
Valerion
VisionMaster Pro 2
Great picture/gaming, but RBE and no lens shift are dealbreakers.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
PX3-PRO is the top dog right now at that budget. $3K would be a good price. Black Friday/CM is a month away though, I'd wait at this point. // Meanwhile, you're going to need to elevate the UST projector though. Sitting on that hearth will have part of the image hitting that fireplace...which I hope you never plan to use if you're going to have a UST and screen there. (I wouldn't chance it, ever). Also, the width of that space where the image would go... I feel like an 85" TV makes more sense there? It would be brighter than a UST for one, and it would do a good job of filling most of that space, for two.
I have the 5050UB. It is excellent and remains so even after 3500 hrs on the original bulb. I recently purchased a Hisense PX3 Pro UST for another room, and it doesnt match the Epson for filmic look. Also black levels aee better on Epson.
You’re on the right path a UST projector with an ALR screen is usually the best TV replacement for a bright living room, especially with windows on the same wall, and the Hisense PX3 Pro fits that use case well; waiting for a PX4 Pro could bring small improvements, but it’s not likely to be a huge leap. Just make sure to invest in a good ALR screen, since that matters as much as the projector in bright conditions. If you consider alternatives, long-throw can still work with the right setup, but UST is simpler for this scenario. As a side note, the Dangbei DBOX02 Pro is a nice easy-to-use projector with great color, though it’s more suited for flexible, casual setups rather than replacing a TV in a bright room.
PX3-Pro is honestly one of the better UST options in that price range right now! for $2999 it’s actually pretty competitive considering the brightness n features. for screens, if you want good bang for the buck, there are some decent budget ALR options now compared to a few years ago. brands like Nothing Projector have some popular picks in the lower price range. around the \~$1k mark you can definitely find a decent 120” ALR screen without going completely crazy on budget.
Just got my PX3 as well. Quick things: - out the box it had smooth motion / motion interpolation enabled, which may be the “clinical” thing you are experiencing. Turn that crap off :) - play with the focus some. It’s pretty easy to have it ever so slightly out of focus and it’s hard to tell. - Try one of the dark picture modes. Otherwise, no RBE effect here, but that really sounds like it’s a person to person thing.
Depends on your use case, the PX3-Pro still seems to be the best mixed use UST. Nexigo Aurora Pro mkii is best for dark rooms. If you don't need UST then you have more options (Valerian Max, Dangbei S7 ultra)

Valerion
VisionMaster Pro 2
Great picture/gaming, but RBE and no lens shift are dealbreakers.

Epson
Home Cinema 5050UB (V11H930020)
Great value with huge lens shift, but outdated lamp tech and poor HDR.
Epson
Pro Cinema LS12000 4K PRO-UHD Laser Projector
Superb 4K/120Hz gaming and no RBE, but requires calibration.

BenQ
W1070
Budget king, durable with good image, but RBE can be distracting.

BenQ
HT2060
Excellent 1080p contrast and quiet gaming, but low brightness for big screens.

Ranked #1
Valerion - VisionMaster Pro 2

Ranked #1
Epson - Home Cinema 5050UB (V11H930020)

Ranked #1
Hisense - Laser TV PX3-PRO

Ranked #1
Anker - NEBULA X1 4K Triple Laser Projector (D2351)

Ranked #1
BenQ - GV50 Portable Projector

Ranked #1
Anker - Mars 3 Air