Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#48 in

Outdoor Sleeping Bags

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score67% positive
16
2
6
Last updated: Jun 19, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconDefAtom
11 months ago

I use a summer quilt for warm nights and an Enlightened Equipment Enigma 20°F (950 fill power) quilt for colder ones. And my pad is thermarest neoair nxt r4.5.

Reddit Icondowningdown
7 months ago

I used [Apex100](https://www.reddit.com/r/Ultralight/s/7ZnTBu2xdk). I am also a super cold sleeper. My [20F EE Enigma](https://imgur.com/a/2s5OIhf) with all my layers is cold at 35°F. I do have to insist that a 660g 8 to 9°C comfort bag sucks, no matter how cold OP sleeps. Especially comparing to my diy quilt which is similarly rated, way lighter and sythetic. I mean, the weight difference is so much that you could layer an entire additional [3°C comfort rated Cumulus quilt](https://cumulus.equipment/en/eu/p/quilts-and-comforters-neo-quilt-300) on top, be waaay overkill for even the coldest of sleepers, and still be lighter than the rab piece of junk.

25 days ago

>I was absolutely freezing all night >Current setup: 20° EE quilt There’s your problem, read more below. Others have said that your pad is the weak point, but at above freezing, it should have been adequate. However, if you are loosing heat to the ground, adding clothing layers really doesn’t help, so despite your seemingly overkill setup, the pad may in fact be the weak link. Otherwise (from a fellow cold sleeper) down pants make a huge difference for boosting the warmth of your sleep system. I know EE quilts work for many people, but ignoring their racism, the design sucks and has several features that compound negatively unless conditions are close to ideal/you are lucky/you are extremely skilled: -extremely long (12+ft) baffles that promote down shift and cold spots. Even if a baffle is perfectly filled there will be some down movement, and the larger the baffle, the larger this cold spot will be. Also, the U-shaped baffles are a straight up cost cutting decision since there are less chambers to fill (the high price does not reflect this). -no differential cut. Differential cut (smaller inner fabric, larger outer fabric) helps maintain the 3D shape of baffles and stabilizes down. No diff cut plus super long baffles equals even worse performance (unless down is perfectly distributed and stays that way). -limit rated. Quilt will sleep colder / be heavier than expected. Granted many makers use limit rating, but the best regarded ones don’t. Limit rating plus no diff cut plus long baffles equals bad performance. FWIW, I have a 20°F EE quilt and a 20°F WM bag. The bag sleeps true to the rating while the quilt looks like a straight up piece of crap next to it. Based on the performance and specs, I estimate I would have to upgrade to a 0°F quilt plus hood to get the same performance as the WM bag, but the quilt will be *heavier*, only $30 cheaper and still have all the bad design choices mentioned above.

Reddit IconFickle-Moment-9472
5 months ago

I have an EE Revelation 850 & an EE Enigma 950. Both 20°, 10D inner and outer. I haven’t had any problems with drafts or down leakage in either but the 850 fill is significantly warmer and doesn’t have issues with down migrating. I will soon be selling the 950 because it just isn’t warm enough.

Reddit Iconfleuron01
4 months ago

EE quilts are straight up poorly designed too. Their baffles shift down to the sides and EE was a well-documented down under-filler before they finally owned up to it. Between the two, Katabatic is a far better buy.

Reddit Iconpeptodismal13
11 months ago

My SO sleeps cold. Thermarest Trail Pro - they used to make a women's specific one. I may upgrade this to the Nemo Tensor All Season for a holiday gift. Feathered Friends Egret - I take this from her when I go climbing it's so cozy I sleep warm- I freaking cook: Nemo Tensor All Season EE Enigma 30 950 fill

Reddit Iconratcnc
7 months ago

Marmot Mad River 0° is currently on sale at REI for $250. Kelty Cosmic Down 0° is the standard inexpensive option. EE *has* had their quilts on sale recently. If you want to go the quilt route you should be able to get a 0° Enigma for around $400. That will be your lightest and most compact option.

Top Outdoor Sleeping Bags on Reddit

1
NEMO Disco 15 Series

NEMO

Disco 15 Series

79% positive of 114 users

Spacious spoon shape, but bulky and inconsistent warmth.

Check priceAmazon
2
Hammock Gear Classic Burrow 20°F

Hammock Gear

Classic Burrow 20°F

89% positive of 27 users

Budget-friendly quilt; very warm, but not ultralight.

$239 Hammock Gear
3
NEMO Disco 30

NEMO

Disco 30

84% positive of 31 users

Roomy spoon shape, but bulky and prone to zipper snags.

Check priceAmazon
4
Katabatic Gear Alsek 22°F Quilt

Katabatic Gear

Alsek 22°F Quilt

84% positive of 25 users

Premium quality, very warm, but high price for weight.

$379 Katabatic Gear
5
Neve Gear Waratah

Neve Gear

Waratah

94% positive of 17 users

Great warmth-to-weight and value, but untreated down.

$265 Neve Gear

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs