Myprotein Impact Whey Protein

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#53 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score61% positive
58
15
22

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: May 20, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconAnxietySalt5203
3 months ago

My bruddas, cant go wrong with extreme milk chocolate. But i drink it with milk. I recently switched over from myprotein. So far i have tried, Myprotein milk tea - 3.5/5 Drinkable, finished 2.5kg worth. But had a weird aftertaste. Drank with water Salted caramel - 1.5/5 The artificial taste and the aftertaste killed me. I wasted 2.5kg worth of protein. Drank with water Optimum Nutrition Double choco - 3/5 Drinkable but weird after taste. Drank with water Extreme milk choco - 5/5 My new love.

3 months ago

My bruddas, cant go wrong with extreme milk chocolate. But i drink it with milk. I recently switched over from myprotein. So far i have tried, Myprotein milk tea - 3.5/5 Drinkable, finished 2.5kg worth. But had a weird aftertaste. Drank with water Salted caramel - 1.5/5 The artificial taste and the aftertaste killed me. I wasted 2.5kg worth of protein. Drank with water Optimum Nutrition Double choco - 3/5 Drinkable but weird after taste. Drank with water Extreme milk choco - 5/5 My new love.

Reddit IconBetArtistic1158
3 months ago

What's your take regarding the safety/contamination aspects? MP is my favorite as well taste-wise (cookies & cream is to die for). I know they have an Origin range that came out recently that's meant to be more "checked".

2 months ago

I tolerate MyProtein Impact Whey reasonably well and it tastes kinda awesome to me. I like Cookies and Cream, Cinnamon Danish, White Chocolate, Vanilla in this order. Chocolate Smooth is kinda bland but it’s good. A bit too harmless and uninteresting to my taste buds but it can be useful for cooking (protein cupcakes and such). Though they contain sweeteners and other processed ingredients, they are one of the few protein powders that don’t sucker punch me with that synthetic sweetness like a lot of products (sugary or sweetened) do. I also like the “play dough” texture that their powders have. I actually like putting two cups of that stuff in one greek yogurt because it becomes kinda like cookie dough. I also like BioTech USA’s isolate (isolate is lower lactose if you’re intolerant or sensitive - I’m not, or not significantly enough). I’ve enjoyed Pistachio, Hazelnut, Coconut, Chocolate in this order. The flavor with BioTech USA is a little more synthetic and overtly sweet but close enough, I guess. The texture is also a bit too fine and powdery for my liking but whatever. — Unflavored whey is also a thing if you wanna stay as natural as possible. There are brands out there that go the extra mile for super ethically and clean-sourced milk but I haven’t gone so far down the rabbit hole as of now. — Following along for other people’s recommendations. 👀 I’m always down to try a new protein powder if it’s good. I wanna try Ghost next, I’ll order some soon.

Reddit Iconcharlotie77
about 1 month ago

You can’t mix it with one or two ingredients and not expect it to taste like protein powder. The key is to make a smoothie with other overpowering ingredients that will mask the taste and/or chalkiness. Myprotein Impact Whey unflavored is basically undetectable in my smoothies. I mix it with milk, Greek yogurt, half a banana, and peanut butter.

14 days ago

Myprotein Impact Whey unflavored. And has an A score on Labdoor

Reddit Iconchupacabrito
10 months ago

For unflavored, I like MyProtein. They have both WPC (impact) and WPI (impact isolate), and both are clean flavors. I buy them all the time to cut flavored powders, since I find most of them too strong and sweet for my liking. The only annoying thing with MyProtein is having to wait for a sale. Their standard prices are way overpriced so you have to wait for good sales and discount codes. Very annoying.

Reddit IconCobraaazzz
11 months ago

Do not take Cinnamon danish though, absolutely disgusting and still 2 more kilo left.

Reddit IconDue_Cartographer8162
10 months ago

I have tried my protein chocolate caramel one and bulk pistachio one both were bad, in the drink I do like having the bulk one but in ice cream it has such a strong taste of protein 😭

Reddit IconEmotional_Isopod_126
8 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

8 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

8 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

8 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

8 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

3 months ago

I ran through about 20kg of myprotein impact whey , they do clump up occasionally but nothing too severe. Though now the pricing q bad so probably considering buying ON again

9 months ago

Anyway 20-24p per scoop is normal across all brands assuming relatively similiar scoop sizes. If not enough just use more scoops. For whey protein MP is pretty much as legit as it gets with cost savings from it's economies of scale. Not sponsored by MP, just been through a lot of MP whey protein 5kg bags.

Reddit IconIhavenocluelad
6 months ago

MyProtein Impact Whey Coconut is my #1 so far. Their cookies and cream sucks though lol

6 months ago

MyProtein Impact Whey Coconut is my #1 so far. Their cookies and cream sucks though lol

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: