
Segway
Ninebot Max G3
Hill climbing beast, durable, but heavy with limited range.
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
It has 9.5 inch tubeless tires...not the crappy solid tires. The thing weighs 26 pounds and goes 20mph. This is the final boss of last mile scooters. Its not a parts bin though so it costs a little more...Black Friday deals are coming though.
I have a NIU Kqi Air, which works fine for me, but I also only weigh 120 with gear. Mostly I ride from Caltrain to the Union Square area, so no really crazy hills. But it’s absolutely sufficient for what I want it to do.
I just got the NIU Air from Best Buy. I would highly recommend going this route based on what you have described as your use case. Should get 15 - 20 miles for an avg sized individual. I really like it. Had a few issues getting it set up but chatgpt walked me through getting my Bluetooth set up. No issues in my first week and am very impressed with how light it is. Don't wait, you can always test it out and return. I don't think you'll find anything as good for 600. I looked but all other options had more compromises (mainly solid tires which I am not a fan of).
The problems people have with it ( and apparently Niu scooters in general) with regards to the Anti Theft system being something you CANNOT disable, and constantly causing annoyances when you move it, are what stopped me from buying. Like, holy shit, who makes a scooter you can take with you, but you have to constantly keep it on or else it puts on a light show even when the alarm is muted when you nudge it funny? Did nobody actually use one IRL? The numbers SOUND great, but someone on their managerial team who said "YEP THATS FINE SHIP IT" needs to be slapped with reality.
I would assume the ratings are low because it’s $1000 and it has the same specs as a $450 scooter. It’s not a bad scooter, I owned a KQi3 Pro for 1000 miles and it was great. I didn’t need the extra light weight because it was just kept in my garage and didn’t need to be lifted almost ever. If you are looking for something specifically to be carried then the KQi Air is a great choice, at 26lbs I don’t think there is a single other scooter than even competes with its performance at that weight. If you aren’t concerned with price to get what you want, then get the Air. Gotrax is a trash company so I would avoid them at all cost.
Yes, but as far as I’m concerned, **weight is a spec**. You might not care about it, but it’s still a spec. If you buy a bike, you can easily pay twice as much just to save 1 kg, so I don’t see why it should be any different for a scooter. That’s why, in my opinion, it really deserves a super positive rating. Of course, someone else might prefer speed, power or other specs—but those can also be irrelevant depending on the use case. For example, what’s the point of extra power if you live in a country where the law limits you to 20 km/h, and in a flat city where there aren’t even any hills? The only Air real drawback, in my view, is that people who look for light weight usually also care about portability—for instance, if they take the train/metro and bring the scooter along. The Air is easy to carry, but in a crowded train it’s still bulky. Same thing if you go on holiday by car: it takes up a lot of space in the trunk. The situation could already improve a lot if they made a version with a foldable handlebar (that is very large). Let’s see what happens in version 2.
I actually own both the Air and an E-Twow. In every respect I find the Air better: comfort, safety, braking; plus it has a much stronger light which is really useful for riding at night, and the turn signals are a big help too. The E-Twow, however, has one huge drawback: the solid tires. Sure, they protect you from flats, but they slip on wet asphalt like a bar of soap. That said, the E-Twow does keep one real advantage: it’s much smaller (deck, wheels, but especially the foldable handlebar). Both are light enough to carry up to a third floor, so that’s not really an issue. But you really notice the size difference if you plan to use the train (or subway): you can put the E-Twow under a seat or in the luggage rack, while with the Air on a crowded subway… good luck. Same thing if you go to a restaurant – the E-Twow fits discreetly under a table. I’ve even taken it into places where scooters aren’t usually allowed, just by using its folding carrying bag: it looks like a sports bag, and nobody complains. Same story when traveling by car – the Air takes up the whole trunk. That’s why, after buying the Air, I didn’t sell the E-Twow. I use the Air 95% of the time, but that remaining 5% (when I need to take a train) I prefer the E-Twow… just hoping it doesn’t rain.

Segway
Ninebot Max G3
Hill climbing beast, durable, but heavy with limited range.

Ausom
DT2 Pro
Budget-friendly speed demon with hydraulic brakes, but quiet horn.

Inmotion
Climber
Budget hill climber for heavy riders, but no suspension or strong brakes.

Segway
Ninebot KickScooter MAX G30P
Durable, moddable commuter for value, but lacks suspension and heavy.

Segway
E3 Pro
Lightweight, stable ride for heavy riders, but awkward folding.

Ranked #1
Inmotion - Climber

Ranked #1
Inmotion - Climber

Ranked #1
NIU - KQi Air

Ranked #1
Segway - GT3 Pro

Ranked #1
Segway - ZT3 Pro

Ranked #1
Segway - Ninebot KickScooter MAX G30P