Macro Mike

Peanut Butter Protein

Macro Mike Peanut Butter Protein

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#71 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score80% positive
20
1
4
Last updated: May 21, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Icon711989
3 months ago

Macro Mike, hands down. The peanut flavours I think don't have probiotics. It's expensive and I hate the gimmicky marketing, but it's undeniably the best tasting brand. Nuzest is just okay. I found myself adding extra ingredients (peanut butter or fruit) to make it taste better. Bulk Nutrients Earth protein I hated, threw out half the sample pack. Their soy isolate is very good for baking though - I like to make baked oats with it.

Reddit IconConstant-Tree7055
7 months ago

I’m a macro Mike fan but I much prefer their almond protein over their peanut protein flavours. I find all the peanut protein flavours just taste like peanuts but the almond actually tastes like the marketed flavours. They’ve just released a pea protein which I’ve purchased but yet to try.

Reddit IconEffableFornent
4 months ago

I can't do the dairy proteins, so I got some of the Macro Mike sample packs... I think the peanut based ones are great! The almond ones have a bitterness in not keen on. 

Reddit IconFeudalist
9 months ago

It might not be available outside of Australia but the brand Macro Mike makes the best tasting. Their chocolate flavoured peanut protein tastes like drinking a Reece’s chocolate cup

Reddit Icon_greentrees
4 months ago

Macro Mike (especially the peanut butter one), PranaOn or NutraOrganics strawberries and cream

Reddit IconIndependent-Idea8446
Reddit Iconlaura_ann86
11 months ago

Macro Mike. The almond-based ones are the best (golden gay time is 👌), but the peanut ones are still good. No chalkiness, really smooth. I actually look forward to drinking them. The protein waters are nice too, but have more of an artificial flavour. I can’t fault the protein shakes at all.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: