
Sennheiser
HD 560S
Budget gaming king with clear sound, but tight fit.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
I bought the new Jade Audio JT7 planar magnetic and they go great with it! They come with 2 sets of cables and sound amazing for ~$100! Best value out there if you ask me.
I've tried a couple of the ones on here and I think the jt3s absolutely bulldoze everything else up until the ft1 and even then I could see the jt3s taking it in certain conditions. I'm less excited about the jt7 but they are still solid, same for the jt1s.
You’re not gonna get wide soundstage on a closed back without some sort of audio manipulation like Ifi’s XSpace button. Even then it isn’t the same. You have to prioritize, closed back for isolation and more detail or open back for soundstage and better spatial awareness. For what it’s worth my room is noisy too (fans) but once my game starts I don’t even notice it. TBF I only do single player, non-competitive gaming. I can’t stand isolation either, I have tinnitus. With all that said, if you opt closed back Fiio makes some great budget cans. The JT1 is a closed back around $60. I use Jade JT7 open backs with a ifi hip dac amp and the sound is stellar. $100 planar magnetic headphones is just crazy value, I highly recommend if you opt for open back and can stretch your budget to $100-$120. Good luck! Cheers
Unless you absolutely prioritize isolation for use in public spaces or monster bass open backs are the way. There’s a reason 90% of “audiophile” sets are open. They prioritize soundstage, accuracy and separation. If you ever wanna dabble, check out a set of Hifiman Edition XS for around $200. Tool is my fave band and with those it sounds like I’m sitting criss cross applesauce right in front of the kick drums, it’s incredible. Whatever you get, enjoy!
Jade JT7s and buy a 3.5mm boom mic cord to make it a “gaming headset”.
Better to just buy some real headphones and a stand alone mic. Can get a Fiio JT7 and a Blue Yeti mic for less for example. Gaming headphones have been a scam for a long time imo. They are good at a couple things but nearly always made to break within a couple years. Most headset mics sound terrible. The last gaming headset I bought was years ago Logitech Pro X in 2020. Headset piece on the right side snapped after just taking it off my head. Never again. HiFiman does make good headphones. Arya Stealth and Organics are top tier imo but are more expensive.
I prefer the build quality and sound quality of real headphones and mics instead of gamer headsets. That also includes for games. My headsets and iems do great for gaming by being more immersive than your typical gamer headset. Especially for games like Resident Evil series, Elden Ring, etc. Big cinematic moments sound better. You will also be able to hear footsteps and player actions just fine. That said, the build quality does look good imo for the Kithara, but for the price it's not worth it imo since the mic is bad. The JT7 I recommend is $120. Bet it sounds just as good or better than the Kithara. Can buy an actual mic for another ~$100 so you don't sound like a tin man when talking.
King of Value is koss for sure. The KSC75 with a headband or a kph40 would be the best bang for your buck. In the same vein, the moondrop old fashioned would be really good as well. Very mid forward, great for on the go listening. All three of course with yaxi/soulwit pads. If you want over ear, options get a bit more limited, a used sennheiser hd599 is a really great choice, as well as a 560s as they have low impedence good for a disc player. Also the fiio JT1 kor JT7 would be good options with planar drivers.
No that's a fair question. Stock koss pads aren't exactly the most comfortable, so yaxi, and soulwit by extension, make replacement pads that's are thicker, fluffier, and are more comfortable. Koss uses universal sizes for pads, and clips on the backs of the drivers so you can mix and match various headbands and earclips that fit that size. If there's a headband "made for the KSC75" it'll also fit any other koss on ear headphones. The issue with a thicker pad is that it reduces bass as the driver is further from your ear, and it may increase treble depending on frankly a lot of factors, but koss in particular punch well well above their price range and are known as the titan in the value headphone world. Some find them uncomfortable but the pads and band being swappable remove that issue almost entirely, some people just don't like on ear headphones.
A review of the FiiO Jade/Audio JT7 ( the very cheap planar from FiiO Subbrand) - also takes to pad swaps very well and IMO more comfortable than the FT1 Pro.

Sennheiser
HD 560S
Budget gaming king with clear sound, but tight fit.

Sony
WH-1000XM4
ANC king, durable, but unreliable mic and touch controls.

Sennheiser
HD 6XX
Legendary mids, durable, but narrow soundstage and weak bass.

Sennheiser
HD 490 PRO
Super comfortable, wide soundstage for gaming, versatile pads.

Sennheiser
HD 599
Super comfortable, easy to drive, wide soundstage, open-back.

Ranked #1
Sennheiser - HD 6XX

Ranked #1
FiiO - FT1 Closed-back Headphones

Ranked #1
Sennheiser - HD 560S

Ranked #1
Sony - MDR-7506

Ranked #1
Sony - WH-1000XM4

Ranked #1
Sennheiser - HD 560S