
Breville
Bambino Plus
Fast heat-up, easy for beginners; inconsistent shots, annoying cleaning.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
If you go with a Jura, make sure you do a bit of research before buying. As an espresso/black coffee drinker, I love my ENA 4, but it only doses 10g of coffee at maximum strength, which is a fair bit less than your traditional espresso (and definitely not enough for the long/coffee option). I pull a double shot and make my own Americanos to get the best tasting drink.
For fully automatic, Jura ENA 4 (it will be above your budget). For semi-automatic, Breville (or Sage in Europe) Bambino - just ignore the fact that it has a steam wand. Pair it with Baratza ESP or DF54 grinder. If that busts your budget, get a Kingrinder K6 hand grinder. For fully manual, one of the Flair machines or Cafelat Robot.
I have jura ena 4 and its been loyal for 4 years now, couldn't be happier with the coffee quality, but im just a casual when it comes to coffee.
Jura ENA4 as a present from my job. I use it daily and my Nespresso has sit idle since.
If you're mostly a black coffee - Americano lover with the occasional milk drink then get a Jura Ena or Jura E4. I have similar coffee drinking habits as you and I went with the Jura E4. Its a coffee only machine, but the quality is great and it was reasonable. I think $1400. Also I decided on a coffee only super automatic because the long term maitenance will most likely be less than a machine that will do milk drinks. Get a seperate milk frother like I did and you will be happy. Oh and I make my own batch of cold brew coffee once per week separately to keep in the fridge 😉 It works out great. Good luck.
Both are fine. Consider if you want something with an automatic milk frother, or a steam wand. Other good choices: Jura Ena, Delonghi Eletta or Rivelia. And congrats, super autos are big step up from coffee pods taste wise. And much cheaper in use.

Breville
Bambino Plus
Fast heat-up, easy for beginners; inconsistent shots, annoying cleaning.

Cafelat
Robot Series
Manual, durable, exceptional espresso; no milk, effort for multiple shots.

Gaggia
Classic Pro E24
Mod-friendly workhorse, great espresso with mods; weak steam, poor temp.

Lelit
Bianca
Precise flow control, dual boiler; long heat-up, average build quality.

DeLonghi
Stilosa Series
Budget-friendly, moddable; flimsy build, needs upgrades for good espresso.

Ranked #1
Breville - Bambino Plus

Ranked #1
ECM - Synchronika II

Ranked #1
Lelit - Bianca

Ranked #1
Gaggia - Classic Pro E24

Ranked #1
Breville - Bambino Plus

Ranked #1
Breville - Bambino Plus