Myprotein

Impact Whey Protein

Myprotein Impact Whey Protein

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#40 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score61% positive
47
16
14

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Aug 8, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconcharlotie77
4 months ago

You can’t mix it with one or two ingredients and not expect it to taste like protein powder. The key is to make a smoothie with other overpowering ingredients that will mask the taste and/or chalkiness. Myprotein Impact Whey unflavored is basically undetectable in my smoothies. I mix it with milk, Greek yogurt, half a banana, and peanut butter.

3 months ago

Myprotein Impact Whey unflavored. And has an A score on Labdoor

Reddit IconD_Buck1
2 months ago

Myprotein white chocolate, sometimes have it as a shake, but add it to overnight oats to give extra protein and a sweet taste.

Reddit IconEmotional_Isopod_126
11 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

11 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

11 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

11 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

3 months ago

Sweet - strawberry cream Vanilla-like - salted caramel These 2. Matcha latte I suspect the flavor changed lol so I stopped buying after going through a few 5kg bags Now I buy muscletech instead since mp price difference not that much

3 months ago

Sweet - strawberry cream Vanilla-like - salted caramel These 2. Matcha latte I suspect the flavor changed lol so I stopped buying after going through a few 5kg bags Now I buy muscletech instead since mp price difference not that much

3 months ago

Sweet - strawberry cream Vanilla-like - salted caramel These 2. Matcha latte I suspect the flavor changed lol so I stopped buying after going through a few 5kg bags Now I buy muscletech instead since mp price difference not that much

6 months ago

I ran through about 20kg of myprotein impact whey , they do clump up occasionally but nothing too severe. Though now the pricing q bad so probably considering buying ON again

11 months ago

Myprotein handsdown, just buy during cyber Monday for best pricing which I've observed over the years. IIRC can buy approx 12.5kg of normal impact whey before hitting the $400 gst threshold, then store it and use it across 1-2 years. Flavors that I've tried in bulk are matcha latte (recent reformulations made it blander), strawberry cream (GOAT). Also strongly recommend salted caramel. Can't remember which vanilla flavor I tried but q decent.

12 months ago

Anyway 20-24p per scoop is normal across all brands assuming relatively similiar scoop sizes. If not enough just use more scoops. For whey protein MP is pretty much as legit as it gets with cost savings from it's economies of scale. Not sponsored by MP, just been through a lot of MP whey protein 5kg bags.

Reddit IconFireGuilt
3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

3 months ago

In my experience, all the chocolate-based ones from Myprotein are better and more portable. Chocolate brownie, plain chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, etc. The more 'plain' ones, like Hokkaido milk, banana, and vanilla, are alright, but I'm not particularly crazy about the flavours. Meh flavours are unfortunately matcha (which I had high hopes for). However, I find that all the 'sweet' ones tend to taste good at first but become very cumbersome to drink especially if you drink often and gym often. Like, I get so turned off by the sweetness of things like golden syrup and cheesecake. However, as other redditors mentioned, one good hack is to use milk instead of just water. It really changes some of them up in a good way, but unfortunately, that also means added calories.

Reddit Icongreekbodybuilding
2 months ago

The myprotein impact whey unflavored, tastes like watered down milk. It mixes well and the flavor is pleasant.

Top Protein Powder on Reddit

1
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

Optimum Nutrition

Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

76% positive of 992 users

Trusted all-rounder, but price hikes and quality decline concern.

2
Dymatize (BellRing Brands) ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

Dymatize (BellRing Brands)

ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

88% positive of 184 users

High-quality hydrolyzed isolate, great taste, but pricey with sucralose concerns.

3
Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

Transparent Labs

Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

96% positive of 80 users

Clean, third-party tested isolate; premium price for quality.

4
Kirkland Signature (Costco) Whey Protein

Kirkland Signature (Costco)

Whey Protein

72% positive of 452 users

Budget king; great value, but clumpy with artificial taste concerns.

5
Oath Nutrition Clear Whey Protein Powder

Oath Nutrition

Clear Whey Protein Powder

97% positive of 68 users

Refreshing, juice-like fruit flavors; pricey, low carb, but gentle.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs