
Logitech G
G600 MMO Gaming Mouse
Customizable MMO workhorse, durable, but discontinued and pricey.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
I have the G3 800mah version. Used it for about 8 months. The left click started to rattle in this time period, so I switched to VXE. I'd say the build quality isn't good.
The G305 was my first modern gaming mouse, so it deeply influenced my mouse grip. In practice, this means I hate normal mouse shapes that widen at the back, because it makes it nearly impossible to move the mouse between your fingers. It also forces you to keep your fingers further in front compared to what I had done with the G305, changing the relation between the fingers and sensor position, causing further annoyance. My frame of reference for a "normal" mouse is the incott G23. No complaints about it whatsoever other than the shape. Unfortunately, the G305 isn't a great device. The clicks are a bit stiff and inconsistent as you move away from the front of the mouse, the mouse wheel is mushy and annoying to click, and the weight can feel off after you've used proper mice with built in batteries instead of heavy AAs. My first stop was the Razer Orochi V2. Verdict: awful. The shape is similar from the top down, but includes an awkward flaring on the bottom of the left wall, forcing your thumb to either sit awkwardly high above it, or even more awkwardly, on it. More over, the clicks are the stiffest I've seen on any mouse and the shell design makes things even worse. I put a mouse skate underneath the top shell to try and make them at least usable, but they were still the worst I've experienced and certainly not good enough for gaming. Next up was the Corsair Katar Elite. This one may have been my go-to, if not for one issue. Before that though, the good - the mouse shape is actually better than the G305. It's not as eggy and feels more consistent when you shift your grip along it. The flat sides are also an improvement, though they do slope inward a too aggressively, making the mouse oddly slim at the bottom. The front of the shell is also really tall, which feels great for control, but it's tall enough to actually cause some minor discomfort over time, though it mostly seemed like a temporary problem. Something else that was temporary was the scroll wheel. The scroll wheel click is nice enough, but the actual scrolling part broke very quickly. Missed inputs, opposite inputs, ghost inputs, delayed inputs, every possible issue. I considered buying another unit, but it seems like every one of these mice ends up this way, making it an overall no-go. Shame. The battery life is good, the clicks are light and very consistent across the surface, their flat angle means you don't put pressure "down" (in a sensor movement sense), which is good for aiming as well. Highly recommended for people without the need for a scroll wheel. After that I settled for the incott for a while, before finding the Mchose G3A. It's heavier than the incott and Corsair, but still reasonable. Feels incredibly rigid and doesn't sound hollow like most others do. Clicks are consistent, shape is pretty much bang on with the G305, battery life seems decent. Scroll wheel is mediocre, but no worse than Logitech's, so I can live with it. Side buttons are incredibly soft though, so get ready to treat them as if they were touch sensitive. The DPI button also isn't remappable in the software directly, but some people recently said they've found a way to do it with editing config files. The big issue with this one: the wireless signal. I keep the dongle fairly close to on my desk and no other mouse has had problems. The Mchose completely drops out periodically when I plug a controller dongle in next to it, but seems to be inconsistent with my mainstay wireless keyboard next to it as well. I'll test it more, but it's a disqualifier for me as it stands. Today I got my VXE Dragonfly V3 in the mail as well. So far, it seems like a downgrade. The clicks are stiffer and inconsistent across their length like the G305's. The scroll is mushier and the wheel click is very stiff. The side buttons have a very long throw. The body also seems to be a bit shorter. It took me a while to notice, but it has a surprisingly big effect on how the mouse handles for me. The mouse feels oddly hard to control overall. Idk if it's because of a combination of shape, lighter weight and factory skates or the actual tracking, but it's much tougher for me to avoid overshooting small adjustments. So for now, the Corsair is worth a recommend if you don't need a scroll wheel. If you do, maybe the Mchose fares better with no other wireless devices around, but I'm still on the lookout. I'm curious about the G305 superlight, but it's very pricey, so that's probably not happening any time soon.
I've been playing CS for a long time and realized that my spray control is done with my fingers, mostly my thumb acting like a lever. On the R1 Pro Max, that's impossible because of its 120mm length. My first serious-ish gaming mouse was the Logitech G100s. Then the G305 with an AA battery – didn't get along with the weight balance. Then the Mchose G3A (sensor garbage and bad balance). Then the Glorious Forge Series One Pro Genos – not bad, climbed to 2215 Elo. Now I'm back on the G305 with a AAA mod, it's fine, but it feels outdated for serious play and a bit heavy. I want something with a proper center of gravity and lighter weight. I'm 182cm tall, around 100kg. I'll measure my hand later, don't have a ruler at home right now. I don't get how people play with low sens and control spray with their forearm and whole arm. That's complete nonsense and masochism. With that style, you're completely immobile – it's like driving with a bus steering wheel. My DPI 1000 and sens 1.72, 6 of 10 windows sens. On g100s my sens was the same, but 800 dpi. And I'm using acceleration. I'm tryed without - bullshit spray, like with r1 pro max now.
If you're considering this get an mchose g3. I own both and the g3 is essentially an upgraded better version of this mouse. Own both and g3 > g305.
I have both. Mchose one has better clicks, is closer to g305 shape and has better weight distribution. However, my mchose copy just keeps disconnecting while on 2.4 Ghz mode, but works fine on Bluetooth mode. Just go for mchose g3, but make sure you get either the v2 or better version of the mouse.
I just picked up other egg mice. Mchose g3, Attack shark g3pro and Fantech Aria v2 pro.
If we're going for the exact same shape, with a modern experience, then yes, Mchose G3 would be your best bet The g304 was my first mouse, moved to a gpx superlight when I realized I needed bigger mice for my hand, now on an ATK X1 Ultra but might move to a kysona Jupiter pro when they have some in stock
Yep, the mchose g3 is basically a modern g305 so I really suggest you go with that. Even the dpi button thingy. R1 doesn't really fill out your hand like the g305 does, trust me I tried an r1 pro for a bit and really didn't like how small it was, the shape too.

Logitech G
G600 MMO Gaming Mouse
Customizable MMO workhorse, durable, but discontinued and pricey.

VXE
R1 Series
Budget king: lightweight, great value, long battery life.

Hitscan
Hyperlight
Ultra-light (39g) for small hands; sensor is outdated.

Razer
Viper V3 Pro
Adaptable shape, optical clicks, but scroll wheel malfunctions.

Logitech G
G502 HERO High Performance Gaming Mouse
Durable, heavy workhorse with free-spin scroll; prone to double-clicking.

Ranked #1
Hitscan - Hyperlight

Ranked #1
Teevolution - Terra

Ranked #1
Razer - Viper Ultimate

Ranked #1
Glorious - Model D Series

Ranked #1
Logitech G - G600 MMO Gaming Mouse

Ranked #1
Razer - Naga Trinity