimal extraction.

Reddit IconOutinDaBarn
4 months ago

You really can't beat a good simple Mr. Coffee. I currently have a [Ninja](https://www.walmart.com/ip/Ninja-12-Cup-Programmable-Coffee-Maker-Glass-Carafe-Stainless-Steel-CE250/997508948?wl13=1955&selectedSellerId=0&wmlspartner=wlpa) it has a dial for how much coffee you want and 2 buttons to make it run,

Reddit Iconadriellee
5 months ago

I used a Mr Coffee 12 cup for years and it broke on me the other day. I ended up buying a Ninja Dual Brew for $100. It’s awesome, I love it. You can make a full pot of coffee or you can use the single cup function (Keurig style). I bought a reusable k cup so I’m not wasting plastic and I can use my own fancy beans. I mostly make one cup at a time - it brews the coffee so fast and it’s so good! You can also just have it brew hot water for tea super fast.

Reddit IconBeWonderfulBeDope
7 months ago

Ditto Mr Coffee 12 cup is going strong 4yrs later

Reddit IconGingerSnap_123
5 months ago

We have had the absolute cheapest Mr Coffee drip 12 cup pot for 7+ years. I keep saying I’m going to upgrade us to something fancier when it breaks, but it’s too simple to break!

Reddit IconGorov
3 months ago

Mr. Coffee 12 cup coffee maker at Walmart. $25. Simple electeic grinder. $15. Filters. $3. Buy whole bean coffee and grind when ready to make coffee. Explore different beans and roasts. Enjoy. I've done French press, pour over, espresso... Mr. Coffee wins for ease and gets used every day. If you have an Aldi nearby, Honduras whole bean organic coffee. Thank me later. It is my go-to.

Reddit Iconlookintouk
7 months ago

A classic drip coffee maker like the Mr Coffee 12-Cup or Technivorm Moccamaster, both simple, one-button, no-frills, and make excellent black coffee that’ll last for years.

Reddit Iconsupergrl126301
7 months ago

am I the only one with a 15 yr old $30 Mr Coffee ?? My parents have one thats now close to 30 yrs old.

6 months ago

it could the thing where it WAS made better, but now its garbage. its the 5 of 6 cup one i have and my parents have the 12??? idk its huge.

Other Reddit Recommendations: