Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Top Pros
Top Cons
Reddit Reviews
I just got the Quatix 8 in 47mm and it has all of your required features, plus I think its the best looking Garmin right now. Battery lasts 15 days on a charge. love it. https://preview.redd.it/tlszgqfe13gg1.jpeg?width=1848&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5278ea2b3202bb61f1c1f330b6fdee57f69f1467
I'd suggest creating a list of features in your AWU that you can't live without, then seeing if Garmin can support it. This will help you decide if you'll be ok with the tradeoffs and also potentially help you assess what you truly "need" out of a watch. I would also assess the features on the Garmin watch you're interested in, and see how that compares with the AWU. You may end up with things you "need" or really want that the AWU doesn't have (e.g., battery life or flashlight). Afterwards, assess your tradeoffs both ways. You might find one is missing more than the other, or one is missing more important things to you. I got the F8 (AMOLED 47mm) recently and now I don't know how I was even surviving with only the 9 days on my F6S before this! I forget the last time I even charged it. The flashlight has also been very helpful for random things. Also, I would recommend sticking with an AMOLED display, I think you'll be very underwhelmed with a MIP one coming from your AWU.
I just went from a Fenix 6s to a Fenix 8, and I'm really glad I upgraded screens from MIP to AMOLED (along with size to 47mm). Not as important to everyone, but I think it's something worth comparing and considering.
Ich habe mir die Fenix 8 Amoled Titanum Sapphire 47mm direkt nach dem Launch gekauft und bin bis heute super glücklich, von der Fenix 7 gewechselt zu sein. Im Allways on-Modus hält der Akku nach wie vor 7 Tage. Ich habe täglich mindestens eine Aktivität mit GPS-Nutzung und per Bluetooth gekoppelten Sensoren und Kopfhörern. In den ersten Monaten gab es noch erhebliche Softwareprobleme. Die sind aber soweit ausgeräumt. Ich kann sie dir nur wärmstens empfehlen. Auch im Sonnenlicht hatte ich noch nie Ableseprobleme. Die Karten sind deutlich besser als bei der MIP-Version. Und ich hätte nie gedacht, wie oft ich die eingebaute Taschenlampe nutze.
You and I are/were in the same spot. I got my AMOLED 47mm Titanium black DLC, a week or so ago from the same deal. I have not owned a watch in like decades but I love this watch and wish I had picked one up years ago, it really helps you if you are trying to get fitter. Its a lot of money so here is my opinion and hope it helps you: In terms of sizing, I believe the 47 and 51 have the same display size, so the only thing bigger about the 51 is weight, **battery** and bezel. I think most reviewers say the bigger watch gets you a day or 2 more battery than on the AMOLED. From your pictures, I have a slightly larger wrist than you, personally in terms of looks the 47 looks better on anyone with average wrist size like us. You'd really have to think about how much you prefer the MIP battery life for extremely long outdoor useage of if you want to charge your watch once a month (mine lasts about a week with AOD on). From what I've seen from reviews the battery on AMOLED version is more than sufficient for marathon/triathlons. In terms of the screen, my coworker has an instinct solar, its definitely not an ugly display but its also not comparable to any AMOLED from any manufacturer including the Garmin AMOLED version. I've been outside on walks/runs with my Fenix 8 and I've not been in any condition where I had trouble reading the AMOLED screen. Conversely, my coworker has a MIP Garmin and its definitely not as easily viewed in our office setting but its not as if you can't read it, its just not as easy to glance at in certain lighting conditions without the backlight. Weight is something you also should think about. The larger displays and the Solar in terms of specs are heavier which some people are sensitive to. I'm personally not. I saw a ton of reviewers say the weight of the Fenix is noticeable at night when sleeping compared to something like a Vivoactive, Venu or Forerunner. Personally, this is my first watch (smart, fitness) in decades and I can't tell the difference between this and the Vivoactive. I think the weight sensitivity is contingent to where you wear it, the closer to the wrist the more you feel the weight. There is also the nylon band option if the weight really bothers you.
Ya. The only thing that’s kept me in the garmin ecosystem (Fenix 3,5,8) is the battery life and simplicity. I weighed out my last purchase of the 47mm fenix 8 AMOLED vs the Apple Watch Ultra and literally the only thing that made me buy the 8 was the battery life, it was more expensive and had less features. Honestly though, it will be my last. They’re creeping up into the bottom end of quality Swiss watch range, I have a handful of nice mechanical watches that have all went up in value as I’ve owned them. I know it’s not the same thing but I’m not buying a 2k watch every 3 years where the old one is going to become a paperweight after 6-7 years
With no gps activity and stock watch face I get 20-22 days on my fenix 8 47 mm AMOLED. Always on display is off. With 2h gps activity every day I get about 7-9 days
I went from Apple Watch to Garmin fenix 8 few months ago. Honestly Garmin motivates me more to be active, over all Garmin is better, it looks like a watch, you can use it as a watch only and battery holds for long time.
I swapped from Apple Watch to fenix 8 bit over a month ago. If you were using Apple Watch Ultra like me fenix 8 47mm is only 9 grams heavier, and honestly I did not notice this difference. But all is personal preference. If you really need the diving option then take fenix, but if you can live without it then go for FR. Garmin watches are million times better than Apple so whatever you decide for sure you will be happy.
970 is lighter but still faces lots of software issues. I went through 3 in 5 weeks because of issues. The Fenix is bigger and heavier. I don’t love the new buttons on it either. Both have drawbacks, I’d say it’s more personal preference of the two designs.
Comes down to personal preference, really. I had a Fenix 8 for months, then switched to the 970. Prefer the weight of the 970 for daily usage.
Fenix 8 47 amoled safire. Because it was the same price as the 970 and I wanted maps.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Chronic health condition management

Top pick
Oura - Oura Ring Series
Best for Elderly & emergency safety

Top pick
Apple - Ultra Series
Best for Extended battery life

Top pick
Garmin - Fenix 7 Series
Best for Rugged durability for extreme environments

Top pick
Garmin - Fenix 7 Series
Best for Running performance & coaching

Top pick
Garmin - Forerunner 255 Series
Best for Sleep quality tracking

Top pick
Oura - Oura Ring Series





