Garmin

Forerunner 910XT

Garmin Forerunner 910XT

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#208 in

Fitness Trackers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score63% positive
5
1
2

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Apr 29, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconecontrariety
5 months ago

I have a Garmin 945 that's going on 6 years, following a Garmin 910 that still worked when I retired it after 9 years. Right now the battery lasts ~6 days, down from ~2 weeks when I bought it. One button is starting to have intermittent contact issues.  On the water front, these are triathlon watches and are designed for swimming.  I have replaced each band once, and I use a quick-release leather band for daily wear and a quick-release silicon band for swimming.  My next one will probably be either the 955 or 970, once the button gives out.

Reddit IconFit-Cable1547
7 months ago

I don't know if there's a "correct" way, but I count the rest time in the same way I count the rest during a run, bike or strength workout--it's all part of the total time for the session. The older Garmins, like the 910x, used to just lap as a split where the newer ones from at least the 935 on switched to a rest with the lap button press which I always found annoying since you couldn't split a longer interval nicely that way without fumbling with a double tap. Ended up just using my 910xt for swimming to also help save the barometer in my 935 lol. As another commenter said, once I got the FORM goggles I didn't have to worry about that anymore. 😀

7 months ago

I don't know if there's a "correct" way, but I count the rest time in the same way I count the rest during a run, bike or strength workout--it's all part of the total time for the session. The older Garmins, like the 910x, used to just lap as a split where the newer ones from at least the 935 on switched to a rest with the lap button press which I always found annoying since you couldn't split a longer interval nicely that way without fumbling with a double tap. Ended up just using my 910xt for swimming to also help save the barometer in my 935 lol. As another commenter said, once I got the FORM goggles I didn't have to worry about that anymore. 😀

Reddit Iconjbm747
4 months ago

Was GARMIN for many years, starting with Forerunner 910XT and progressing to Fenix 5Pro Saphire. Did last Tri event in 2019 and ended up switching to AWU when it first was released. I have no regrets, if I ever go back to Tri will probably use another GARMIN for racing/training but keep AWU as daily driver.

Reddit Iconmypeez
9 months ago

Nice. Was going to ring in with my 910XT, but you win.

Reddit IconAdept_Spirit1753
2 months ago

You won't get "very accurate hr sensor" in any watch, they all use the same technology which has its own disadvantages. As long as I'm aware you can't program strength directly on any garmin watch.  Your best bet would be older fenix/epic/forerunner series 9

Reddit IconBlindusek
8 months ago

Fenix/Epix are the same, Forerunner 9xx has 99% same functions but a bit lighter and not as tall, but only available in one size

Reddit IconCafescrambler
8 months ago

Many of us have been here. Just get the best Garmin you can afford and you’ll never look back. I bought the EPIX 2, and love it, but the Forerunner 9xx series are probably the best bang for buck if you’re into fitness training.

Reddit Iconenjoyingthevibe
12 months ago

Ive bought a 9 series forerunner. Id come from an apple watch too, after the initial excitement of talking to it I just found it limited in functionality for sports. I'm very happy with the forerunner, itis not the Apple watch at all. It's excellent. I dont need any more if that helps.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: