
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Reddit Reviews
The Marshall speakers sound significantly better than the JBLs, and can go for 12+ hours easily. Better bass response than the JBL, plus they look cool as hell, like a little Marshall guitar cabinet. https://www.marshall.com/us/en/speakers/bluetooth/portable
Marshall Middleton first gen. It’s a heavy beast but has the best balance. JBL has the best software but the sound profile is fatiguing. The ULT 3 is boomy compared to the better balanced ULT 1 and excellent ULT 7. Emberton 2 has great vocal clarity but not much bass. Middleton corrects that shortcoming. It’ll work well with what you listen to.
Not sure how light you packing, but the Marshall Middleton weighs 3.8 pounds, the Marshall Emberton II weighs 1.5 pounds…both sound amazing to my ears and I love playin em paired.
Great point. I take mine a lotta places, dusty places like camping and the beach. It’s been dropped on cement. Spilled stuff on it. Zero issues. And of course they pair with other same era Marshalls like embertons. And that’s the 1… afaik, the 2 ups the rating from Gen 1 —IPX7 ( waterproof not dust-proof) …to Gen2 IP67 both waterproof and dust-proof Also supposedly more base presence and even better sound staging. Also better volume levels and at full volume less distortion and bass drop ( it’s a bit of an issue but I usually don’t have it at full blast) My 1’s sound awesome as they are. Partly due to the fact that there’s actually 4 speakers on every side, afaik that’s quite unique. I lovem and would definitely recommend either them or the 2’s — Battery life jumps from not bad 20 hours to a more decent 30 on the 2’s. Wattage climbs from 20 to 30 watts. It’s pretty intriguing this review. Seems to say that the version 2 loses the stack daisy chain feature in favour of AuralCast which for me is a negative. If true. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7K-9rXsUKVQ
Amen they are surprisingly heavy to lug 2 of em around. Them there big drivers, battery and big ass-bass ain’t light. Lot of times I just grab the Marshall Middletons. Not as much bass n power but enough…and they’re a fraction of the heft required to pick em up.
The Marshall Middleton line has Aux in and low latency. It’s what I hook my OP-XY up to when I travel.
Dont sleep on that middleton. I got 2 of them to stereo and it sounded rich but compare to its older siblings like tufton, acton or stanmore the middleton is a little digitally processed but besides that since yiu got the money for xtreme then I suggest you get the killburns 2/3.0 and it sounds better than middleton and louder for its size.
I wouldn't expect too much from it if I were you. You'll get a real performance boost if you opt for a larger speaker, such as the Marshall Middleton for example.
I'd go with the Sony ULT 7 for a large speaker, and for a smaller speaker that also produces all frequencies, I'd choose the Marshall Middleton, because of the stereo separation which is superb in my opinion.
The Marshall Middleton 1 or 2, would fit the bill in your situation. The low volume Bass, and the soundstage is quite fantastic, with most genres of music playing under 50% volume.
I have the Middleton by Marshall and that thing is amazing! It's loud has good base. The only thing I hate is the control. But you can control it through your phone.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Audiobooks and podcasts

Top pick
Anker - Select 4 Go
Best for Audiophile-grade sound

Top pick
Harman Kardon - Go + Play 3
Best for Backpacking and hiking

Top pick
LG Electronics - XBOOM Grab
Best for Boating and kayaking

Top pick
soundcore - Boom 3i
Best for Outoor parties and large gatherings

Top pick
JBL - PartyBox 520
Best for Quiet home listening

Top pick
Bose - SoundLink Flex Series





