ASICS

Magic Speed 4

ASICS Magic Speed 4

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#205 in

Road Running Shoes

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score65% positive
22
6
6
Last updated: Aug 31, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconljustinamarko
6 months ago

Edge ~ VF1,2 EP3, DNE4, you can consider AP4;

6 months ago

In my case Sky and AP 4 feel different as a mid/heel foot striker; Sky is to flat, stiff/firm, and AP4 is soft, more natural or even rolling

Reddit IconSuplexCT
11 months ago

I have them and I agree, they're solid for speed work/race day pero i HATE doing warm up/cooldown paces on them. Sobrang sakit sa binti

Reddit IconTalkyRaptor
8 months ago

The magic speed 4 is very mid, not a good shoe for what it should be. The newer magic speed 5 seems to be basically a stripped down cheaper metaspeed edge tokyo.

Reddit IconJantokan
4 months ago

I own the Megablasts, but don't own the SB3. Megablast is a very fast shoe with not the most comfortable upper. In my opinion, it should be viewed as a plateless racer rather than a do-it-all training shoe like the Superblast. The slowest I can comfortably take it is a marathon paced run. Most comfortable pace is HM to 10km pace. I've taken it all the way to 3km pace, and it's surprisingly stable enough to handle even that. But on easy runs, I struggle a lot with it. It's super duper energetic. The ride experience reminds me a lot of the EVO SL in such a way that it is very energetic and will push you to run fast. Only difference is the Megablast is built like a tank.

6 months ago

I may be one of the very few people who loved the Magic Speed 4 hahahaha I’ve always been a high stack guy— always preferred shoes at 40mm heel stack minimum. The Magic Speed 4 was perfect for me because it had the snappiness I wanted on a workout shoe, durability that is better than race shoes, and the high stack height that I was always looking for. Thank you for your detailed review of the Magic Speed 5. It made me realize that the Magic Speed 4 was probably a one-off shoe that won’t be repeated.

5 months ago

If you can still find them, Magic Speed 4. Firm and snappy, and despite being tall, still very much stable.

4 months ago

If you use it as your tempo shoe, it's a beginner-friendly shoe in that regard. It's also a great shoe if you're a forefoot striker or someone who pushes off a lot. I have owned the Magic Speed 4s up to around 300km before selling it. It's a durable shoe that does an ok job as a tempo shoe. It can handle daily training miles but it's an uncomfortable experience. I personally found the midsole foam to be way too firm, and the plate makes it worse.

Reddit Icon5artlam5
7 months ago

This looks promising. My Magic Speed 4 is way over 500kms and still has some pop for fast sessions. I like the MS4’s firmer foams compared to other super trainers. Been interested in lower stack shoes that can go the distance and this might be one I can consider.

7 months ago

I kinda feel like they became softer now than before. Maybe it’s just me because I’m leaning towards the heavier side it provides enough support for me on speedier sessions.

Reddit IconAccomplished_Tap_382
8 months ago

Asics Magic Speed 4's. They're not technically a daily trainer, but I've been wearing them for the past 7 months (I'm on my 2nd pair now), and I love them - I run 10k, 5/6 days/wk. I tried the Superblasts, Novablasts, Mach 6's, but just couldn't duplicate the feel of the Magic Speeds, so I went back to them.

Top Road Running Shoes on Reddit

1
ASICS SUPERBLAST 2

ASICS

SUPERBLAST 2

71% positive of 805 users

Marathon workhorse, but loud and clunky at slow paces.

2
Nike Vomero Plus

Nike

Vomero Plus

74% positive of 565 users

Ultra-comfortable for long runs, but too bulky for speed.

3
Saucony Endorphin Pro 4

Saucony

Endorphin Pro 4

80% positive of 228 users

Stable race shoe, versatile, but narrow fit, lacks bounce.

4
ASICS Megablast

ASICS

Megablast

72% positive of 457 users

Very durable and versatile, but narrow toe box, causes blisters.

5
Mizuno Neo Zen

Mizuno

Neo Zen

81% positive of 117 users

Plush and versatile, but can be too soft and unstable.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs