Macro Mike

Peanut Butter Protein

Macro Mike Peanut Butter Protein

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#80 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score75% positive
15
1
4
Last updated: May 1, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Icon711989
about 2 months ago

Macro Mike, hands down. The peanut flavours I think don't have probiotics. It's expensive and I hate the gimmicky marketing, but it's undeniably the best tasting brand. Nuzest is just okay. I found myself adding extra ingredients (peanut butter or fruit) to make it taste better. Bulk Nutrients Earth protein I hated, threw out half the sample pack. Their soy isolate is very good for baking though - I like to make baked oats with it.

Reddit IconConstant-Tree7055
6 months ago

I’m a macro Mike fan but I much prefer their almond protein over their peanut protein flavours. I find all the peanut protein flavours just taste like peanuts but the almond actually tastes like the marketed flavours. They’ve just released a pea protein which I’ve purchased but yet to try.

Reddit IconEffableFornent
4 months ago

I can't do the dairy proteins, so I got some of the Macro Mike sample packs... I think the peanut based ones are great! The almond ones have a bitterness in not keen on. 

Reddit IconFeudalist
8 months ago

It might not be available outside of Australia but the brand Macro Mike makes the best tasting. Their chocolate flavoured peanut protein tastes like drinking a Reece’s chocolate cup

Reddit Icon_greentrees
3 months ago

Macro Mike (especially the peanut butter one), PranaOn or NutraOrganics strawberries and cream

Reddit Iconlaura_ann86
11 months ago

Macro Mike. The almond-based ones are the best (golden gay time is 👌), but the peanut ones are still good. No chalkiness, really smooth. I actually look forward to drinking them. The protein waters are nice too, but have more of an artificial flavour. I can’t fault the protein shakes at all.

Reddit IconTimelyAd9556
6 months ago

Bondi Protein Co for me. $24 for 800g on special at chemist warehouse. Dissolves super easy in rice milk. Macro Mike peanut based flavours are disgusting in my opinion. The almond based ones are good. But price is far too expensive.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: