Google Wifi

Nest Wifi

Google Wifi Nest Wifi

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#217 in

Mesh Wifi Systems

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score26% positive
9
4
21

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Aug 29, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconApprehensive_Tax1760
9 months ago

I just replaced my old Google router mesh from 2019 with Eero 7 mesh. The speeds are much faster but has less stability. I really took Google router for granted, we had zero connection issues. With Eero I have at least 3 connections issues a week to fix. Garage keypad, kids iPad, smart light

Reddit IconCrabbieMike
11 months ago

We recently moved into a new home and now have gigabit internet. I have tried two different systems so far: the Linksys Velop system with two points. I would only get the speed I pay for in the room the router is in, but as soon as I go into the next room, it drops to around 200 mbps. Upstairs, it drops even further, even with the second point, unless you are hardwired into the second point. I am currently using the Nest Wifi router with four points, but I now only get a maximum speed of 500 Mbps downstairs and 150 Mbps upstairs, even with two points upstairs. Unfortunately, the Nest points don't have Ethernet, so I can't check that speed.The house is 1,328 sq ft. I just need a system that gets my speeds better for both downstairs and upstairs, as it is needed in both areas.

Reddit IconCreamCapital
4 months ago

I finally got sick of restarting my Nest Wifi manually every two days when my wifi would inevitably stop working. Switched to TP-Link DECO. Oh my god why did it wait so long, It’s been flawless for over a month. Don’t ever have to think about it. Google abandoned this product. If you’re thinking about switching, do it.

4 months ago

Nest Gen 2. Never look back man. Switch and sell the Nest while they still have value

Reddit Icondeztructo
10 months ago

No issues. Frankly it's people not following directions or the app itself not completing certain functions. Others are just people not wiring correctly or being impatient during setup. Some of the stalling setup issues I have encountered and can be resolved by force quitting the app and crossing your fingers that you don't have to start all over. BTW, if you are technically inclined installing OpenWRT on your old Google WiFi pucks breathes alot of life into them. Setup is not easy, but it's very rewarding. In fact I recommend using one as an access point with a different WiFi name added to your MESH. Perhaps even one that is dedicated to IOT devices and guests.

10 months ago

If you mean the Google WiFi 1st gen white pucks, you are **long overdue** for security patches. Last firmware update was [3 years ago](https://support.google.com/googlenest/answer/13800967?hl=en). If you are technically inclined you can install OpenWRT on it or at the bare minimum upgrade the primary Internet facing puck to 2nd gen (Nest WiFi 1st gen). However, thatis probably next to be 'forgotten'. If you can find it cheap, it'll be worth it.

Reddit IconDopamine-Boost
7 months ago

Price point and basic reliable functionality are key for me. Just bought over the weekend at Best Buy the Google Nest Wifi Pro 6e, 3 pack, at the discounted price of $250. After seeing the routers using the latest 7 Standard, but most priced $500-$999–TP-Link, Asus, NetGear, etc—I said no thanks. For my level of use in our home, the 6e is a really good deal. And many devices in our home are in the Google ecosystem. My Google Nest Wifi (2nd Gen) was good for over 5 years. I started to have issues that I could not resolve. The internet connection from Spectrum is good and so is the modem. I’ve read that on average the previous Google routers have a life span of 3-5 years. I’m not sure I believe that just like mechanics saying you to change your oil every 3K miles. However, I’ll take the 5+ years of life I got out of the 2nd generation Google Nest Wifi. I’m curious whether I’ll get 5 years out of this 6e router, which I’d be content with. Fingers crossed.

Reddit Iconeditorreilly
6 months ago

I bought mine in '21 as an upgrade to my Google nest router which couldn't hack all my smart stuff. The pro 6 handled it without a problem and still runs strong with 50+ devices

Top Mesh Wifi Systems on Reddit

1
eero Pro 6 Series

eero

Pro 6 Series

82% positive of 175 users

Easy, reliable, smart home ready; but paid features.

2
TP-Link Deco XE75 Pro

TP-Link

Deco XE75 Pro

80% positive of 117 users

Great coverage, easy; but unreliable Ethernet, poor app.

3
eero eero Max 7

eero

eero Max 7

80% positive of 114 users

Incredibly fast, reliable; but very expensive, limited control.

4
eero eero Pro 7

eero

eero Pro 7

78% positive of 106 users

Fast, reliable; but paid features, needs internet to function.

5
eero eero 7

eero

eero 7

85% positive of 71 users

Easy, reliable coverage; but no 6GHz, paid features.

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs