Good Protein All-in-One Shake

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#40 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score90% positive
9
1
0
Last updated: May 6, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconAlexis_chap
3 months ago

We just brought Good Protein Chocolate Fudge All-in-One Shake, 2kg and then this is what we always buy Isopure Clear Protein, Tropical Punch, 1.25 kg, Alani Protein Shake Cookies N Cream, chocolate BioX Power Whey Complex 2.27kg not at Costco from Popeyes supplement,

Reddit IconEnoughMongoose
8 months ago

I really like Good Protein but it is quite sweet. I have the vanilla cupcake flavour. I typically just blend it with water, ice and a banana and it’s delicious. I’ve also used it in pancakes and muffins and it worked great!

Reddit IconGlitchyFinnigan
about 2 months ago

I haven't noticed it being grainy, but it is really fine and clumps easily

Reddit Iconkipnus
9 months ago

I like this brand: [https://goodprotein.ca/](https://goodprotein.ca/) I put it in oatmeal and smoothies.

Reddit IconLibertinelass
about 2 months ago

Love Good Protein. I have a subscription. They often throw in gifts like a reusable tote and vegan collagen. Love them for this. Customer service is fantastic too.

Reddit IconRepulsive-Soup-5137
about 2 months ago

It’s uses Reb-M, derived from stevia, without the gross stevia taste

about 2 months ago

It’s considerably cheaper with the sale at Costco than vs the site.  $79.99, with $16.00 off for $63.99. And for a 2kg bag. GP only has 440g & 880 bags on their site.  Your first order for the subscription is 40% off, so 37.19 (vs 61.99) for 880g. So, $3.20/100g @ Costco with sale price vs $4.23/100g @ GP for first S&S order, vs $7.04/100g if buying it at regular price for GP. 

about 2 months ago

I’ve even gotten it off Amazon (during Prime Days) for cheaper than thru GP. Plus I always have delivery issues with GP. With S&S, I think I’m now at lifetime 25% off… but since Vanilla Milkshake is my preferred flavour anyway, I grabbed 3 bags, so shouldn’t need to order for some time 😅

Reddit Iconsciencenerd647
about 2 months ago

I use a shaker with cold water for my 2:30pm snack at work and i don’t find it grainy. I find it a bit think so I use a bit more water. Taste like chocolate milk and I’ve been able to cut down on sugar cravings by using that instead as it keeps me full

Reddit Icontaramichelly
5 months ago

Good Protein is Canadian and also really delicious, it's the only one I've enjoyed because it doesn't have that weird gritty aftertaste. We add frozen fruit to it when we blend it and it makes it taste more like a milkshake!

5 months ago

It's a brand, no clue about their testing standards but I'm sure their website would have the information? [https://goodprotein.ca/](https://goodprotein.ca/)

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: