
SteelSeries
Arctis Nova 7 Series
Multi-device audio & comfort king, but buggy software.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
I use the wired version of the Arctis Pro and also the Nova Pro, and I'm a huge fan of being able to mix SPDIF, USB and analog line in (I use for mic monitoring on my Elgato Wave 3). I do like the DTS Headphone X over optical because I think it works better than the software spatial audio. I use an ifii SPDIF purifier 2 to reduce any toslink bitter. Lately I've been using the gamedac gen 2 out of convenience since I pay on PC and Xbox and need headset support when I play on Xbox. One thing I love about the Arctis Pro headset is the shareport because it's perfect for adding another source without messing with the noise floor of the DAC and works great for mic monitoring.
I share your pain. I still feel like I got the wind knocked out of me. Why on earth do the midrange devices get companion app support but the Pro and Pro Wireless don't? All I want is Sonar on Xbox
Id have to say go with any Steel series line up. They have amazing wired headsets. I'm currently using the Steel series Artic Nova 7x wireless and it's absolutely amazing. But my old headset was a Artic Nova pro wired and that was also absolutely amazing it's about 250 to 300$ CAD
By that logic, the $379 Pro's which are inferior to these in both sound signature, microphone & build quality isn't worth the price. But they are rated as probably Top 3 in Gaming headphones. You have to look at it in the entire package. Software + build quality + feature set + sound performance + mic performance. The Pro's are already top 3 in this regard. There are other headphoens slightly cheaper that may deliver certain things better and vice versa. Many brands have better mics, worse sound signature. Some have better sound signature and worse mics. Some can't do crap for software and EQ control. Then you have Audiophile cans that you then need to buy seperate products to take advatange of and then overall can cost more than the gaming headset. Like it or not, sometimes spending a little bit of a premium for convenience and having a good experience in each category makes sense. I don't want 50 things on my desk just to hear 5% better. I don't want a microphone on my desk either, and want it attached to my mic. I also want a wireless headset. I also don't want to spend hours trying to EQ my games and want something that just sounds a bit more immersive out of the box by clicking a button. I also like to keep all of my software not so bloated with 50 different products. I also like higher build quality and decent mics. That's where the Nova Pro's came in, and they are easily top 3 in most categories outside of audiophile specific devices. Enters the Elites which is better than them by a good margin in each of those categories. With your logic, don't ever fly direct on an airplane... how dare you spend more money for convenience!
By that logic, the $379 Pro's which are inferior to these in both sound signature, microphone & build quality isn't worth the price. But they are rated as probably Top 3 in Gaming headphones. You have to look at it in the entire package. Software + build quality + feature set + sound performance + mic performance. The Pro's are already top 3 in this regard. There are other headphoens slightly cheaper that may deliver certain things better and vice versa. Many brands have better mics, worse sound signature. Some have better sound signature and worse mics. Some can't do crap for software and EQ control. Then you have Audiophile cans that you then need to buy seperate products to take advatange of and then overall can cost more than the gaming headset. Like it or not, sometimes spending a little bit of a premium for convenience and having a good experience in each category makes sense. I don't want 50 things on my desk just to hear 5% better. I don't want a microphone on my desk either, and want it attached to my mic. I also want a wireless headset. I also don't want to spend hours trying to EQ my games and want something that just sounds a bit more immersive out of the box by clicking a button. I also like to keep all of my software not so bloated with 50 different products. I also like higher build quality and decent mics. That's where the Nova Pro's came in, and they are easily top 3 in most categories outside of audiophile specific devices. Enters the Elites which is better than them by a good margin in each of those categories. With your logic, don't ever fly direct on an airplane... how dare you spend more money for convenience!
All these people mad that you bought an actual decept pair of headphones. Are there better out there, for better cost/performance. Yes, sure. And people buy NVIDA or AMD and fans based on aesthetics, and brand loyalty. They buy a certain vehicle, when there is a more fuel efficient car. Take a different airline because of how comfortable they may be for a few to several hours. Rather door dash vs pick up, because it's time vrs money. These are still one of the best 'gaming' headphones on the market, regardless of price. Do they have the audio quality? No. Do they have the build quality? Yes. We all have seen other headphoens from audiophiles that aren't worth the price, or well worth the price. The fact is, the dude says they're way better than his Pro's, and the Pro's are already costly. If they're better than that, then it's somewhat warranted just from the sound signature, let alone the build quality. So many jealous people here.
I think the issue here is that you play on pc, which desktop mics are going to be a lot easier to plug in. Gaming headsets provide a plug and play experience, especially on console where you have to go through several loops just to get a DAC working. I believe that OP is on console, so advice for a desktop mic while doable isn't the most convenient and most definitely will end up out of the budget given. The maxwells have a strong sound signature but are way too heavy to be practical if you're not a big head. In my own experience, I ran Beyerdynamics on console for a bit and actually prefered my artics 5x, as the beyerdynamics were way to quiet especially for siege and as forementioned, getting a dac working on console just doesn't feel worth it. The headset was 16 ohms as well, so it shouldn't have been underpowered. Personally, i'm currently selling both the dac and the beyerdynamic headphones and will be upgrading to the artics elite.
I run the steelseries artics 5x (5p would be the playstation version) I'll be upgrading to the artic elite pro
I find the older style of the arctis pro much more comfortable than the artist nova pro. With third party pads and the more adjustable strap it's nice even if you wear glasses.
I have the arctis elites which is my daily driver for everything around the house, the range is insane. But before that, the arctis 7 was holding up really well. The bad reviews are mainly the high price and the mic quality, which doesnt sound bad and is rated among the top 3 mics according to multiple reviews and youtube videos. Even hearing them use it on the videos, while not broadcast quality, sounds very close to normal speaking, albeit kind of nasally. Youll hear that audeze maxwells are better, which is true regarding sound, but planar drivers are known to break easily because it's super thin. Even pressing the ear cushions against your head can create air pressure that breaks it. Theres rumors of maxwell 2 releasing soon which I hope addresses the weight and planar issues. For sure, stay away from any sony headsets. You read a lot of qc issues from constant disconnects, to breaking very easily. i tried fiio ft1 and sennheiser 560s but I cant stand wired headsets and sennheiser is known to have high treble, even with EQ adjusted.

SteelSeries
Arctis Nova 7 Series
Multi-device audio & comfort king, but buggy software.

Drop + EPOS / Sennheiser
PC38X
Unrivaled open-back sound for price, but lacks isolation.

SteelSeries
Arctis 7 Series
Durable comfort, long battery, but buggy software.

HyperX
Cloud III Series
FPS positional audio & comfort, but buggy DTS software.

HyperX
Cloud Alpha Series
Long battery & durable, but some sound bleed issues.

Ranked #1
Drop + EPOS / Sennheiser - PC38X

Ranked #1
SteelSeries - Arctis 7 Series

Ranked #1
SteelSeries - Arctis Nova Pro Series

Ranked #1
SteelSeries - Arctis Nova 7 Series

Ranked #1
SteelSeries - Arctis Nova Pro Series

Ranked #1
Astro (Logitech) - A50 Series