iRobot

i4+ (Self-Emptying)

iRobot i4+ (Self-Emptying)

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#184 in

Robot Vacuums

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score63% positive
5
1
2

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Sep 18, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconDruggistJames
5 months ago

Some background. I have a Roomba i4+ and looking for an upgrade. In general, the robot has been ok. I've had some gripes but I've worked around it. I am pretty frugal but I am tired of buying the cheap robot vacuums and needing to replace every couple years. My wife has hated the Roomba because it occasionally loses WiFi connection and she isn't tech savvy enough to get it back online. It also gets stuck on clutter around the house so we typically have it do the kitchen on a schedule because we need to clean up for the vacuum on the rest of the main floor. So now I'm looking to move into the mid range and hopefully have a better overall experience, where I can have it clean the entire house without worry it will eat something it shouldn't. We have about 1200 sq ft of LVP on our 1st floor and a couple low pile rugs. We have a short haired dog and a fluffy cat, as well as two kids under 10. I'm pretty overwhelmed with the options, to the point of analysis paralysis. Gemini has recommended the Eufy X10 Pro Omni, Mova P10 Pro Ultra Gen 2, and the Dreame L40 Ultra Gen 2. The Eufy seems to get a bunch of hate here, so that has dropped down my list. Are there any options I'm missing? Here's what I want in a vacuum: \*Good mopping technology \*Good obstacle avoidance (wires, pet toys, human toys, etc) \*Battery adequate for 1200sq ft while doing a good enough job on a single pass \*Set and Forget for the wife, other than routine maintenance \*Bonus: Google Home integration

Reddit IconIcy-Childhood1257
8 months ago

I have two low budget robot vacuums. The first we bought last year for $99 its a Black and Decker. We use it on the main floor which is all hardwood and some area rugs. It has an app that shows location, mapping, battery level, and spot clean features. We have to empty the bin manually. The second we bought this year at an Amazon returns auction. Its a Roomba i4+ with the auto bin dispenser for $100. We have that one upstairs on wall to wall carpeting. It works well and leaves nice grooves where its vacuumed and it knows to avoid the stairs. It has an app but it uses 2.4 ghz network which we don't have. So we use it manually.

Reddit Iconohyeahsure11
5 months ago

I have a Eufy X10 Pro Omni, and I'd say it is adequate at mopping, but that the vacuum portion is sorely lacking. I'm not sure it sucks up much, because the filter bag in the base lasts way too long compared to my old Roomba S9+ and J4+ machines.

Reddit IconGucciRifle
10 months ago

I know the dream x50 is over $500, but I just bought it and upgraded from roomba i4. Holy crap… Roomba i4 isnt even a vacuum.

Reddit IconMahnaMahna-3000
6 months ago

Honestly, if this is your first foray into the Roomba-sphere, then I agree with getting one of the older models like the 600 series with one brush and one rubber grabber. They don't have smart mapping and you have to manually empty them, but they work and are easy to rehab. If you DO want some smart mapping and self emptying, I have had luck with the refurbished i4 series roombas. I still have them going strong. (two cats, two teens, lots of floor space) I have a J5 that I have had to exorcise a few times, but we have grown to have an understanding. I only kept it because it has the smarter smart mapping, with the 'no go' zones. But I have had far far more ease of use with the refurbished i4s.

Reddit IconOk-Host9817
9 months ago

Honestly, the industry is full of fake reviews and paid sponsored videos. The reality is vacuum/mopping in a single unit is not ready for prime time. The vacuums are good. Simple mopping is good. But the fancier you get, the more likelihood of catastrophic errors. Check out this honest take btw: https://youtu.be/jm3SQpl1Y6Q?si=r3OwTX3b_mEtKnUx Discloser: I own Roborock Q8 Max, Ecovacs Deebot, and iRobot i4s, and iRobot mop Brava. I don’t trust the mopping unsupervised. It gets carpets wet. Dirty water occasionally too.

9 months ago

Older iRobot 900 series (980 I think) maybe an i4. I’ve had mine for so years and 5 years. My first eco a a broke within 1.1 years right after warranty. And Roborock I have had for just over a year.

Top Robot Vacuums on Reddit

1
Roborock Qrevo S

Roborock

Qrevo S

82% positive of 247 users

Reliable, great mopping (lifts pads), but poor cable avoidance.

2
Roborock Saros 10 Series

Roborock

Saros 10 Series

76% positive of 370 users

Slim, quiet, excellent avoidance, but weak on carpet.

3
Dreame L40S Ultra

Dreame

L40S Ultra

81% positive of 189 users

Superior avoidance, great for pet hair, but poor on carpets.

4
MOVA P10 Pro Ultra

MOVA

P10 Pro Ultra

86% positive of 152 users

Budget king, smart avoidance, but struggles on patterned carpets.

5
Roborock Qrevo Curv Series

Roborock

Qrevo Curv Series

86% positive of 139 users

Great for pet hair; handles high thresholds, but poor avoidance.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs