Beautyrest Black Alcove Plush

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#518 in

Mattress

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score50% positive
2
1
1
Last updated: Apr 23, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconInvidiousJamieson
8 months ago

Alas, the beds I like aren’t being made anymore. But they are.. Beautyrest Black Hybrid Alcove — this bed was my master bed for a few years until I went to a king. It’s now in my kids room. My king is an Intellibed Midnight. Bought the floor model. We’ve had it a few years and it’s doing well for my wife and I. The other bed is at my mother in laws. It’s the guest bed that we sleep on frequently. It’s the Sleepys Medium Hybrid. Feels really good.

Reddit Iconitssostupidiloveit
10 months ago

Haven't found a salesperson who knows what density foam they have. I'm having such a hard time. Last time I got a Beautyrest hybrid that was below the black, and I really really liked it. But the girl left me and took the mattress which is fine. This time I'm not falling in love with any of the mattress options at local showrooms. I'm really running out of options but need to act as I am sleeping on the couch and it sucks. I don't like the black, I love anything and am almost out of retailers to try

Reddit IconColeLimited
8 months ago

Do not get S&F estate firm euro top. I’ve seen way too many issues with that mattress in particular. I would really consider going with the Beautyrest Black. They have a hybrid line. If you’re wanting a hybrid (more of a foam feel) you could go with a Tempur. They are well regarded and considered to have one of the best customer satisfaction rate in the industry

Reddit IconHalf_Life976
5 months ago

Whatever you buy, make sure you lay on it for a good 15 minutes to half hour before you buy. And not when you're tired, either. Be able to actively feel how your body likes it. I still love my mattress 12 years later. It's a hybrid Beautyrest, nothing too fancy

Reddit IconNala1684
4 months ago

I recently purchased the Casper Cooling Select matress from Costco and definitely do not recommend it. I know I am late to this thread, but wanted to share my experience. It is a super plush bed with zero support. I have lower back pain and stiffness every day since receiving the matress. Unless you enjoy rolling up towels and sheets so that you can have some type of lumbar support, I would skip the Casper lineup. Additionally there is zero edge support. I recently purchased the Casper Onyx for my son from Rooms to Go and it is labeled as a medium and seems to have better support than the Casper Select. I was eyeing the Casper snow for myself, but after this experience and seeing how quickly my son's bed is turning from Medium Firm to Medium Soft...I am not sure I can trust the Casper brand. For a 15 year old, it seems to be okay. For adults who need support and dont want to sleep on an indoor hammock nightly, I recommend you continue your search. I ordered the Beautyrest Black hybrid from Costco as a replacement. Still waiting on delivery, but hoping for something firmer and more durable. Definitely dont recommend Casper although the cooling feature, I do like and if you are into super soft beds then it may be for you. I am a female and weigh about 180 lbs.

3 months ago

I have had the Beautyrest Black Hybrid (currently on sale I think) and it is to me a medium firm mattress. I really like it. I am a combo sleeper...side, back and sometimes stomach. I recommend this mattress. I am 5'3 180 though. I do have it on an adjustable base which is something that I am absolutely loving.

Reddit IconSouth-Ad-5883
11 months ago

I can help! We started with the Stearns and Foster. I wanted to love it so badly. It seems to be really good quality. I was just waking up stiff and thought it was a little too firm. It has no bounce. I felt like if I didn't set my baby down gently enough she'd break her tailbone. So we returned it and put our old beautyrest hybrid back in. In the 2 weeks we'd had the S&F I realized my neck and shoulder pain had started to get better (I literally went to physical therapy for 2 years for this) and one night back on the old mattress and I had a migraine (hadn't had one on the new mattress). Was blaming the migraines on postpartum and thyroid issues. We had the beautyrest dual cool on the way and I canceled it immediately. I am super anti Beautyrest after this experience. So we ordered the Sealy ridgecrest. Tried it last night for the first time. I laid on it for 2 hours and it's absolutely terrible. No support at all. I'm back in the baby's room on our guest bed which is an amazon bed in a box and 100x better than the Sealy. I'm a side sometimes back sleeper and weigh 145. I thought I liked plush but I may be needing more firm. Or at least something with support. We will be going the latex route

Reddit IconSpecialist_Sort_6914
4 months ago

We have one that we bought about 8/9 years ago and I think that we are coming to the end of it’s life. I have been pregnant three times and my weight has fluctuated a good 100lbs heavier than I am right now. It is still pretty comfy but am starting to get more hip pain (I’m a side sleeper). I would 100% buy it again.

Reddit IconVLR_I
2 months ago

Unfortunately, the cost doesn't translate into better quality. I've honestly had better experience with the cheap foam mattress in a box from Sam's. My beauty rest hybrid started to say within a year, too. It year 4 it is almost deep enough for the warranty call. It is totally ruining me, though. I'm ready to order a chunk of foam from foambymail.com My teen is loving hers. On the floor it is going great. It's cheap, but effective it seems

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Best for Ease of movement & sex

Novaform - Platinum 16.5" Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Top pick

Novaform - Platinum 16.5" Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Individuals who toss and turn frequently, or couples who prioritize a mattress that is responsive and bouncy for sexual activity, and dislike the "sinking" feeling of memory foam.
See rankings →

Best for Heavy & plus-size sleepers

Big Fig - Classic Mattress

Top pick

Big Fig - Classic Mattress

Individuals with higher body weights (typically 230 lbs or more) who find that standard mattresses quickly sag, lose support, and cause back or joint pain.
See rankings →

Best for Hot sleepers

Purple - The Purple Mattress

Top pick

Purple - The Purple Mattress

Individuals who consistently wake up feeling hot or sweaty, and find that their mattress absorbs and retains body heat throughout the night.
See rankings →

Best for Long-term durability

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Top pick

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Buyers who view a mattress as a long-term investment and want to purchase one that will maintain its support and comfort for over a decade, prioritizing total cost of ownership over a low initial price.
See rankings →

Best for Motion isolation for couples

Helix - Midnight Luxe

Top pick

Helix - Midnight Luxe

Couples or co-sleepers who are easily woken up by a partner's tossing, turning, or getting in and out of bed.
See rankings →

Best for Natural & organic materials

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Top pick

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Health-conscious individuals or those with chemical sensitivities who want to avoid synthetic foams, chemical off-gassing, and potentially hazardous materials like fiberglass in their sleep environment.
See rankings →

Other Reddit Recommendations: