Apple

Watch Series 1

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#39 in

Fitness Trackers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score45% positive
10
5
7

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Oct 15, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconcisco1971m
10 months ago

I have iPhone and had Apple Watches from the beginning. Apple Watch 1, Apple Watch 6 and just got Apple 11 for Christmas. I have ran 4 marathons with them no problems and training with the free Nike Run Club app on my iPhone. Has real Olympic coaches for the training programs.

Reddit IconMaterial-Spare-6791
9 months ago

Went from Apple watch 1 then 3 then SE 2nd gen to Garmin to Balance 2 XT. The XT is the best watch for me. I'm not an exercise nut, but I walk, cycle some and and indoor row. I'm more interested in health metrics. The Balance 2 XT gives me real time HR, SPO2, steps all in real time on the watch face. Apple cannot do that. And then there's the excellent battery life, 8-10 days with everything on (no AOD) 24/7.

Reddit IconOk-Profession5286
8 months ago

Well, it’s two really good watches. For me Garmin wins because - Battery life - Round watch - Flashlight - Better variation of watchfaces - Looks (in my eyes) Apple Watch wins in terms of smart watch and integrations with iPhone but for me Garmin is good enough.

8 months ago

Maybe for some but for me it was more or less the same. Been using AW1 and AW 2 beside my Fenix when I was trying to move over to AW but I didn’t see any big difference between them. I kept my Garmin anyway

Reddit Iconbbcjbb
8 months ago

I have the smaller Apple Watch and bought a thin silver band on Amazon that looks like a ‘normal’ watch. It has removable links and everything so I was able to get it to fit perfectly. Most people don’t even realize I’m wearing an Apple Watch! I like that it has features unrelated to fitness that sync with my phone also

8 months ago

Mine is a 38mm size, I think it’s available in most models. [This is the band I wear most of the time](https://a.co/d/0aBfzyYA) and I [got this one for working out](https://a.co/d/007ytIiE) since it’s slimmer than what came with my watch

9 months ago

I love the Apple Watch because it’s so seamless with my phone and I love the competition/social aspect of it. It really helps me and my friends stay accountable

Reddit IconNextSuggestion7200
12 months ago

I bought the aw1 till aw7 because I startet running I bought the forerunner 165, the battery life was cool, the body battery and hfv was very interesting so I upgraded to forerunner 570 this year… but the point is, statics like body battery etc is more or less just a rough calculation and drives me crazy sometimes :D so I think I will go back to aw some days

Reddit IconTheBuenasTardes
10 months ago

Had AW 1 thru 7. Switched to Epix Gen 2 for a few years then Fenix 8. And did try the AW Ultra and Ultra 2 but sent those back. Garmin has been SO much better for battery, fitness tracking (running, cycling, etc) and not worrying about the battery while doing so. Super durable. And the flashlight on the 51mm. Chef’s kiss. I do miss *some* of the Apple integration but won’t be going back soon.

Top Fitness Trackers on Reddit

1
Garmin Forerunner 255 Series

Garmin

Forerunner 255 Series

86% positive of 466 users

Long battery; but wrist HR tracking is inconsistent.

2
Garmin Forerunner 955 Series

Garmin

Forerunner 955 Series

78% positive of 353 users

Best value, clear MIP screen; limited smartwatch features.

3
Garmin Fenix 7 Series

Garmin

Fenix 7 Series

71% positive of 691 users

Durable, multi-week battery, flashlight; high price, buggy software.

4
Garmin Instinct 2 Series

Garmin

Instinct 2 Series

83% positive of 276 users

Rugged, solar multi-week battery; bulky, small screen readability issues.

5
Garmin Enduro 3

Garmin

Enduro 3

83% positive of 243 users

Multi-week solar battery, lightweight; but bulky form factor.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs