Apple

Watch Series 4

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#39 in

Fitness Trackers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score43% positive
23
11
20

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Oct 17, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconAmazing_Raisin2836
8 months ago

Honestly, if you are an iPhone user a used old applewatch (like series 4 or 5) is extremely good value for the money. And you don’t have any subscriptions or anything like that

Reddit Iconanonymouse_213
11 months ago

Battery life was a no brainer for me. My old Apple watch series 4 provided me with all the stuff I need but at its best, it only gave me 2 days of battery. Maybe not even. My garmin FR165 slaps. Lasting 8-10 days in 1 charge.

Reddit IconArticleHaunting3983
10 months ago

I have a stainless steel S4 that I bought on release. It’s generally ok for fitness tracking but otherwise showing its age. Is now the right time to upgrade, or do I hold out for the 2026 releases in the hopes it will be special? I’m not in a rush to upgrade, and whilst the cost isn’t an issue per se, I just find the current watches to be really similar to my old one, doesn’t really seem to be a stand out feature I’m missing out on? And the watch body largely looks the same?

Reddit Iconatomicsf
10 months ago

Well I’m on the fence between an AWU3 or a Suunto. Connectivity or none. Have had an AW4 that is now dying. Need one for some smart features and running. For me Garmin 970 or Fenix Pro 8 may be overkill. And I am pretty deep in the Apple ecosystem although I am coming to dislike how everything is dumbed down and also too much. I run on trails a few times a week that lack cell connection so the AWU3 and its SOS features seem important although I question if we’ve been “sold” on safety.

Reddit IconBurnTheeFern
7 months ago

I’ve been using an Apple Watch Series 4 for several years now, and it’s definitely time for an upgrade. The biggest issue being its battery life as it’s gotten to the point where it sometimes dies during my evening runs or even before I head out. Lately, I’ve been getting back into running more consistently, so I’ve been tracking my workouts and paying closer attention to my health and fitness data. Because of that, I want something reliable that can keep up. Before I automatically go out and buy the latest Apple Watch, I wanted to get some input. Would my money be better spent on a different watch? For those of you who run regularly, what watch do you use for both workouts and everyday wear? Are there features you’ve found that work better than what Apple offers? I’ve heard good things about Garmin, but I haven’t looked into them much yet. Open to any recommendations or insights!

Reddit Iconchuckfinley79
7 months ago

Apple Watch Ultra 2 maybe? I don’t know I wore my Apple Watch 4 for years til it got to the point it wouldn’t hold a charge for a whole 24. No problems with them with a glass screen protector and a case with a bumper. I have taken it off before on dirty traumas where I knew things might get messy.

Top Fitness Trackers on Reddit

1
Garmin Forerunner 255 Series

Garmin

Forerunner 255 Series

86% positive of 466 users

Long battery; but wrist HR tracking is inconsistent.

2
Garmin Forerunner 955 Series

Garmin

Forerunner 955 Series

78% positive of 353 users

Best value, clear MIP screen; limited smartwatch features.

3
Garmin Fenix 7 Series

Garmin

Fenix 7 Series

71% positive of 691 users

Durable, multi-week battery, flashlight; high price, buggy software.

4
Garmin Instinct 2 Series

Garmin

Instinct 2 Series

83% positive of 276 users

Rugged, solar multi-week battery; bulky, small screen readability issues.

5
Garmin Enduro 3

Garmin

Enduro 3

83% positive of 243 users

Multi-week solar battery, lightweight; but bulky form factor.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs