
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Reddit Reviews
I have one pair of trail I use a couple times a year. I usually only wear one pair of road until I have an egregious number of miles on them (I’ve pushed two pairs to 700 miles). But I’ve been running more marathons and I like a fresh pair of shoes for each race, so I have one pair of hoka Clifton 8 that I don’t like that has 500 miles, a pair of Clifton 9 that has 370 miles from my spring marathon, and my current pair of Clifton 9 for my marathon next week that has about 100 miles. I also usually switch between Clifton and brooks glycerin, but Clifton’s have been serving me well for my PRs lately and I guess I’ve been hesitant to change (based on my last three pairs lol).
My most recent race shoe purchase is the AP4. Haven’t run a full in them yet, but have done some shorter races. Previously, I’ve raced halfs and fulls in the Clifton 8, Vaporfly 2, Alphafly 1, Endorphin Speed 2, Adios Pro 3, Zegama 1, Topo Specter 1, Endorphin Trail, Endorphin Pro 3, Endorphin Speed 3, and Tyr Valkyrie Speedworks. AP3 has been my favorite of those. Ran 2 halfs and 2 fulls in them plus an ultra and then put a lot of miles in them as a daily trainer. Great shoe. AF1 was great too, but I did a lot more daily miles than races in those.
I absolutely hate the 10s. Really enjoyed the 8s and to a lesser extent the 9s. I run 5 days a week went through 3 pairs but the fit and arch support as a mid sole striker were main selling points. The 10s shifted me to heel strike hurting my knees and Achilles. I can not tolerate the heel drop on the 10s. Brand new and I had to go buy a pair of the Mach 6s
I have been buying Clifton’s (8 & 9) for a few years. Went to get a new pair and was told they were Clifton 10 w/ higher arches. They were nothing like any of my previous Clifton’s. My plantar fasciitis flared up and was worse than ever. I only wear Hoka’s & I wear them all day so this was a shock. I switched to another brand and added an insert and my PF is back to being manageable.
Last official marathon 3:45. Wore a fresh pair of hoka clifton 8’s. Trained my whole block in them as well.
Yea I 100% agree. I personally don’t get along with Hoka as i feel them a bit too firm for my liking. Hopefully you have a running store that has a broad selection of shoes for you to try.
Hoka Clifton are amazing they have regular wide and 2E shoe for women .. get the 2E shoe if they are super wide.
Well you’re mischaracterizing the spirit of what I’m trying to get across. Of course it matters what show you’re in 30 miles into a run (wouldn’t want to be in vans) but the reality is the vast majority of runners in the world don’t get to a point where they’re 30 miles into a run, but many own multiple pairs of runners. Still, I could wear a pair of Clifton’s for a 50 mile run and then for next week’s hill sprints and they would be more than fine for both 👍 - and that’s what I’m saying
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Achilles tendonitis

Top pick
Brooks - Glycerin GTS 22
Best for Budget-conscious running

Top pick
ADIDAS - Adizero Evo SL
Best for Heavier runners

Top pick
ASICS - SUPERBLAST 2
Best for Long-distance training

Top pick
ASICS - SUPERBLAST 2
Best for Marathon race day

Top pick
ASICS - SUPERBLAST 2
Best for Maximum cushioning and joint protection

Top pick
Nike - Vomero Plus





