Big Agnes - Rapide SL Insulated Sleeping Pad

Big Agnes rapide sl, the wide long version is a great sleeping mat

I tried a half dozen different mummy bags before immediately returning them. I'm 6'3" 235lbs, pretty tight fit. Perfect solution for me was a Katabatic down quilt. Really good quality and versatile. Paired it with a Big Agnes Rapide pad. Most comfortable pad I've ever used.

Yes it's a matter of seeing what works for you. Personally - I am a side and stomach sleeper. Mummy type bags and narrow tiny pads suck. I used to use a Nemo bag with a sleeve to receive a Klymit V. This worked ok, but not great at all. I finally got fed up and too the extra weight. I now use a Big Agnes Rapide double wide and a Kelty Galactic down rectangular bag. Went on a trip last week and it was the best camping sleep I ever had.

Big Agnes rapide SL wide and a queen fitted sheet. I know you said no air mats but you’ll never get a better night sleep camping, and IIRC they also do a double sized mat. Also IIRC lifetime guarantee.

I’m similar size, and I’ll echo others I. The Big Agnes Rapide SL, but get the wide lad and opt for the long pad as well. Is almost as comfortable as my bed at home, has cool side rails to keep you on the pad as well. Packs up reasonably light and small as well. I’ve used it down to about freezing temps and it doesn’t feel cold at all - it has a down top with a heat reflector apparently which helps reflect body heat when it’s cold…but also doesn’t make it hot to sleep on when it’s warm and muggy nights like we had this summer. I’m also a side/stomach smelter and it’s great for that too.

We have gone through five different sleeping pads over the years. I know you said you’re on a budget, but man a good sleeping pad is one of the most important pieces of kit you can buy. We bought these red inflatable air mattresses from Amazon for our kids and they’re fine, but my daughter isn’t a fan of the ridges they have on them. We have finally settled on Big Agnes Rapide mats. They are expensive, but when I say they are as comfortable as my bed at home that isn’t hyperbole.

I have no experience with the vectair but we did upgrade a couple years ago from self inflating MEC pads to a similar thickness air pad (Big Agnes Rapide SL) The comfort upgrade of the new pads ks night and day difference. My wife’s biggest complaint is how her hips bugged her on the old pads, it’s a non issue. Such a great upgrade, I’d say try the vectair.

I’ve used the Rapide down to about upper-20s and stayed ~relatively~ comfortable, but that probably was more so due to having a good sleeping bag/quilt. As others have said, you could get a thin closed cell foam sleeping pad to put underneath it. R values are generally additive. If weight is a concern, I’ve heard some people say they put one of those reflective emergency blankets (extremely lightweight) under their sleeping pads. Though, it’s debated if this actually does anything. It might be better used sandwiched between a foam pad and the rapide, or on top of the rapide itself (if you don’t mind the obnoxious crinkliness)

I have the BA Rapide. I believe the outer edges are slightly larger, so your arms don't sink. They are raised just a bit and are more comfy. I find it pretty comfortable.

Im a big fan of the Big Agnes Rapide.

I had the BA Q-Core for a few years until it too developed a slow leak. Thought I had maybe punctured it during a desert trip (thorns, needles and such). Did a soap smear to check for leaks. Turned out to be a material separation between the valve and the air mat portion. Glue just gave out, I guess. Called up Big Agnes and sent them an REI screenshot of my purchase date. BA was cool enough to send me a replacement of the Q-Core (discontinued) with the Rapide SL (current equivalent). Can’t say that either air mat is “ultralight,” but they are warm (good R ratings) and comfortable. As a 3-season High Sierra hiker, sleeping through very cold nights near glacial lakes is a big deal for me. Big Agnes makes great mats, sleeping bags, and tents. Their stuff is made to be durable without making comfort a secondary consideration. Yeah, I’m a fan.

Big Agnes Rapide for me...100+ nights on one

100+ nights on a Rapide. Love it as a side sleeper. If the insulation slips BA will replace it. If slips mid-trip (happened to me) you can inflate it and shake the insulation back in place more or less.

I slept on mine in the mid 20s or lower (water bottles froze) with a 20-degree quilt. Never felt cold from the pad.

Important to know from the start: I have scoliosis as well as a lingering low back/hip injury, and at home I sleep on a probably-too-soft mattress. But I don't have any of the problems I mention below even when I sleep in a different bed with a different firmness, such as while traveling for work or family. My setup as of last year's season is a Therm-A-Rest Z Lite Sol underneath the Big Agnes Rapide SL inflatable pad (standard length, wide width). In other words, I'm not laying flat on the ground by any means - there's plenty of cushion from uneven or firm ground, and I haven't had any temperature issues (I pair these two pads with a now-discontinued Sea to Summit down bag that's plenty cozy). The Big Agnes pad was new last year, after multiple seasons attempting and failing to make a thin Therm-A-Rest Trail Scout work with the Z-Lite (I would anti-recommend the Trail Scout for this and other reasons). But this current setup isn't working very well, either. On some nights I found myself waking up with a leg or two numb on some nights because of some position that had me cutting off circulation. (This happens at home occasionally when I'm sitting flat on the floor, but rarely when I'm sleeping or lying flat.) Even though I played around with the inflation level of the Big Agnes pad, as I was worried it was maybe too firm at full inflation, that didn't seem to help much. I also prefer to sleep on my stomach, and I haven't figured out a backcountry pillow option that's flat enough to keep my neck at a comfortable angle without being non-existent, as sleeping directly on my arms puts them numb too. Out of desperation, I tried bringing my flat-yet-not-paper pillow from home for a trip last year, which feels embarrassing to write because of the pillow's weight and bulk, lol. If it had worked, I would make adjustments to my kit to bring it every time, but it didn't really fix the setup (which is probably for the best for the rest of my packing list), so I'm back to the drawing board. Given all this, I'm feeling nervous about this season's upcoming trips, as I'm not someone who functions well on a lack of sleep. I'd prefer to try and adapt my current setup before I buy new stuff, too, as these are otherwise high-quality products that I think will last a while, if I can make them work for me. For folks who have finicky backs, or sleep in ways at home that are harder to comfortably do out on trail, how do you adjust your sleep setup for overnighters? What might I change here that will help me sleep better while on trail and thus have a better trip overall? I'm considering the Nemo Fillo Elite - can any stomach sleepers attest to this or other semi-inflatable pillows as being worth the buy?

This. I believe the baffles running end-to-end instead of side-to-side also makes this more comfortable for active sleepers than the NeoAir. The Rapide is on the heavier side but totally worth the weight. I have the wide.

I had one, just sold it as it was comfortable but too cold for what they said it was.. With 13 years of observations and use, I think Big Agnes is not a totally trustworthy company. I stick with Thermarest because no company is ever going to beat thermarest's lightweight AND durable AND warm, due to their patented baffles design. Other companies will beat them on comfort but they just debuted a raised perimeter pad and I hope they basically make a raised perimeter Xlite. Once they make a raised perimeter xlite that's 30in wide. I'm done. That's the pad.

Rapide sl is peak. My favorite pad. Ive got a sea so summit pad that i love too but can't remember the name of it. It has like a 7 or 8 r value tho.

I own two Rapide’s - one for me and one for my wife. Don’t have experience with the others you mention but do own two Megamats from Exped. I like the Rapide. No issues in terms of quality across 3 seasons of use. Been stuffing them pretty hard into a heavily loaded pack too. Comfort is good. I sleep fine. But comfort is also so subjective. I don’t think you can go wrong with any option you chose.

Big ag rapide is absolutely my favorite ive ever used. Hands down.

BA rapide SL is what ive settled on. Good weight for the comfort.

I'm a big fan of the Big Agnes Rapide SL. It's the most comfortable pad I've owned and packs down really small. It's expensive, but worth every penny. I've had it for a few years and taken it on a ton of trips and it hasn't failed me yet. And, if it does, it comes with a patch kit. One thing to think about when setting up camp is to make sure the ground you're putting your tent on is clean of any sticks or thorny weeds, and always use a footprint. This could be the cause of your flat pads, or it could be that you're using cheap pads made of low grade material. 

My Rapide SL insulated is very comfortable but nowhere close 4r. It might be 2r. Maybe. I just replaced it with the REI helix. 1oz heavier, but even more comfortable and a “true” 4.9r. They retail for $160. Exped 5r is also comfortable, warm, and has a great pump sack - although I suspect they’re getting ready to revamp them in the spring and they’ll be a decent amount more compact and lighter then. But you’ll probably find good Black Friday deals on the current one.

Strange I've not heard of many issues with the Rapide SL, only ever really seen glowing praise for it, my partner uses one and loves it. I know the Big Agnes zoom UL had/has issues with its insulating film "sagging" essentially reducing it R value in real world use. Between the exped and nortent? For me personally would be the Exped,mainly because it's been on the market for years, has been tried and tested long term and very well regarded. The very little I've seen of the Nortent was on YouTube when the usual suspects were giving glowing reviews after a few nights use, ironically saw one of those reviewers say that they were no longer using it now after a few months because it started leaking. Also it is significantly heavier and bulkier than the exped.

That makes alot of sense, when I was looking at the Rapide SL for myself a few years ago and last year for my partner; I didn't see anything about issues with the Rapide only the Zoom. Thankfully she bought the old version of the Rapide SL for £90 as places were clearing stock for the new one. That also explains why despite being a cold sleeper has no issues with warmth.

I'd not come across that with the Rapide only the Zoom but quick Google search does suggest the issue or at least potential for that issue is there with the Rapide as well. Yeah for me the marketing approach from Nortent does more harm than good and actually makes me less likely to buy something from them. When I was buying a mat it was a toss up between the X-lite, Exped Ultra and the Rapide SL, ultimately went with the X-lite as it is lighter (despite 30D v 20D of the ultra) and has a good warranty, though definitely less comfortable!

I sleep like a rotisserie chicken rotating on an open flame and have Big Agnes Rapide SL, which works perfect for me.

I do a lot of winter camping (below freezing) and have never had any issues with this sleeping pad. Wear the right base layers and don’t get into your tent cold and you’ll be fine. I love my Rapide SL.

Most comfortable pad I’ve used is a Big Agnes Rapide SL. I have a bad back and sleep poorly in general. This pad is amazing for my needs. I’m 5’9” around 180 lbs with the regular length pad but 25 inches wide.

Everyone is recommending systems that work for them, which is amazing. There are so many good options. I use a rapide SL big Agnes pad for me with a Nemo rift bag. For my pup, she has a whyld river bag/bed (can be separated during warm weather) and a foam pad that slips into the bed sleeve. I went with whyld river because it packs down so well and has connection points that work well for me. My pup needs the ability to switch positions during the night and their snaps (one of 2 connection methods with the other being more secure) allows the quilt/top to separate before tension may create a tear. We sleep in a Nemo tracker tent. Pup is 85 lbs lab/pit mix.

If we're dividing the weight by 2 people, check out Big Agnes Rapide Tent Floor Pad. Mine perfectly fills my 2P tent and is like 3lbs or so. Not unreasonable for 2P hiking that short a distance.

I've got a BA Rapide SL for my daughter to sleep on, but since I primarily hammock camp, I went the cheaper route for myself and got the REI Helix. It's a decently comfortable pad, especially when I pair it with my CCF mat, but you've got my attention with the Light Tour. Even if it doesn't sleep as warm as it should at a rated 7.5, it's probably at least as warm as my Helix, and much cheaper, and lighter.

Big agnes rapide sl Not necessarily the lightest, but a really good balance of comfort, warmth, weight, and cost https://www.backcountry.com/big-agnes-rapide-sl-insulated-sleeping-pad

I would suggest the Rapide SL over the Zoom UL, just based on reviews about R-Value. If R-Value is not an issue, the Zoom is probably the better option. I use the Rapide on short trips and my Nemo All-Season any other time, which is comfy if you slightly deflate it.

I second this. I always grab my Rapide when I want to focus on sleep. My favorite pad by far.

It kept me warm in the low 30's (frost on the ground when I woke up). Edit: that's Fahrenheit (just above freezing).

Roughly the same size as this guy, and can also vouch for the Rapide SL in the 25" x 78" size.

You've tested *all* of them? You find the Nemo more comfortable than an Etherlite XT? An REI Helix? An Exped? A Rapide SL? That doesn't compute for me. The Nemo is more comfy than a Neoair but well below all of those.

The Rapide SL is easily the most comfortable pad I have used. I have an older version though where the insulation doesn’t work properly, so I can’t use it in cold or even cool weather. I believe they fixed this issue, if so I would 100% go with that one. I tried the Tensor all-season and absolutely hated it, which was surprising because I have heard rave reviews about it. It made my arm go numb, jammed into my ribs/side, I could only inflate it ~halfway to be comfortable, and it sounded like I was sleeping on a Doritos bag. However it is incredibly packable and lightweight. Unfamiliar with the Etherlite personally. I ended up with the Exped 5R, not as comfortable as the Rapide SL but miles ahead of the Tensor. EDIT: Mainly a side and occasional back sleeper.

I like my big anges Rapide SL. The way it pushes you back to the middle as you toss and turn is nice. Comfiest mat I’ve tried. 3.5 inches thick, cheapish, 482 grams

Get something thick AF with no foam inside like a big Agnes rapide

I love my big Agnes rapide SL, but have heard great things about zen bivvy pads. I’ve been very happy with their quilt, so my next pad will probably be from them.

Lighter would be an air pad. Not sure about colors, as my Big Agnes Rapide SL is red and Nemo Tensor is usually yellow. If you're sleeping on it, is the color important? Would that be for backpacking?

Nemo, Big Agnes and Thermarest all make good air pads. I use the Big Agnes Rapide SL in wide regular and it's comfortable for me, a 63 yo side sleeper.

Big Agnes, my partner is a side sleeper and it doesn't bottom out, she went through 6 different pads before picking this one. Having your hips hit the ground all night is the worst Also Backpacking Light did a review/comparison on pads and this one got the best bang for your buck on money, insulation, weight, and comfort.

Bought the Rapide for my wife last spring because she kept stealing my score on trips we weren't together. She loves it.

I would check out big agnes rapide It is perfect for those who move a lot when they sleep because of the sides are higher so you can feel where the edge of the pad is.

Yeah it is heavier, but not that much. I think it might be worth it in this case.

Ive got the big agnes boundary deluxe long wide. Its a dream to sleep on. It you want a bit more lightweight i also used the rapide sl. Also really comfortable but thinner material so smaller pack size and lighter weight. Theyre on sale now on big agnes. €100 for the boundary deluxe. An absolute steal

I have a Big Agnes Rapide SL insulated in extra long/wide. Love it, and my friends who’ve borrowed it also love it. No punctures after approx 80 nights on it so far.  

I'm a side sleeper and have the Big Agnes Rapide SL and it's brilliant. Pretty well insulated, and weighs/packs down to nothing too.

they both kinda suck tbh try a nemo tensor, big agnes rapide, or sea to summit etherlite, or thermarest neo air

Big Agnes Rapide SL. Super comfortable, great R value, packs down super small, and lifetime guarantee. A lot of my gear is Big Agnes. I’ve never ever had a complaint with any of their gear.

I'm 6' 1" 235. Check out the Big Ages Rapide SL. So far the most comfy. You can get it extra long and extra wide. I have the wide one and it's awesome.

I havent used it in super cold weather. I do most of my Backcountry camping in Sept, October. Just a couple weeks ago it dropped to like 35 on the mountain one night and I didn't even notice.

As a side/stomach sleeper I couldn't hang with the foam pads, they were too thin for my hip bone. Check out the Big Agnes Rapide SL, the edges are thicker so you never fall off. I move around a lot in my sleep and would wake up off my pad, this helps significantly. A bit more weight but I value my sleep.

This is a really nice pad. I chose it because the ultralight ones were not for me, probably because I'm not ultralight myself. This is a really good compromise between weight and comfort.

https://www.rei.com/product/233244/big-agnes-rapide-sl-insulated-tent-floor-sleeping-pad?sku=2332440001&store=&CAWELAID=120217890017713188&CAGPSPN=pla&CAAGID=147758270799&CATCI=pla-2023795263505&cm_mmc=PLA_Google%7C21700000001700551_2332440001%7C2023795263505%7Cbrand_flag%7C9920629669&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=9920629669&gbraid=0AAAAAD_DTly8JSNS6oXVtuBFYRG07LMPV&gclid=Cj0KCQjw0NPGBhCDARIsAGAzpp2jFnG8i19M-7MEjnjnJ5bHXIJmIOUxmOY_A_lZ6YUy6OTyeuGfuVIaApfqEALw_wcB My boyfriend and I use this sleeping pad! I have insomnia and need super specific conditions to sleep, whereas he could sleep on a whirring helicopter blade, and we both absolutely love it.

Try the Nemo Tensor, the Exped pads, and the Big Agnes Rapide (heaviest, but thickest). You should be able to lay on all of these at an REI if you have one nearby. They should have all the most popular ones blown up and ready to try.

Couple of other questions… when you say side sleeper? Are you in one position the whole night, or do you flip from side to side? Do you ever wake up with sore shoulders or hips? The sensitive question would be, are you on the smaller or larger size? And lastly how tall? The Rapide is my favorite for larger or more side sleeper oriented? Especially the ones I like to call the alligators. (Like to roll as they sleep) I also suggest the wide for alligator side sleepers as it gives you room to move. The others are excellent pads, but I prefer the thickness of the Big Agnes. Also are you in a sleeping bag? What kind? Or are you a quilt person? We should be asking about your full sleep system when suggesting a pad… but without you here in front of me… I can’t sense some of the things that I would need to know? in the end… if comfort is more important than weight… and sleep is first aid… then you should consider the more comfortable pad… thickness is key. You will have more ability to change inflation firmness to match your sleeping comfort the further you are off the ground.

The Rapide by BA is a solid choice. Especially if you, as I do, consider sleep first aid? If you wake up bad, you begin bad…

I’m about 1.5 years in with my Rapide and it’s held up really well. Paired it with a padpal UL inflator, which also rocks and weighs 9 grams

The Big Agnes Rapide SL in wide and long has been a total game changer for me. Excellent mat. 🙂 Used it on several camps in all weathers and has never let me down touch wood.

Ah that’s a shame, my experience is the opposite. Heard lots of great reviews. Maybe different batches perhaps? Who knows. 🤷 All the best with it and hope you find a great mat.

I just got this it is a good solution. Six two 300lbs. 25x72 is the one I have would prefer the longer one but didn’t want to pay extra. I don’t mind my feet hanging off and wouldn’t matter for a side sleeper.

This is great. Not least because it validates my decision in choosing the BA Rapide SL! Now can you do the same for sleeping bags?

I got Rapide SL for me and my wife week ago, didn’t use it at the trips yet, but it more silent than our previous exped sleeping mats for sure. I also love the rectangular shape and that it is wide. I used to have regular size “mummy” shape sleeping pad previously and I feel it was small. ok to sleep, but wide rectangular will be more comfortable. Sad that I need to pay with weight for that)

I'm taking the big agnes all day since I'm a side sleeper. The extra 1.25 inches of height over the neoair really makes a difference. Although, a good in-between is the tensor all season.

I haven't used a lot of different pads but I'm also a side sleeper and had a lot of issues until I got the big Agnes rapide sl, there are a lot of different sizes available so get the one that fits you. I haven't found a good pillow though.

I can't speak to the Exped, but I've used both the Nemo and the Rapide. The Rapide is noticeably more comfortable, heavier, bulkier. It's a lower R-value, and doesn't seem to live up to it's rating even. I'm not saying it's a bad buy. Nemo Tensor seems to be the best combo of comfort and weight I can find if I emphasize weight. If I'm emphasizing comfort, the Zen Bivy Flex Air is maybe 6 oz heavier, and is the most comfortable backpacking pad I've ever tried. It's absolutely superb. That said, I don't use it because of the weight, but I'll sure as hell slide over on to my girlfriend's mat when she gets up.

I have lower back pain as well and for me the thermarest self inflating mats were never as comfortable as newer pads. I've now settled on the Big Agnes Rapide wide as my pad of choice. Its 4" thick, wide and comfortable for me as a side sleeper. Those recommending you go to an REI and try some are right on the mark IMO.

I tried the Hikenature and ended up returning it due to how loud it was. Ended up with a BA Rapide SL.

There are LOTs of good thick inflatable pads. I'd recommend going to a store that has several to try as they each feel a bit different and what I like (Big Agnes Rapide) may not feel right to you. I'd suggest getting the wide models (25") and look into Flextale pumps to inflate them.

As a side sleeper I found my BA Rapide wide to be comfortable.

You can get the Big Agnes Rapide for $200 (https://geartrade.ca/products/big-agnes-rapide-sl-insulated-long) but Justin Outdoors seemed to like the TREKOLOGY UL R7 which is considerably cheaper on Amazon.

They might but it'll depend on where the noise is coming from. It could be the pad against the tent...or the internal foil on insulated pads. I'd found it more likely to be the foil in which case a cover might not help much. I bought a Gear Doctors sleeping pad from Amazon that seemed decent for a budget pad but it was REALLY loud so it got returned and we ended up buying the Rapide wide pads.

WM for sure for bags / quilts also Cumulus are good but import duty makes them expensive, Big Agnes Rapide SL is mega comfortable pad with a good R not light but bloody comfortable compared with any thermarest

Honestly your whole sleep system will make you cold unless it’s high summer. Those sleeping bags are no good for less than 12 degrees, if you really get into this awesome hobby get a down bag and a decent branded mat. Check out ebay for used mats, get a quality brand Thermarest, Exped Sea to Summit anything with more than 4 r value. Big Agnes Rapide SL is the king of mats that Ive tested, pricey but worth it you’ll sleep like a babe on it.

I have the Big Agnes Rapide SL and i can vouch for it. took it to yosemite for a 9 days of camping and woke up feeling amazing every morning. i’m 5’7” 160 pounds and side sleep for the most part. I do have the regular and would reccomend at minimum a regular wide, as long as the size and weight difference aren’t an issue. i know we are in the REI reddit, but if you go on sea to summit’s website, you can get up to 60% off on a sleeping pad right now

Rapid SL is one of the best. But it's cold so in low 30° F I would take a foam pad as well. Zenbivy Flex Air is more comfortable. 

I tried both of the mentioned pads and can confirm that they have a lower real R value. If you combine one of them with the Thermarest Z Lite Sol it will be warm.

The Rapide SL is great. Just try to get one of the recent ones as Big Agnes changed to a better manufacturer. My original Rapide SL sprung micro leaks on almost every weld. Big Agnes sent a replacement new version and I've had no problems. The new version is also a little lighter than the previous one.

I bought a new BA Rapide SL last summer and used it on a snowy trip in October where it dropped to probably -3 or -5C at night. Had to put the pad on frozen ground as well. I would not use it in those conditions again. I kept waking up every 30 minutes because i could feel the cold creeping up from the ground through the sleeping pad. It was survivable but not comfortable by any means. Fantastic sleeping pad otherwise IMO, had no complaints using it even on a 2c night on non-frozen ground.

Nemo Tensor, Kilos Gear AeroCloud Elite, Big Agnes Rapide SL, Thermarest NeoLoft. The Sea To Summit Etherlight XT is also comfortable but heavy and bulky for a backpacking pad.

I have used that mattress for a few years. It is a great mattress.

Two inches isn't thick enough. Someone mentioned the Big Agnes Rapide (3.5" thick), and we've always been comfortable on the Rapide or its predecessors.

I know I'm a bit late, but for anyone else curious, I have the Rapide SL 25x72 and I don't think it's a quiet pad at all. I think in comparison to some other pads that have a "chip packet" crinkly sound, it doesn't make that sound, so maybe that's why people say it's quiet. But it makes a really loud sort of sound, kinda like rubbing two balloons together or something haha. It doesn't really bother me much, and I have sound sensitivity, but it's pretty loud and if I was doing a stealth camp or around other people they would definitely hear me a couple tents over

I just went through this. I’m 6’ 260 pounds (muscle of course). I went with the big Agnes SL wide long. I browsed the others. Sleep and warmth are important. Be my first trip for canoe back country this weekend.

I’m 6’0 260. I did bought the big Agnes and used it a couple weekends ago. I would suggest blowing up with the pump sack. Then releasing some air with 2-3 maybe more valve button pushes. Might take a few nights to see what works for you.

I’m a side sleeper and I love my big Agnes rapide.

How noisy is the 5R? I have an BA Rapide and it’s incredibly loud anytime I move. Was considering getting the 5R during this sale.

I wanted smaller and warmer pad and recently got the Big Agnes Rapide SL. Super comfy and packs down small. I love it.

Big agnes rapide sl. The side baffles completely eliminated the feeling of falling off the pad that I'd get with other inflatable pads and help to prevent drafts with my quilt. Also going to suggest a flextail pump to inflate. 

I also have a Rapide SL (and a Megamat) I put a thermarest mat under my Rapide to help with the occasional bottoming out when I sit up or put an elbow down. The trick to all inflatable sleeping pads is finding the right inflation level (firmness) for your preference. Don’t forget you can always soften it up by bleeding some air.

I haven't had a good night sleep until I started to use the Rapid SL. It has a good weight I think, the R rating is valid on it, only need higher for winter camping (for that i'm using the therm-o-rest, which is crazy good, except the shape, where i much prefer the rectangle shape of the Rapide with the raised sides, because I'm turning around a lot). To fit the pump you do need to be a bit aggressive with it but doable. Side note: a non fully inflatable pillow made a big difference for me to get comfy 

I am twisting and turning around a lot even after I fell asleep and with the mummy shaped pad I often found myself halfway off the pad in the middle of the night.

The Big Agnes Rapide SL is the best mat I’ve used yet. Packs up real small while including a pump sack. Don’t ignore the R value on your pad, you’ll appreciate a higher R value even in the 60s.

