Beautyrest Black Series One Extra Firm

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#637 in

Mattress

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score40% positive
2
2
1
Last updated: May 1, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconInvidiousJamieson
5 months ago

Well, I haven’t laid on the firm saatva, but have laid on an extra firm BR Black series 1. So how firm do you want it? And in this context when you say firm, I’m assuming you want the bed to feel hard.

Reddit IconFlimsy_Buy_100
8 months ago

Bought extra firm 6 years ago. The mattress is in very good condition but it is Extra firm. I got a latex mattress topper from Amazon and it helped a lot. Mattress is Beauty Rest, I don’t remember the latex one but it was a small business on Amazon

Reddit IconBarbKatz1973
3 months ago

My spine is attached to my skull with titanium bolts, my spine is held together with titanium plates, I have back issues. My mattress, which I change every five years is a Beauty Rest Black extra firm. Yes they are expensive, yes, it does the job. I sleep well, I rest and I awaken with no more pain than what I had when I went to sleep. Your back is one of the most important structures in your health and life, do not fall for gimmicks or advertising.

Reddit IconDaddys-Fixation
5 months ago

For the mattress, Simmons BeautyRest Extra Firm 13 3/4 inch height. Different stores have different names, so go by the height.

Reddit Iconbeyondplutola
8 months ago

$800 Beautyrest innerspring mattress, firm. No idea what model. Bought it the furniture store 8 years ago when we bought the bed. It’s getting time to replace and I’ll just be looking for another basic spring mattress. I’m not very particular. As long it’s firm and springy, I’m good.

Reddit IconNo_Inside196
9 months ago

On our 2nd Beautyrest Black (firm king) because the first was replaced under warranty when it sagged and this one is sagging, too. We both weigh less than you. I regret it. Felt great new but by 6 months in both times there was a huge hump in the middle and deep depression where we sleep. *GONG"

Reddit Iconwhosthatgirl
Reddit IconOrdinary_Signature42
5 months ago

I personally like a soft mattress. But what I've found is there are too types of soft mattresses: mush and truly soft. Mush you get in and can't get back out. This is the Beauty rest Black line at the Brick (Canada) Truly soft are medium firm mattresses with great foam tops like Beauty Rest Trilliant at Sleep Country. Mush is awful but a supporting mattress with a cloud top is a thing of beauty. I had a mattress like this several years ago, amazing. Then I switched to medium firm on medical advice. Big mistake. My body likes to be held but my joints like to be whispered to. I am a side sleeper with a little back until the sleep apnea chokes me awake.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Best for Ease of movement & sex

Novaform - Platinum 16.5" Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Top pick

Novaform - Platinum 16.5" Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Individuals who toss and turn frequently, or couples who prioritize a mattress that is responsive and bouncy for sexual activity, and dislike the "sinking" feeling of memory foam.
See rankings →

Best for Heavy & plus-size sleepers

Big Fig - Classic Mattress

Top pick

Big Fig - Classic Mattress

Individuals with higher body weights (typically 230 lbs or more) who find that standard mattresses quickly sag, lose support, and cause back or joint pain.
See rankings →

Best for Hot sleepers

Purple - The Purple Mattress

Top pick

Purple - The Purple Mattress

Individuals who consistently wake up feeling hot or sweaty, and find that their mattress absorbs and retains body heat throughout the night.
See rankings →

Best for Long-term durability

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Top pick

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Buyers who view a mattress as a long-term investment and want to purchase one that will maintain its support and comfort for over a decade, prioritizing total cost of ownership over a low initial price.
See rankings →

Best for Motion isolation for couples

Helix - Midnight Luxe

Top pick

Helix - Midnight Luxe

Couples or co-sleepers who are easily woken up by a partner's tossing, turning, or getting in and out of bed.
See rankings →

Best for Natural & organic materials

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Top pick

SleepOnLatex - Pure Green Organic Latex Mattress

Health-conscious individuals or those with chemical sensitivities who want to avoid synthetic foams, chemical off-gassing, and potentially hazardous materials like fiberglass in their sleep environment.
See rankings →

Other Reddit Recommendations: