Withings - ScanWatch 2

It's apples and oranges. I've had the Apple Watch for close to 8 years before switching to the ScanWatch 2 : yeah, there is more features on the Apple Watch but it's mostly for things I don't use (music, calls, texting, Siri). I burnedout of all this and just chose a watch that would still quantify things for me without the constant pings. And, of course, the battery life is night and day but you don't need me saying it. I don't run to the charger anymore, I don't dread long exercices because the watch wouldn't finish them. The only thing I miss a bit is the GPS : You have to have your phone awake for the location to register, you can't go run without it. Which, I wouldn't do, but I know some people like that.

Not a chance. Withings' last update completely broke mine and what is worse is they have zero customer service.

Omgosh I wish I could send you mine. I have a scan light 2 and love it but I’m allergic to the face and am upset that it’s not working for me.

I do, since it fits my needs perfectly. It has been a very solid, reliable watch that doesn’t overwhelm me with information or features. The battery lasts way longer than any smartwatch. The only watch with “smart-ish” functionalities that allows regular watch bands so I’m not dumping hundreds of dollars on lower quality proprietary bands. My experience with their support has been majorly positive.

I love it. Great battery life. ECG, HR, SPO2, Sleep and workout tracking. It's not perfect and neither is Withings but the company has the right vision and a great ecosystem. They were also recently awarded a €20.7 million grant (about $22.5 million USD) from the French govt to further develop their AI and ecosystem. I actually look forward to seeing where they're going to be at in 10 years. I can recommend it. I actually liked it more than I thought I would.

I'm not an Apple guy and I love my Scanwatch 2 but this strikes me as solid advice.

Same happening with me. Gave up and returned back to Apple Watch

It depends on your needs. The battery doesn't last the advertised 30 days, at least not with the features I want activated, but it still lasts around 2 weeks which is way more than anything else in the market. The fitness tracking isn't as good as other brands from the reviews I read but they're good enough for my needs (occasional light jogging). The screen is kind of too small for notifications but it's passable to know with a glance if it's worth taking the phone or off your pocket. The software is so-so. Not great but I rarely interact with it save for managing alarms and tracking workouts. In my opinion it's the best looking smart watch by far. I've gotten a lot of comments on it over the years, all positive.

Step counting is rather conservative (my experience vs Apple Watch), and sleep tracking does not differ between deep sleep and REM. Even with these limitations, I really love it for its battery life and design.

I have one, I like it, I recommend it, but I don’t trust it. Maybe my skinny wrists and dark skin throw it off. I’ve cross checked heart rate against fitness machines and an O2 Ring and it seems to lag and be way off during a workout but yet the overall answer is close enough to the other devices. So if you’re trying to do cardio at 135 beats per minute it seems inaccurate but if you’re ok with overall workout stats it seems ok. The sleep score is also odd. It seems to want a 50/50 deep and normal sleep even though the web claim 90-120 minutes is all you need. Tldr - i recommend it for casual use.

Yes, I love it. Battery life from 25-30 days 🤗

I’ve had my scan watch 2 for almost 2 years now. I’ve also had the Vivoactive right before I got this one. I like the Withings watch more because it looks classier/like a regular watch, the app is very user friendly, it tracks the basic health data I need (steps, sleep, HR), and the battery life lasts two weeks before I need to charge it. I can also track different workouts which is nice too. However, the watch stopped charging after a year and a half (luckily it was covered under their two year warranty). The Garmin watch app is very outdated. However, if you’re a hardcore athlete or like the nitty gritty raw data points, then Garmin is for you. I also like how the Vivoactive shows messages on watch face better than the Withings watch.

I got the Withings Scanwatch 2 to replace my Garmin and its been great as far as I needed it but if you want more smart I think Polar may be the best option

I switched from my garmin to a withings scanwatch 2 and its amazing, great battery life and it looks like a normal watch when the screen isn't on

I wish I didn't buy mine last year, it took a lot of fiddling to get the app to work (had to find an older version online) and it only charges properly 1/3 of the time with the official charger. Should have got an Apple watch or Samsung.

I would def go all in with my Withings scan 2 watch. The ONLY thing that annoys me is that there is no “find my phone” feature. My older Citizen CZ watch has this function… I even tried to wear both Apple watch and Withings watch at the same time for a bit, bc I liked seeing my rings close but that just felt weird since I type on a keyboard all day.

When the new Apple watch came out a month or so ago I kept seeing videos on how well the battery has improved giving you 42 hours or wear time. I get 42 days of wear time on my scanwatch 2 and still have battery life. I will never go with Apple for that reason alone.

Yes, if your priorities are fitness/health tracking and battery life. Personally, I also love the look of it.

I use mine as a heath tracker (sleep, steps, etc) and watch, no notifications or activity tracking of any kind, other than what it does on its own. Love it. It's as passive of a 'tracker' as it gets. And if you want to track those things, you got the choice.

If you want something stylish look at Withings. I have their smart watch which looks like a regular watch. I get so many compliments on it. I’ve had mine for 5 years and it out lasted all of my Fitbits. It was around $250 for watch face with rubber band, but I purchased a metal band for around $100. I

https://www.withings.com/us/en/

I'm using mine now for about 2 years I'd say and I'm very happy with it. I only really use the step/activity tracking and message notification feature. I like that I don't have to charge it each day, I usally charge it maybe once a month, if even. I travel a lot and only having to open the app once to have the time synchronized is also a nice feature. So for me it's a recommendation, but I don't use all of the features, so can't say anything about the full experience.

It is great for me. The vibration only alarm is something I use a lot. Run twice a week. My scale is a withings and all these devices feed data into my Apple health. I did enable a minimum of notifications, so it lasts almost 30 days. Their support is the best I had: they replaced my watch for free when it had an issue, 2 weeks before the end of warranty.

“One of my life partners “. — you have multiple? Lol. Ps I have the orig Steel HR, and am looking to upgrade to Scanwatch 2– ecg and black face

Yes I like the Steel HR. probly 5 yrs now. Was my daily watch till my sister in law gave me her husbands Rolex oyster after he died (age 80). Now I wear the Rolex on left, and a Fitbit charge 6 tracker on right. Dumb. So I just bought a new withings scanwatch 2 ($150 on eBay). I bought the black face Scanwatch 2. the black circle in the middle of the white face Steel HR was a little jarring visually. I’ll see if I can get used to a black face watch. Then I’ll probly rotate btw the Rolex and the Scanwatch 2.

Agreed. On balance I'm happy with mine. If you want something that has classic looks and can provide notifications without adding yet another screen to get addicted to, the Withings watches pretty much nail it. Sadly they won't last long enough to pass down to anyone, but then that goes for all smart watches.

Yes Been wearing mine since Dec 23. It's my all time favorite watch. white dial gray strap I switch between brown and black. Some people have lots of compliants about the app. I don't use the app much so less issues for me. My lady has one too Rose gold. We like them. It has a sophisticated mature look don't let the nay sayers stop you it's a great watch.

Not at all, at least on iOS notifications seem super buggy, they work a few times after starting the app and then stop. I’ve tried every fix under this heaven, not closing the app, reinstalling, factory reset etc. if someone knows a fix that works please tell me

Hi, I’ve had a Steel HR, a Scanwatch 1 38mm and a Scanwatch 2 Nova. Step counting is as good as my iPhone, when I have it in my pocket whole day. Sleep tracking is good enough for me. I use it mostly for design, battery, step counting and notifications. Notifications are my biggest need and here is my problem with it. I’m not sure to whether it depends but at some SW versions of the app/watch the notifications are not working. Then you have to wait 1-2 months until they release a version with given functionality. My problem is, I need the watch to get notified when calling/messaging from important persons (phone has to be quiet). So I love the design, the straps, the battery, but the issues with notifications let me think about a new Apple Watch.

I have Scanwatch 2 Nova and I love it. I look forward to the new smarter OS announced yesterday

The scan watches seem to do all they claim - I don't use most of them - but I wouldn't be buying another one, because the integrated battery cannot be replaced. It's advertised to take 500 charge cycles - which is all well and good but that's an almost meaningless metric - the charge capacity of the battery will very likely be a great deal less long before 500 cycles - like mine which gradually expired over 6 months outside the 2 year warrantee - the watch was still immaculate - but junk.

i tested it for 2 days and i concur

I have both. And I’d say, if you have an iPhone absolutely nothing compares to the Apple Watch with apple health for features. But you’ll have to charge it every day. On the flip side the scanwatch looks more ‘grown up’ and like a nice quality watch. And the battery lasts much longer, probably 2 weeks min for me. (With notifications and stuff) Both will record what you need. but I think if you go for an Apple Watch you would appreciate all the extra functions you get if you use it with an iPhone, like Apple Pay, Apple Watch music, make calls, all the additional apps and customisable watch faces etc. Hope that’s helpful

Yeah that’s why I got one too, to also have a watch that had actual hands! Plus I recently had heart surgery so I still wanted something with hr monitoring etc! I think the scanwatch is a great watch and it’s nice to have something more formal looking for work!

The scanwatch is a great option if that’s what you’re looking for!

I must say even though I like my Apple Watch I really am also very fond of my scanwatch! They’re great watches

I find my scanwatch report hr and exercise pretty much in line with my Apple Watch tbh no noticeable differences when I switch them up. I always get a comment about my scanwatch people saying it looks nice as well which is nice! I really like both of them lol

I've used a Scanwatch for three years and wouldn't recommend it for sleep tracking. It doesn't recognize biphasic sleep patterns and is inconsistent with daytime naps.

I have a Scanwatch and an Apple watch. I wear my Apple watch only when I am running. My scanwatch is always on my wrist. I love the looks and the battery life. It tracks my heart rate, sleep, and activity frequency and I get notifications. Apple watch doesn't look nice as a watch and the necessity to charge it every day is a big disadvantage.

The scanwatch is very good. the 30 days of battery life depends on a lot of things depending on what you have activated. The documentation on their site is very clear. It’s the most beautiful hybrid connected health watch! It takes heart rate very well for health during the day (every 10 minutes) while walking or at night. But for sport it's less good, it's better to turn to another brand which is more sporty. The step counter is precise as well as the floors mounted. The Ecg and oxygen have been clinically validated. Notifications are limited but it's a health watch. Personally I just have notifications for treatments, reminders and calendar. A lot of people complain about this but in general it's always like that in reviews. So yes it has bugs at times, it's a shame that functions are announced but take a lot of time to come out. Which manufacturer has no problem Call, google microsoft everyone frankly every 2 months releases products which at times are buggy. My scanwatch nova lasts 3 weeks of autonomy and I recharge it while it is at 20%. I wear it every day but I don't sleep with it. I take an ECG and oxygen once a week. I start walking or hiking exercises and the frequency is always good. On the other hand, I do crossfit with a call watch because the screen displays more information, the heart rate is very precise and the GPS is included unlike the scanwatch which requires the phone.

the scanwatch is the only one to detect paradoxical sleep and naps. The sleep score of the Appel watch is ridiculous compared to withings.

Hi there, been between the two now for ages. Scanwatch is really crappy with sports tracking and subpar with sleep, so I usually have the Garmin for sports stuff and the Scanwatch as an EDC. And if I have a digital itch I switch it up. If you want a watch that looks like one and tracks some metrics but not too OCD or data hungry, don‘t think twice and get one. It‘s the nicest hybrid watch package out there. The analog Garmins look like children‘s toys in comparison. If you care about HR tracking, combine that nice Withings watch with a cheap Apple watch. Using Apple with the best tracker around for workouts and sleep tracking, you are finally getting the accurate sleep phase tracking Withings promised but never delivered. But all those numbersw don‘t mean much to me and I prefer having a real watch on my wrist…

Basically all the options in the market sync to apple Health. My favorite is either a Garmin (buttons instead of touch screen, many shortcuts via buttons, mip is less screen and more watch) or a Withings Scanwatch, which are the best hybrid watches that give you real watch vibes while still providing notifications and health metrics.

I reckon the two are totally different gadgets. Scanwatch is a normal watch + health tracking. Apple Watch is a gadget, full functions smart watch. If you just want to track your health and sleep and want to have time on your wrist, go for Scanwatch. If you want to have smart watch with notifications, apps, music controls or other smartphone controls, also want to track your health, go for Apple watch.

Try a Withings scanwatch. Looks great, and gets a month of charge.

I like my Withings Scanwatch, it’s significantly cheaper than a Garmin or an Apple Watch at £230 or £330 depending on the version you select. Battery lasts a month and it’s an accurate heart rate and step tracker. It has a calorie tracking feature but I don’t use it to track calories so I can’t really comment on its effectiveness for that. It’s also waterproof so I swim wearing mine too! I also like that it can pass for a normal watch as the screen and pedometer dial are integrated into a regular watch face. However, it’s not touch screen but is operated with a tiny knob on the side, so it depends what you prefer really.

Withings scanwatch does the job for me, but I work in an office. Previously had 2 fitbits

I have the original scanwatch and before that had a steel HR. It tracks steps well, pushes messages for a small number of select apps which I want prompting on, and notifies me if I'm getting a call. I run a few times a week and track my runs. Some are treadmill runs, and some are outdoors. I track my sleep, and sometimes my watch picks up other activities. I charge about once every 3 weeks or so. 99% of the time everything works seamlessly. There are a few niggles - sleep sometimes is lengthened by me laying in bed and having a coffee so I often have to manually adjust the sleep length to when I actually woke up - not a hardship, but probably something which I shouldn't need to do. I also find it under calculates calories - I use a polar heart rate monitor with my treadmill so would assume this is accurate and on a 10k my treadmill will suggest around 1000 calories whereas my watch will say 750ish. I can't compare for outside running with GPS as have no direct comparison but it seems to be the same sort of calorie assumption so assume it's under. Again, not an issue - more of an annoyance. My only major gripe is that I can't overwrite the calories to correct them and have it pull through. So, if I record the 1000 calories manually against my run, the lowered 750 calories remains the value in my total daily intake - manual adjustment are only recorded against that one metric and not pulled through elsewhere. Had a right ding dong with the customer service about that as it's really not helpful, but no changes. Anyway, yes, I'd recommend. I like that it looks like a watch and I like that it does the basics of a smart watch. I like the ECG and the O2 monitoring. I like the breathing prompts. And I particularly like wearing it for weeks without taking it off.

I have a Withings Scanwatch that I wear everyday. I climb with it on, and have an elastic band for it. With weight applied it easily stretches over my hand, and with my full weight the watch pops off/apart at the hinge. I have light scuffs on the bezel after 2 years of indoor climbing with it, but no glass scratches at all.

I have owned the Scanwatch and a Garmin. While the Scanwatch was a nice watch, and I definitely see a use case for it, it was not competitive as a sports/running watch.

I have a withings hybrid that I love. less ugly imo, was a decent price, and feels less like you have a piece of tech attached to you at all times. plus it measures everything I need and want