Vital Proteins (Nestlé Health Science) Collagen Peptides

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#21 in

Protein Powder

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score84% positive
36
4
3
Last updated: May 21, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconauntiems30
3 months ago

I'm with you. I can't stand any artificial sweeteners. No stevia, no sucralose, no monkfruit, nothing. Here's my current homemade daily boost - 1 cup of fairlife fat-free milk (sometimes unsweetened vanilla oatmilk instead), 12 ounces cold brew coffee (sometimes omitted if I'm feeling extra caffeinated already), full serving of vital proteins unflavored collagen peptides (18 grams protein), 1/2 of a miralax dose, 2 tsp of benefiber, and 1/4 cup (about 2/3 of a packet) of chocolate carnation breakfast essentials. This gives me about 3 grams of added sugar (my only source most days) and either 21 or 34 grams of protein depending on which milk I use.

Reddit IconBeautiful_Arrival124
3 months ago

My midwife just recommended protein powder from Thorne which is the brand of prenatals I've been taking! Haven't tried it yet but I get 30% off through her Fullscript. I recently started using Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides from Costco. I'll put that in a smoothie or coffee with whole milk. I've been eating lots of high-protein Greek yogurts, snacking on nuts and pumpkin seeds, meat sticks, toss a frozen salmon patty in the airfryer, ground beef and beans...

Reddit Icondanifx
12 months ago

For protein powder i like Vital Collagen Protein. Great for skin. Whey protein makes me feel yucky. For fiber i do benefiber soluble fiber. Tasteless. And I don’t take electrolytes often so no thoughts on that.

Reddit Iconerouz
29 days ago

It have little smell but not bad not good just different I drink it with juice https://preview.redd.it/j50iiiav5wwg1.jpeg?width=3072&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4689dc3d9466a9b995b8de06dd007f1edb3242fc

28 days ago

https://www.hollandandbarrett.ie/shop/product/vital-proteins-collagen-peptides-unflavoured-6100148487?skuid=051533&utm_campaign=shopping&utm_id=22829054155&utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google&gclsrc=aw.ds&&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=22825070585&gclid=CjwKCAjwhqfPBhBWEiwAZo196sZ63mPKd9AAwlYaiUhan3ctast67ZigsLzTRak-nh6FOvs8hxiYcBoCuwEQAvD_BwE

28 days ago

Question was about taste not price it's what works well for me so I share. There are different make which will be different in price as well.

Reddit IconFlickasMom
10 months ago

I was going to mrntion Vital Protein, too. Zero taste. As I understand it, beef collagen (which this is) is only lacking one amino acid to be a complete protein (and of course I don't remember which one it is).

Reddit IconFooddea
10 months ago

all of the flavored orgain products have sucralose, which has been known to mess with some folks (myself included). the only one I've found at Costco without it is their unflavored collagen powder. finding protein bars, shakes, or flavored powders that don't have sucralose or a ton of sugar in them is a chore. I've gotten to the point that I just mix up a bunch plain, unsweetened powders and milks myself every morning.

10 months ago

I haven't found any flavored Orgain products without sucralose at Costco.. Perhaps yours carries something mine (in the Midwest) doesn't?

Reddit IconIllustrious_Fox1134
12 months ago

Your coffee protein is akin to swallowing wet flour because the structure of the protein is being changed (by the hot liquid). You may want to mix your protein into room temp water before adding to coffee or try one of [these ideas ](https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/protein-for-coffee#directions) ([Source](https://www.nfpt.com/blog/combining-protein-powder-with-hot-liquids) it's referring to whey protein but the science still checks out) I've had success with mixing collagen protein (Vital Protein) with warm liquid. Also, Vital Protein is gluten, dairy, corn and soy free. However, collagen protein isn't a complete protein so it's best to use a supplement (ie in addition to eating other protein sources like meat) and not as a meal replacement

Reddit IconIndigoBlues116
3 months ago

I use unsweetened vital proteins collagen powder (20 G protein) and low fat plain Fairlife milk (13 G protein per cup) and that’s 33 gram of protein in my coffee each morning. I don’t like sweet stuff and especially hate artificial sweeteners, so this is what works for me. I’ll drink the milk alone as well. It’s about $5 per 6 cup bottle, and the vital proteins is about $33 at Costco for 34 servings.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: