Orgain

Orgain X JUSTIN'S® Organic Plant & Nut Butter Protein Powder

Orgain Orgain X JUSTIN'S® Organic Plant & Nut Butter Protein Powder

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#96 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score71% positive
17
2
5

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Oct 8, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconactuallyamber
8 months ago

I recently found their peanut butter one and it’s my new favorite.

Reddit IconAstridv96
7 months ago

Orgain peanut butter chocolate is the one I like. I blend it with a banana, soy milk and a small spoon of peanut butter. It’s so good

Reddit IconBrilliant-Bother-503
8 months ago

I don't consume artificial sweeteners and prefer one with minimal processed ingredients. I use Orgain peanut butter protein powder.

9 months ago

Orgain plant based peanut butter protein powder has no artificial sweeteners (Stevia is used) and no heavy metals. In addition to being healthy it tastes really good.

10 months ago

Orgain peanut butter plant based protein powder. There are no artificial sweeteners (Stevia is used), and the ingredients are mostly healthy. It tastes great. I mix it with oatmeal, almond milk, and Greek yogurt for breakfast.

5 months ago

Justin’s Orgain peanut butter protein powder. It is a vegan one with no artificial sweeteners and tastes great.

Reddit IconDMenace83
5 months ago

Orgain peanut butter chocolate. Nothing compares to this.

Reddit IconManufacturerOpening6
8 months ago

The peanut butter orgain is my fave! I blend with unsweetened soy and it is quite yummy!

8 months ago

I am a very strict vegetarian and prefer a lot of vegan choices. I buy Orgain made with pea protein. I genuinely hate 98% of protein drinks I have tried, but if you like peanut butter, I think the peanut butter Orgain powder is delicious. I usually make it with soy milk to add extra protein since the powder is only 21g protein. Just make sure the soy milk (or other nut milk) doesnt have a lot of added sugar.

8 months ago

I hate most protein shakes. I am a very strict vegetarian. The Orgain Peanut Butter protein powder (pea protein) is delicious. I make it with unsweetened soy, but it is also great with almond milk and I imagine it would be good with cashew or other nut milks. Just make sure that you blend it with unsweetened so you aren't getting to many sugars. Orgain has a lot of options. My mother likes the vanilla and chocolate, but I am picky.

Reddit Iconmattskee
11 months ago

Basically any non-milk protein powder seems worth a shot.  Orgain has a very weird flavor and texture (IMO) due to their creamer base. A more neutral plant based one is worth a shot. Too many options to list them all personally I like Sunwarrior but it's kind of pricey, so I also use plain soy or pea protein. 

Top Protein Powder on Reddit

1
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

Optimum Nutrition

Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

76% positive of 992 users

Trusted all-rounder, but price hikes and quality decline concern.

2
Dymatize (BellRing Brands) ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

Dymatize (BellRing Brands)

ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder

88% positive of 184 users

High-quality hydrolyzed isolate, great taste, but pricey with sucralose concerns.

3
Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

Transparent Labs

Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

96% positive of 80 users

Clean, third-party tested isolate; premium price for quality.

4
Kirkland Signature (Costco) Whey Protein

Kirkland Signature (Costco)

Whey Protein

72% positive of 452 users

Budget king; great value, but clumpy with artificial taste concerns.

5
Oath Nutrition Clear Whey Protein Powder

Oath Nutrition

Clear Whey Protein Powder

97% positive of 68 users

Refreshing, juice-like fruit flavors; pricey, low carb, but gentle.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs