Supreme 11.5” Medium Hybrid

Yes, but I want to stay in the Costco ecosystem because the returns and warranty is so strong. I also tried a tempurpedic supreme hybrid it it's just to soft for my weight even at "medium firm" rating.

Yes I do, I was in the exact same position as you except I went with a tempurpedic after the Kirkland pillow top and did not like it. The tight top Kirkland is much better in my opinion.

Just bought a tempurpedic supreme medium hybrid. So far so good. Have had only less than a week. Really liked the pro adapt medium hybrid in MF so it was a no brainer to try the Costco tempur given the return policy. Good Luck!

Not sure what your budget is but we have the tempurpedic medium hybrid from Costco and love it. We’ve had it since late August. I had horrible back issues from an old mattress and this one has been great. Good luck on your search. We went to mattress firm and tried different mattresses and read a ton on Reddit to try to find the most similar models to try out since Costco doesn’t have displays.

Don’t buy a tempurpedic we did and I regret that purchase the most

Yes the one in the store felt amazing got the same model and after a year and a half it hurts my back but my wife is happy with it so there’s that

I bought a tempurpedic worst decision ever. I’ve always bought mattresses from Sam’s for the most part and this past year bought a 4k tempurpedic mattress and yeah that’s the last time I buy one.

I just got the Tempur-pedic Supreme Hybrid with the Ergo Adjustable Base from Costco, and I love it! It's would rate it medium-firm, so I think it's pretty good for stomach sleepers, but it's also good for side sleeping. In shopping for this mattress, I also liked the Casper Snow, but that was softer.

I also just went through all this same research. Came to the same conclusion that I never thought to try a foam bed (5’11, 240lb side sleeper). Tried the Costco tempurpedic supreme blah blah medium hybrid after some people’s recommendations. Honestly, alleviated my back pain in probably 3 days. Have only had it for 2 weeks so still breaking it in, but has been miles better than I was willing to give credit to and way cheaper ($1500 difference) through Costco versus their pro adapt mattress in the retail stores. Plus the Costco return policy if I do end up cratering this thing a couple of years haha

I don’t think so, but they do rename it. From what I understand their Supreme model is just the previous adapt model but I don’t know that for sure

So I had read that the hybrid versions were slightly softer. I’m not sure what that translates to real world, but since I’m a heavier side sleeper, I thought there was less risk going a point or so softer versus the firmer all foam version.