That’s funny because I was going to add unless it’s for someone else lol.
On that note, how often does your wife go? I have a Katabatic Palisade, it is THE nicest item of gear I own. Unless you believe your wife will be jealous of the Katabatic, it is up to you to decide if it’s worth the extra $200 or so depending on how often she goes.
If it was my girlfriend I would let her use whatever she felt was warmer and I would take the other. Likely meaning I sleep in the HG haha
As others have said, the Katabatic is the choice. However the Katabatic is comfort rated, so an EE 20 is like a 30 deg Palisade. I am not familiar with PCT temps but you may be able to get away with a Palisade. I sleep warm to 20 on a CCF pad.
Katabatic uses a wind-resistant shell (one reason I switched a few years back when they resized their quilts) so the quilt will feel more substantial for a given amt of down fill.
I get no drafts in my Katabatic Palisade though it’s tougher to compress into a smaller pack.
I’ll echo someone else here in recommending a Katabatic quilt. I have a very similar sleep style to you and the Palisade 30 is my favorite piece of sleep system gear I own. With Katabatic’s differential cut, I’ve found I don’t need to use the strap / cord system to keep it snug enough around me (I also have an Enlightened Equipment quilt and the difference is noticeable).
I had a Disco 15 briefly. Nice bag, but I’ve had the Palisade 30 in similar temperatures (just a touch below freezing) and been just as comfortable.
Dragonfly is a great tent. Have the 1p version and love it.
Agree with others about the Nemo pillow for side sleepers. I like the quality so I’m still stubbornly using it, but I need to make a change.
Edit to add: I really like the QuickDraw filter. I bought a second one to use as a loaner and the flow rate was much worse than my first — filed a warranty claim and replacement was easy. Soak it overnight before using it.
> likely the Durston usual suspects
Why? There are so many more options to consider, and those are relatively heavy.
> I struggle with cold legs and feet if my sleeping system is inadequate
Same. Alpha leggings, insulated booties are key.
> Aiming for around a 10 lb baseweight (light, but not gram counting extreme ultralight)
No need for then hyperbole here. "Gram counting extreme ultralight" is a 4 lb baseweight. There's nothing extreme about 10 lbs. you can get down to like 7-8 lbs while still being fairly conventional
> Katabatic Palisade 30
That'll do
> Thermarest XLite
That'll do
> Would likely also include a 1/8th inch closed cell foam as a base and sit pad
You don't need to do that. Carry one sleeping pad. If you want foam, carry foam. There are many benefits to it. But don't carry foam *and* an inflatable
> I’d be concerned that the Palisade might not be warm enough for shoulder season
It will be fine. Supplement it with clothing as necessary. You can always increase quilt insulation with clothing, but you can't reduce it
> The decision on Regular Width vs Wide is still a big question mark.
Why? You said you're 5'9", 145 lbs and scrawny, youre aiming for 10 lbs or less, and you came to /r/ultralight for advice... given all that, there is no reason in the world that you need a wide pad
Fwiw, I'm only slightly larger than you, and I slept happily at Rae Lakes this past August with an R 2 torso-length foam pad, and a 40F quilt. But obviously September is different.
Top Outdoor Sleeping Bags on Reddit
1
NEMO
Disco 15 Series
79% positive of 114 users
Spacious for side sleepers; bulky, temp rating optimistic.
Additional_Lie6388
