Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#22 in

Outdoor Sleeping Bags

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score76% positive
13
1
3
Last updated: Apr 28, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconDecent-Goat-5289
8 months ago

I just got the magma 30 and would recommend. Compact, lightweight, and very cozy.

Reddit IconFun_With_Math
7 months ago

It got down to 25 while in my 35 degree comfort rated REI magma down sleeping bag. I had pad with R-value of 2.5. I wore non-cotton thermals from Walmart. I slept great. I'm also a 6' tall 185lb man that likes the cold. I think that matters. I wouldn't suggest that setup for everyone. Also, the weather had been warmer previously so the ground temp wasn't that low.

Reddit IconJaded-Tumbleweed1886
10 months ago

I have both Wind Hard Tiny quilts (the pro only came out within the last year) and an older model REI Magma 30 (grey outside, orange inside, sewn footbox), and the Magma is noticeably nicer on the skin than the Aegismax quilts. They are incredible insulation for the dollar but I do believe that if you spend more dollars you get a better product in this particular case.

Reddit Iconpash1k
12 months ago

Magma 30 is pretty good. Make sure you have a good sleeping pad, r value of at least 3.

Reddit Iconkrampus1689
4 months ago

- ditch the wipes for biodegradable - ditch the multitool, good knife is all you’ll need. I use mossy oak and they have withheld for years. - MSR pocket rocket has been a super small and great camp stove for me, these cheap amazon brands I would be cautious of. - do not get that sleeping pad. It’s cheap and will be extremely uncomfortable and only good for summer. I use flextail gear mummy pad and my wife uses Hikenture 6.2 r value sleeping pad. Both comfortable and warm. Hikenture is more noisy but easy availability and cheaper. - can’t speak on the tent but a free standing is better for new campers. - sleeping bag is going to be very bulky. Try to find a 20F ultralight bag. I can’t speak on specific brands. I use a 30F REI mummy bag and it’s been good but I’m in the market for a new one too. This Coleman will not fit in a backpack. Your biggest expense will be your sleeping system. Don’t cheap out here especially if you plan on doing fall and spring trips.

Reddit IconAlaskanarrowusa
3 months ago

You want a bag that’s rated for real cold, not just “summer temps” so a bag rated around 20°F (–6°C) to 30°F (–1°C) is the practical sweet spot for those conditions. With that said, your pad is decent and pairing that with a bag that actually matches the sleeping pad’s insulation would keep you warm bottom-to-top instead of leaving a cold gap at your torso. The 75-liter pack size you have also gives you enough volume for a real backpacking-appropriate bag like either: - the REI Co-op Magma 30°F Or - Feathered Friends Flicker 20°F / Down Or - Mountain Hardwear Lamina Z-AI 20°F Which I personally think are all really good for your use case, the REI Co-op being my personal choice if I had to choose. Otherwise, try [11 Best 2-Person Tents for Camping and Backpacking](https://alaskanarrows.com/11-best-2-person-tent-camping-and-backpacking/) for other options GL

Reddit IconFinal_Razzmatazz_274
6 months ago

Did you get the new magma 15? I got each the 30 and the 15 and while I love them, I feel like there’s such a huge gap in temp conditions. The 15 I’ve slept in down to about 22 and it was WAY too warm still. If I slept in the 30 down to 22 I’d undoubtedly be cold. I just think it’s bizarre they came out with two bags that seemingly have a huge gap.

Reddit IconFurrypocketpussy
13 days ago

I got a kammock firebelly that I found at the REI garage sale. Been pretty happy with it, but would probably go for an REI magma or thermarest if I were to get a new one

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: