
Brooklyn Bedding
Signature Hybrid
Durable, comfortable, adjustable firmness; excellent value.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
I HATE the feeling of sinking into the mattress!! I finally upgraded and got a Titan (whatever the basic one is, Core I think?) it actually arrived while I was in labor, so I got to climb into the brand new bed with the brand new baby and it was just the absolute best feeling. That was almost 4 years ago now! 😮 Still feels wonderful!
The Titan Plus Core is solid and usually heavily discounted (it’s like 600 bucks for a queen atm, I believe). I was a big fan of the Helix Dawn Luxe when I tried it out, too. Both should have enough cushioning to not feel like you’re lying on a brick on your side.
Hey, great question. So the Titan Plus Core was recently updated from the old Titan Plus and its surface feels a good bit softer. It seems a little more balanced out now despite it being a pretty minimal change. I have the Titan Plus Elite myself and it’s super firm and supportive but I’ve never had issues with the springs. I lie on my stomach so I’m plopping all my weight on it basically and I have 0 complaints. I’ve enjoyed all the Titan stuff I’ve gotten my hands on so far.
If your budget allows, I’d recommend going for the higher-end models from brands designed for sleepers with bigger bodies(like Big Fig or Titan). Their premium versions usually add features like pillow tops or cooling covers, so you get strong support without that overly hard, uncomfortable feel. They tend to land around a medium-firm range and are built to hold up well over time. For more specific recs, I have the Titan Plus Elite myself and it was 10000% worth it. The Big Fig Luxe made me want to buy it when I tested it also. And, if you would prefer the firmer feel, the Titan Plus Core is less plush but still super supportive without being rigid.
If you really like it and it's in budget, the Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze is solid and should hold up, I'd get that if you're able to in person (depending how hassle-free the return policy is). If you just need an supportive mattress that functions fine on a basic bed frame, I'd put my money on one of the Titan Plus beds. The base model (Core) is affordable and holds up really well. I have the Titan Plus Elite myself because I was having a similar sagging problem with the mattress I had before it, and I can't praise it enough. I know it's not convenient, but online mattresses typically offer an at-home sleep trial so you can return it if you don't like it. Good luck!
Titan Firm with a 3 inch latex topper has been AMAZING. I bought it 4 years ago and love love love. I tried the hybrid commonly recommended one from Titan but it was too wobbly.
Titan Firm with a 3 inch latex topper has been AMAZING. I bought it 4 years ago and love love love. I tried the hybrid commonly recommended one from Titan but it was too wobbly.
I've had the Titan Plus Core Hybrid for a few years and it's holding up well for both my BF and I. I'm 350, he's a little less (310-320). We both think it's comfy.
It stays supportive all night, yes.
I don't notice any pressure points myself, no. The bottom portion of the mattress is coil, but the top is foam, so it feels pretty good.
I haven't found it's softened at all. Looks the same as it did when I bought it. No sunken spots, no lumps.
I would agree with one of the commenters that the Big Fig is one of the most supportive options on the market. I'm around 300 lbs, and I test mattresses for support, sleeping positions etc. It's one of my faves. I've also had good experiences with the Saatva HD. With regard to the Titan Plus Luxe, I found it to be a good supportive option for someone in my weight range. However, it does have that plush pillow top on top. If you're a side sleeper, you might want to stick with that so you get good pressure relief. But, if you just sleep on your back, I would go with the Titan Plus Core. It's firmer and has less plushness right on top. To your general question about materials, I would stay away from memory foam mattresses with thick foam on top. We larger sleepers do need something on the firmer end, and memory foam can indeed let you sink in too far.
I got to test and review the Plank Firm mattress, and it's definitely one of the firmest mattresses I've tried. The firm side felt like an 8/10 and the extra firm side felt like a 9/10. I didn't get to try it for super extended period of time, but it was super firm. You might also want to look at a latex hybrid mattress. In my experience, a lot of them are on the firmer end. The Saatva Latex Hybrid and Avocado Eco Organic come to mind. And, as others have noted, many of the mattresses built for larger people can be really firm. I'm 295 lbs, and I still got some firm support from the Titan Plus Core and the Big Fig as well.
Can I ask what positions you both sleep in? You say you're not getting good pressure relief, so I'm imagining one of you sleeps on your side. I'm a 295 lb. back and side sleeper, and I've had good experiences with the Titan Plus Elite and the Titan Plus Elite. The Titan Plus Core was too firm for me, but the other two models add some better pressure relief with their pillow tops. You're right that the Big Fig is pretty firm, and I didn't get the best pressure relief on that one either. I also like the WinkBed Plus but it might be too firm if one of you is closer to 220.
Hey, I'm 6'7", and I weigh almost 300 lbs. I also test mattresses for a living, and I am a fan of the Titan mattresses. I will say that the Elite feels softer than the regular Titan Plus, so that might be a better fit for you. The Plus, for me, scored about a 9/10, which is way firmer than average. The Elite scored closer to a 6.5/10, which is pretty much medium-firm. Some other models you could check out are the Helix Plus and the WinkBed Plus. Those are made for people our size, and they should be within your budget for a full-size.
I test mattresses, and I've tried a good amount of the mattresses advertised specifically for heavier body weights. I'm 6'7" and I weigh 295 lbs, so I take that into account when I'm testing. There are a few models that I've had a good experience with. First off, the Big Fig felt as firm and supportive as advertised. I wouldn't say that it felt like sleeping on a board, but it definitely felt more like I was sleeping "on top" of the mattress. I found it to be good for back and stomach sleeping, too. I also liked the Titan Plus mattress. It's a more affordable model. This is also on the firmer side, and it's designed to hold up more weight. It was also good for back and stomach, but the Titan Plus Luxe I found to be better for side sleeping. And, the Saatva HD is the priciest of the bunch, but it's my favorite. It features many layers of high-density foam and more supportive coils. It's also firmer and good for back and stomach. Also, my good friend has had one for 4 years, and he's still sleeping on it with no sagging issues.
I’m also a Titan user. Bought mine from Brooklyn Bedding in 2021 & it’s still holding up amazing. Back then, we decided to go with the Titan Firm Hybrid, but I don’t believe they offer that model any longer. I rotate it once or twice a year.

Brooklyn Bedding
Signature Hybrid
Durable, comfortable, adjustable firmness; excellent value.

Sleep EZ
Organic Latex Mattress
Highly customizable layers, durable; but extremely heavy.

Helix
Midnight Luxe
Pain relief, side sleeper support; but some find too soft.

Purple
The Purple Mattress
Unique grid feel, cool; but heavy, expensive, polarizing.

Brooklyn Bedding
Aurora Luxe Cooling
Excellent cooling, zoned support for heavier sleepers.

Ranked #1
Novaform - Platinum 16.5" Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Ranked #1
Brooklyn Bedding - Titan Plus Luxe

Ranked #1
Purple - The Purple Mattress

Ranked #1
Sleep EZ - Organic Latex Mattress

Ranked #1
Helix - Midnight Luxe

Ranked #1
Sleep EZ - Organic Latex Mattress