Garmin
Forerunner 245 Music

Garmin
Garmin

Garmin

I am also using an AMOLED (epix pro gen 2), which replaced a fr245. I had a tough time in some scenarios with the MIPS display, such as on shaded trails and around subset (both common in my users). In these cases I am happier with the AMOLED.
A few months ago I made the transition from the FR245 to the Epix Pro Gen 2 Sapphire and have been enjoying the change, I especially like the larger and brighter screen. I hope you have a great time with the new watch!
I usually wear both a watch and a fitness tracker. For the watch, it is usually a Seiko SKX007 or a Citizen Eco-Drive Promaster. For the fitness tracker, I wore a Garmin Forerunner 245 for several years, and a few months ago, I purchased an Epix Pro Gen 2 Sapphire (47m).
Garmin Venu 1, 2, or even one of the newer Vivoactives would be great. You can get a Venu 2 for probably about $100-$130 on Facebook Marketplace right now. You can also get one of the older Garmin Forerunners for about the same price as well, if not a little cheaper
Use forerunner for swimming and it works great. So happy I no longer have to count my laps and I can just swim.
if he is working a lot in the rain, get him something with more than 2 buttons so he would be able to use the watch using only the buttons (without the touchsreen) if he needs to, something like a forerunner, or instinct (doesnt have a touch screen) or a fenix (but a fenix is one of the more expensive ones)
I recently switched to Garmin from FitBit because I wanted GPS navigation on the watch for hikes. The Garmin run coach has sucked me into running and now I have to remember to include hikes. Seeing the Vo2 Max score go up has been motivating. The GPS navigation is really neat, I can go to a trailhead and tell Garmin to calculate a hike for X miles and it will. I don't think all of the Garmin watches have that feature, but its great for exploring. Makes walking more interesting.
The same I was big on the Apple ecosystem and felt like it was a cool watch just because it integrated so well, but I never even downloaded any apps for it. All I ever used it for was timers and reminders and stuff like that and basic fitness tracking, and my forerunner does all the same stuffbut way better. Should’ve switched sooner
Dito. Venu will offer a tick “sexier” display due to oled, FR will most probably go longer. Might be a case for weekend hike ;)
All true except advanced metrics. They are also present in Fenix (it has even more features for hiking) and Instinct. Forerunner is not more advanced. The rugedness is mostly about the bezel. In fenix and instinct it has a rim which gives extra protection to the screen. But that means rugged watches are more bulky what can be a problem in the gym. The real question is lightness of forerunner vs battery life of fenix /instinct
Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Top pick
Oura - Oura Ring Series

Top pick
Apple - Ultra Series

Top pick
Garmin - Fenix 7 Series

Top pick
Garmin - Fenix 7 Series

Top pick
Garmin - Forerunner 255 Series

Top pick
Oura - Oura Ring Series