
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Reddit Reviews
I'm a smallish dude, new to running. I just got the 165 Music last week so i can go on runs without my phone. So far, I absolutely love it - it does everything I need and far more. And I'm the kind of guy who reads (and did read) the manual cover to cover and watched tons of videos so I really get the most of out it. It's my first smart watch that I've not hated within hours (I just needed to turn off the message notifications). I didn't think I'd sleep with it but I've got 4 nights under the belt and am gelling with it, as long as I set it to sleep mode with the touchscreen off, and loosen the band a notch. I wanted it mainly for podcasts while running without the phone. Just be aware that there are only a few options for podcasts that I found with services I own or are free. Spotify works OK, but inserts more ads and you can't bulk download a playlist of podcasts. Youtube Music is better without the extra ads, but you can't download a playlist of podcasts. The best I've found that's free is [PlayRun.App](http://PlayRun.App), you just need to manage it a little manually but you can download a list, no extra ads. The other downside of podcasts on Garmin though is you are stuck listening at 1x speed (I'm a 2x or 2.5x guy). I am getting used to it, but there's a paid subscription podcast option for Garmin that lets you speed them up before uploading, I'm just too cheap for it. Anyway, the solution works, and music of course works fine though storage is limited, especially if you have a lot of podcasts. If you want a good "lower end" Garmin, the 165 is pretty great.
I just upgraded from a forerunner 55 to a forerunner 970 (bday present to myself). I’ve had an Apple Watch. My opinion is if you want barebones and dont mind running with your phone if you need music, a forerunner 55 is good enough. If you want good enough + music, forerunner 165 Music. There are a number of good comparisons online. I got a 970 because I wanted a fancy one. I love it but it does provide some redundant metrics to whoop that dampen the impact whoop has for me
I had an older generation Vivoactive and purchased the 165 music when it came out. The running features and metrics are worth it alone, but I also like the physical buttons. I looked at the 265 and 965 as well but the advanced metrics and better heart rate sensor wasn’t worth it for my needs, and I use a heart rate strap anyways.
As a counter point, I got the FR 165 Music for run tracking only. I don't really care about any of the advanced metrics or analysis. I just want to track the basics like distance, pace, and sometimes heart rate. I like the spotify support and custom workouts I can build using Connect. It does everything I need and I don't regret not getting the 265.
Honestly just get the 265 or 265s. I got the FR165 music and wish I’d just paid more for the 265 because I want to do a triathalon next year.
I "upgraded" from a 745 to a 165 and don't regret it at all. While I lost a couple features it was never anything that I really used or care about. The only thing about the 165 is that you need to make sure you buy the music version not the standard version
FWIW I'm primarily a cyclist (though I did get back into running since buying my Garmin watch), and I really love my forerunner 165 music. It's not the bottom of the line, but it's definitely not their top offering. The forerunner is only $250. Maybe you've already got a cycling computer, but if not it's super handy being able to track rides on your watch with the click of a button. Like that it includes heart rate info too.
I have the 165 music…It does everything you list except for control Strava/nike run club (or maybe it does and I just don’t use that…I use Runna and the workouts automatically sync to the watch and Garmin guides me through my workouts).
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Chronic health condition management

Top pick
Oura - Oura Ring Series
Best for Elderly & emergency safety

Top pick
Apple - Ultra Series
Best for Extended battery life

Top pick
Garmin - Fenix 7 Series
Best for Rugged durability for extreme environments

Top pick
Garmin - Fenix 7 Series
Best for Running performance & coaching

Top pick
Garmin - Forerunner 255 Series
Best for Sleep quality tracking

Top pick
Oura - Oura Ring Series





