Axe and Sledge Farm Fed

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#69 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score90% positive
9
0
1
Last updated: Jun 16, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconBestSmokerEU
4 months ago

Axe and Sledge Farmfed is a whey isolate and they've got some incredible flavours available. 25g of protein per serve, 1g carb and 1g fat.

Reddit Iconcorpseplague
8 months ago

Na it hurts my stomach, gas. My go-to is now Axe & Sledge Farm Fed 100% Isolate. If a powder is not pure isolate it bothers my stomach.

Reddit IconNo_Explorer_1290
4 months ago

I bought their peanut butter and honey flavor to try.... needless to say I ended up placing another order and now have a few extra on deck and also grabbed a cold brew and their brown sugar pop tart variety to try next. Really liking them and Tranparent lab products latelym

Reddit IconObsessiveIndecisive
3 months ago

Farmfed whey, lean why by nutrisport and pescience select. The last one is the best of the group but they’re all good.

Reddit IconOpposite_Fondant5364
9 months ago

Axe and sledge Grass Fed Vanilla Milkshake is a very good brand imo. Also GNC basic vanilla I feel is pretty damn tasty

Reddit IconAggressive-Elk8139
8 months ago

Hey guys, For some reason I I don’t like some of the “goated” mainstream protein powders. I was so addicted I would just us water + ryse protein powder and that would be enough, however addictions slowly fade away and you start cravings some luxurious tasting stuff. **What I love but now kind of bored of:** * Ryse protein (Chocolate cookie blast, Peanut Butter cup, Cosmic Brownie), I have eaten 6 pints per day of these for about a year. Served me well * Ghost whey (Slowly hated the chip’s ahoy, noticed it wasn’t rly my cup of tea, I loved the Coffee Ice cream) * Muscle Sport Lean Whey (overall I did not mind the flavors, I can finish a tub even tho it wasn’t my favorite flavor) * PandaSupps (I like their formulations but need to find the perfect flavor, ordered some more) **What I tried and rly tried to love but couldn’t:** * PEScience, I tried so many times and so many flavors, they just never hit home for me. (chocolate truffle, CnC was very cream heavy) * 1up, their protein powders were rly cream flavor heavy * Axe and Sledge (C&C, Chocolate macadamia) * Legion (Salted caramel, dutch chocolate) * Transparent labs (used to love their dark chocolate but flavor was too mild after a while) * Myprotein (Several chocolate flavor, salted caramel) * Jocko Molk (chocolate, didn’t mind it but didn’t topple ryse, wasn’t worth it for me) * Applied Nutrition (Choco Beuno, White choco Beuno) * Isopure (chocolate) * Mre Lite (Chocolate, Fudge Brownie) * Clean Simple Eats (brownie batter) * Dymatize (Cocoa Pebbles, flavor weren’t rly strong for me) * Ekkovision (Tiramisu, Brownie batter) * Fairlile milk + vanilla extract was abysmal IMO * Orgain (tasted rly weird, maybe its the plant-based formulation) * Optimum Nutiriton (l was hesitant to put this, last time I used it was 2022/23, at the time it wasn’t rly good, but they could have improved so. I tried their chocolate/vanilla, milk was okay but with water, I didn’t like it) **Btw: this has been a very expensive trial and error but worth it.** **Final notes:** It sounds like I am a pain to recommend to, hopefully someone as messed up as me can be helped. As you notice I am chocolate heavy advocate, Idm a vanilla here and there if it’s amazing, lean whey and panda supps vanilla are great. **Flavors I despise, (or maybe haven't tasted good one):** * I don’t like mint (non-negotiable) * pure peanut butter flavored * fruity/cream heavy flavors as you see. For example strawberry shortcake by ryse was more cake/cream than pure strawberry. **Possible flavor/goals:** * I guess the best case scenario for me would be a great vanilla which I think I have, but have never found a good salted caramel (awaiting my panda supps order) * Also Biscoff (cookie butter) * But as you see I like chocolate, chocolate hazelnut, Ferraro Roche/Nutella vibes I get tempted to re-order most protein I don’t like from the sheer positive reviews they get. **Attempts:** I have tried normal cacao, very expensive dutch powders, black cacaos and expensive vanilla bean extracts. They all just try and mask the protein flavor and are dominant, I don’t like the intense dry pure cacao flavor For example when I use a 1Tbsp of Dutch chocolate it overrides any flavor and I just taste that powder, it doesn't seem to blend, just overpower. If i use too little, I can't even sense it's there. I like rich/luxurious gelato/Haagen-Dazs/Lindt vibes. Sorry for the long post. I hope I am not being annoying and hope someone can help me out 😭. Edit: I don’t mind other solutions as well, anything that would work and is not a calorie bomb. I am trying to replicate PinkBerry’s Chocolate Hazelnut rn, I hate normal yogurt and love Greek. I know Pinkberry uses yogurt but their chocolate hazelnut is heavenly.

Top Protein Powder on Reddit

1
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

Optimum Nutrition

Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

76% positive of 1,009 users

Trusted brand, great taste; but price hikes and quality dips.

$36 Amazon
2
Dymatize (BellRing Brands) ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

Dymatize (BellRing Brands)

ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

88% positive of 188 users

Hydrolyzed isolate, easy on stomach; but pricey with sucralose.

$33 Amazon
3
Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

Transparent Labs

Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

96% positive of 82 users

Clean, third-party tested, easy digestion; but premium price.

$59 Amazon
4
Kirkland Signature (Costco) Whey Protein

Kirkland Signature (Costco)

Whey Protein

72% positive of 454 users

Budget king; good value, but poor mixability and digestion.

$54 Costco
5
Oath Nutrition Clear Whey Protein Powder

Oath Nutrition

Clear Whey Protein Powder

97% positive of 68 users

Refreshing fruit juice-like taste; gentle, but pricey per serving.

$32 Amazon

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs