Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#68 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score91% positive
10
1
0
Last updated: May 30, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Icon0fearless-garbage0
10 months ago

Bob's Red Mill Whey Protien Powder. : )

10 months ago

Would recommend using it in smoothies with greek yogurt too, as it increases volume and makes it fluffy.

Reddit Iconcazort2
3 months ago

I only ever buy unflavored whey concentrate, which I buy from Bob's Red Mill. It's a brand that specializes in baking and not supplements, so it selects for flavor more than the brands that sell whey primarily as a supplement. This pattern plays out across many ingredients. I also don't recommend ever buying 5 pounds of anything that you haven't tried. If you're gonna buy that much of something, buy a smaller amount first, or find someone you know who already has it and you can try it once, so you know what you're getting into. Whey is really expensive; you don't want to blow money on something you won't enjoy.

Reddit Iconchromacrawl
6 months ago

Bobs red mill whey powder is flavorless and can be added to a ton of stuff

Reddit Iconcraigleary
8 months ago

Bobs red mill whey for just whey and no junk. Mixes well varies and the ones that mix better will have some junk in it. If you took bobs and added a little vanilla or chocolate and a slight amount of sugar it will taste even better.

Reddit IconFearless_Mistake_400
7 months ago

Garden of Life Whey Protein Bob's Red Mills Whey Protein Nutricost Bob's Red Mills Almond Protein All have little to no extra ingredients, just simple Whey Isolate or Concentrate. None of them has sucralose. It's best to purchase frozen berries in bulk and create your taste w/ a blender, i.e. strawberry or wildberries. This way, you also get Fiber.

Reddit IconFireWoman89
3 months ago

Lots of protein powders use artificial sweeteners, too. Bob’s Red Mill whey protein does not. You could also try Manitoba Harvest.

3 months ago

I don’t use any artificial sweeteners of any kind (I don’t trust them at all), so I know how hard it is to find protein shakes without them. I use Kate Farms: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08FNSZP6X?ref=nb_sb_ss_w_as-reorder-mobile_k0_1_4&=&crid=13YU8FWZWV78R&=&sprefix=kate Kate Farms has a few different lines of shakes. This is the only one that doesn’t have artificial sweeteners.

Reddit Iconkittycatblues
4 months ago

I have used Natural Factors Whey Factors unflavored or Bob's Red Mill whey protein (unflavored) when I want a whey protein without sweeteners. I've used Now brand egg white protein powder too but usually in recipes and not in shakes as it has some different properties because it is made from eggs. I think you'll be hard pressed to find a flavored whey protein with no sweeteners unless you are ok with sweeteners like stevia or monk fruit, which I can't tell from your post as some people consider them "natural sweeteners" even though they are highly refined. Personally I think those taste worse than artificial sweeteners like sucralose so I don't usually use them.

Reddit IconLondonIsMyHeart
6 months ago

I do the same thing, along with chia and flax. Anyway, my go to brand for unflavored protein powder is Bob's Red Mill, from Amazon. It's so HARD to find it unflavored!

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: