
Brooklyn Bedding
Signature Hybrid
Durable, comfortable, adjustable firmness; excellent value.
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
If anyone out there is in need of a plush mattress. Mattress warehouse has the kingsdown crestbrook on sale I got mine with a free adjustable base in a queen for $1100 with white glove delivery. Couldn't be happier, i will say in two weeks on myself mattress and it started out a bit firmer than the showroom model but after two weeks we are starting to feel like the floor model i laid on and fell in love with. Haven't had a bad night's sleep since getting my new mattress and I love. I was scrolling for months and months through name brands like Serta, Bobsopedic, nectar, beauty rest. Finally found the mattress for me, kingsdown is amazing
If it eases your mind, all of the Posturepedic Pros have the same coil system. Whether it's soft or medium shouldn't have an effect on sagging in that regard, and should provide similar support overall. The soft is really just going to be a softer feeling layer of foam in the top. Do you have the medium tight top, or medium hybrid? If you have the tight top and generally like the feel and support, I would maybe consider the medium hybrid in the same line. It should be a relatively subtle difference, but could allow for your hips and shoulders to have a little more focused relief. The quilted tops all basically act like one unit, whereas the hybrid is a bit more flexible in how the layers react. Basically I think it would be the half-step where it should feel slightly softer while still being a bit more supportive in general than the soft tight top.
I hear that. The pictured Sealy looks like the tight top, with the quilting. Right now the Crestbrook is priced lower than the Sealy, but the comfort exchange is equal or greater. They might submit it as an even exchange. The Crestbrook is a solid mattress, but definitely spend some time on it in the store. It seems to have a bit more bounce than the Sealys. I think you'd be happy either way though. But also maybe check out the Dakota Ridge soft pillow top if you like soft mattresses. I love that one, though it is probably more in the ultra plush range.
Most of the sagging comments are by a fraction of the people that buy mattresses. Some percentage of any manufactured thing will have an issue. That's what warranties are for. A lot of people on here throw away a two year old $2k mattress without even trying to get it warrantied, which is basically the equivalent of lighting $2k on fire. Some people refuse to accept that the base is the primary reason for a mattress to go bad (and will cause a warranty to be denied). Another group of people refuse to use a mattress protector, so five years later the mattress has gained half its weight in your sweat and dead skin cells (which will cause the bed to sag and the warranty to be denied). Tempur-Pedic's internal data shows that they get warranty claims on one mattress per every thousand sold. More hand-made brands like Stearns & Foster, Kingsdown, Aireloom, etc. will likely have a higher failure rate, but they also provide a feeling of luxury you can't get without that process. The more mass-produced brands like Sealy have a great record, and Beautyrest has had a few bad lines but they've dropped them and replaced them with better. And across all those big name brands, they all come with 10 year warranties and actually try to honor them. They want to sell you a mattress and have you buy another in 10-15 years, and another 10-15 years after that.
Honestly I just replaced my mattress with financing at teppermans (along with a whole new bed) and I got the Kingsdown plush top mattress and it’s a dream!!!
I'm a skinny 150 lbs guy with scoliosis. For more than a decade, I slept on a mattress made by a small local manufacturer, a simple medium firm innerspring mattress with an Eurotop and it was fine. Also, when I go to hotels and Airbnb's, I sleep usually well and pain-free. I'm just back from France where I spent one week on a child mattress in my friend's guest bedroom and it was perfectly fine. The nightmare at home began in 2021 when I had to change my old locally made Eurotop mattress. -Cheap Zinus foam mattress bought on Amazon. It was okish once a memory foam topper was added to it, but still would give me frequent back pain that would wake me up. -Plush Wayfair mattress: way too soft, horrible violent back pain, couldn't return it, resold it, went back to the Sinus -Tuft n Needle horrible mattress: way too painfully rigid. They refunded me, made me keep it, it's now in the guest bedroom. Guests love it. Go figure. -Zinus hybrid mattress that was allegedly medium firm. It was a brick. Even with a memory topper on top of it, it was a brick. Amazon refunded me, didn't take it back, I resold it. At this point, I did all the mattress stores in my city, bought a big brand mattress that was way too soft. I couldn't return it, only exchange it. Ended up almost forcefully (nothing else was working in the store) with a Kingsdown mattress that was the softest Kingsdown mattress of the collection, but still too rigid for me. Sleeping on the side, I would wake up in horrendous pain after two hours. I have added a topper and if I sleep on my side, I'm ok until 5-6 am, where the back pain starts, but if I turn on my back during the night, I will wake up with violent pain. During Black Friday, I ordered a medium firm Silk n Snow. A brick. A mixture of granite and brick. Completely unusable. After some hassle and delays, they took it back. I once again did all the mattress stores in a radius of 150 km radius and tried everything. At my local Sleep Country, there was a heavy discount on a Casper Snow, $1000 CAD. Big mistake. That thing is waaaay too soft! Violent back pain that lasted for hours during the whole morning. I'm going to exchange it but I'm locked in to what they offer at Sleep Country. Any suggestions around that price or lower? What to look for? The firmness scale seems to mean nothing, it varies widely from one brand to the other. The softest Kinsgdown mattress is too rigid for me while a Casper that is allegedly medium first is way too soft. How to properly test the mattress in store? Which mattress could reproduce the usual hotel or Airbnb experience? In Airbnbs, it often seems to be older mattresses on older box springs. It works well for me. Why would a mattress made for children work so well for me while so many popular brand mattresses don't work at all?
I've had my Kingsdown latex and foam mattress for at least 12 years. There is an indent where we sleep now, but it's still extremely comfortable. I bought it on a whim because it was on clearance and it's the best purchase I've ever made. It's insanely heavy and has no carry spots; it took 3 adults struggling to carry it when we moved. That's my only gripe!
COSTCO CANADA "KINGSDOWN" mattress. (k/s) Very supportive 2 years in. Don't know if Costco USA carries them.

Brooklyn Bedding
Signature Hybrid
Durable, comfortable, adjustable firmness; excellent value.

Sleep EZ
Organic Latex Mattress
Highly customizable layers, durable; but extremely heavy.

Helix
Midnight Luxe
Pain relief, side sleeper support; but some find too soft.

Purple
The Purple Mattress
Unique grid feel, cool; but heavy, expensive, polarizing.

Brooklyn Bedding
Aurora Luxe Cooling
Excellent cooling, zoned support for heavier sleepers.

Ranked #1
Novaform - Platinum 16.5" Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Ranked #1
Brooklyn Bedding - Titan Plus Luxe

Ranked #1
Purple - The Purple Mattress

Ranked #1
Sleep EZ - Organic Latex Mattress

Ranked #1
Helix - Midnight Luxe

Ranked #1
Sleep EZ - Organic Latex Mattress