Naturehike is not ASTM rated. Skip. The Rapide is a great pad but is a bit cold. If you want the direct replacement to this pad get the Boundary Deluxe, which is the new name for the Q Core Deluxe. However if you are going to go winter camping over snow go for a higher R value pad. Exped Ultra 5 Exped Ultra 7 Sea to Summit Etherlight XT Extreme Thermarest XTherm Nemo Tensor Extreme

Just toured the Netherlands and was really happy with my big Agnes rapide sl after using a therm-a-rest for years.

I have the Big Agnes Rapide SL and I love it!

Thank you all for your comments! You didn't make the choice easier, but I realised that it really doesn't matter because they are all good sleeping pads. I decided for the Big Agnes Rapid SL, it packs the smallest and my sleeping bag is only for 7°C – so I will not need a pad for freezing temperatures.

I really like my Big Agnes Rapide SL. Not too noisy, not too heavy, nice and cushy for a side sleeper, plenty warm for shoulder seasons. They're on sale at REI through this weekend.

I use a Big Agnes Rapdie SL Regular Wide, they do a Tall Wide version. Weighs about 650g and R value 4.2. I hike in the alps often. It comes with a lightweight pump bag, takes 4 or 5 squeezes to inflate. Very warm and reliable mat, very comfortable and thick. Another one could be the Nemo Tensor Insulated which some of my fellow hikers have liked too.

I do a combination of back and side sleeping, and i’m pretty comfortable on my rapide SL. i do have it on the more inflated side

Big Agnes is what I use. They are so much quieter than other inflatables.

I’ve been able to sleep on the Big Agnes SL Rapide

I have the double width, because I hate having my arms fall off the pad, and I car camp. I brought it to FloydFest and slept all 5 nights on it.

I have trouble sleeping and did five nights on a BA SL Rapide no problem

You can get a Big Agnes Rapide sl for 130 euro currently in the EU. It is a popular comfortable pad, too cold for its R=4.8 rating, but if you only need R=3 it will do. I would invest in a bit more expensive and warmer pad though so that you are set for future trips where the temperatures may dip below zero.

Check out the sleeping pad comparison chart I posted. It's a quick reference for pack size and weight across multiple brands. The best 2 light air pads that are still comfortable: Big Agnes Rapide SL NEMO Tensor (any version really) I personally prefer the Rapide SL but my wife really likes the Tensor. Both available in 20x72 up to 25x78, I always recommend at least a 25" wide. Both insulated and smaller packing that the other that may offer more comfort or insulation like the Big Agnes Campmeister Deluxe or Therm-a-Rest NeoLoft. Maybe not as small as some cheaper Amazon pads or the infamous Klymit static V but guaranteed more comfortable. They also have lifetime warranty which I know doesn't help you in the woods, but does protect your investment in the event there's a leak you can't find. The Big Agnes zoom is too crinkly like all the Thermarest air pads are. The Sea to summit etherlight packs too big for what it is and the external material is super squeaky on a tent floor.

I have a Big Agnes Rapide SL that I’ve used 16 nights of over the past 2 years. It is comfortable but the insulation is delaminating from the inside surface pretty badly. I know tons of people love it but I expected it to last longer. I’ll be trying the Nemo Tensor All-Season next.

I've gotta say, I had/have the klymit pad and the biggest thing is just how much colder I was when I slept on that compared to my newer Big Agnes Rapide pad. Sure, I'm still sleeping on an inflatable, but the warmth difference was notable. For context, my comparison is from backpacking mainly in the high sierras and I'm also a three season camping person.

You will not get better comfort for the size than a big Agnes rapide SL imo. Insanely comfy, and R value of nearly 5. Worth every penny- check the online reviews, loads of happy customers

From my own experience, I was used Big Agnes pads for a while but had terrible luck with them. I had two of them get holes in them, could entirely be my fault but annoying nonetheless. I recently switched over to the Nemo Tensor and wow, it’s insanely comfortable and super warm. Packs nice and small too, so far, I’m really happy with it. I’m also a side sleeper and between that pad and a quilt, it was a nice nights sleep.

I have a Rapid SL and love it. It’s honestly not much bigger than the Klymit I used to use and so much more comfortable and warm. I was also able to find it on REI restock for $100 when none of the other fancy pads were even close to that price.

I just got a rapid SL from REI restock for $100. Used it the other weekend. I really like it, my only complaint is it barely fits in the bag.

I have a Big Agnes Rapide SL (25x72). Coming from a Klymit I will never go back. Packs small, super comfortable and the pump sack it comes with is amazing. I found mine at REI restock for $100 and I’m already on the lookout for another for my wife or a double.

I have the Big Agnes Rapide SL and it's super comfortable and warm. I've been very happy with it, and it packs small.

Thermarest NeoLoft is the thickest backpacking pad--comparable in size and comfort to a car camping pad. Big Agnes Rapide SL is plush. Neither is "ultra" light, but they are both legit backpacking pads that emphasize comfort. But I also generally use a hammock due to a fussy back.

They get a lot better than the static v.  Try a Big Agnes Rapide SL or, for the most comfort currently available in a backpacking pad, a Thermarest Neoloft. They're huge upgrades especially if you side sleep and for warmth too. The key is to slightly under inflate so that you can sink into the pad a bit.  The extra thickness of these allow you to do so without touching the ground.   A pad will only get you half way though.  A good supportive pillow is integral.  I've tried several inflatable models, the best of which was probably the Nemo Fillo.  However I recently got a camping pillow from Coop which has changed my life.  Got some extra filling too since I side sleep and like a nice thick pillow.  Yes it's bulky and heavy for a backpacking pillow but 1000% worth it.  Stuff it in a compression bag and it gets smaller than my sleeping bag.   Also, wax earplugs to block out the nighttime noises and I now sleep like I'm at home.

There is some mis-stated info about the Rapide primarily from a Justin Outdoors video where he claims the mylar sinks. Firstly the initial Rapide SL didn't have mylar and was commonly found to be cold for it's R value. They updated it adding mylar foil to the top and bottom of the pad so there are two layers. If you shine a light just right you could easily fool yourself that there is only a single sunk layer of mylar but there are indeed two permanently attached to the top and bottom surfaces. I've used my new Rapide a fair few nights and have been fine. Coldest so far was 36F with a quilt and stayed quite toasty. I don't think another 6 degrees will change my opinion much. Temps in the low 20s or teens might but that's just hearsay for the moment. The Rapide can also be gotten quite cheaply. I paid about $140 for my long wide on steepandcheap. Tensor all season is definitely a top pick for r value and weight though. Pretty sure it's multiple ounces lighter than a Rapide.

No. The rapide is one of the quietest pads on the market.

Yes. It's my current 3 season pad. This may interest you https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=U2CsAf7N__8&pp=ygUgcmFwaWRlIHNsIGluc3VsYXRlZCBzbGVlcGluZyBwYWQ%3D

I’ve got a Rapide SL am a side sleeper and agree it’s very comfortable, once I got the inflation right - I only inflate it enough to stop my hips bottoming out. Having the long and wide version makes a big difference. I’ve not slept in cold conditions so couldn’t attest to its warmth.

I’ve got a Big Agnes Rapide SL and it’s really comfortable for side sleeping - but I don’t put too much pressure n it, in fact it’s more partially deflated, so that my hips have plenty to sink into without touching the bottom of the mat. Maybe experiment with different pressures with your neotherm?

Definitely worth experimenting with different amounts of air - I’ve found a sweet spot that’s really comfy but the mat looks a little deflated when there’s nothing on it

I had the same problem with that lumbar spine discomfort! I ended up finding a solution that worked for me. Big Agnes Rapide SL, inflated only about halfway, AND I tuck my shoes underneath the head to elevate that just a few inches. Seems to take away the arching in my lumbar spine that was so uncomfortable. Maybe that’ll work for you, too…

I went to the store intending to buy neo air, but damn was it uncomfortable. I walked out with a Big aAgnes Rapide even though it was 18 oz instead of 15.5 oz. Didn’t need another uncomfortable sleeping pad I will eventually just have to replace. I’d take your girlfriend to go try some out at REI or if you have a local store that will let you.

I've got the old version which is a little thinner and it's worked great for me as a side sleeper. I switched from a Big Agnes Rapide and haven't looked back. When my current one wears out I'll upgrade to the new Tensor all season. I pump mine up with a Flextail zero pump as fully as it will go and put no more extra air in because I've found out if I over inflate I wake up a bit sore

I've done quite some research and have narrowed it down to these 3 pads. I got to test the Big Agnes, Nemo and a therm a rest NeoAir XLite in store and personally the big Agnes seemed the most comfortable. I didn't get to try the Sea to Summit myself since that was out of stock. I'm on the hunt for a good, lightweight sleeping pad that's warm enough for early spring and autumn. I need it to pack small and be lightweight too. I'm willing to sacrifice grams if the pad is way more comfortable. I want to buy once cry once, meaning a good pad that'll last me. I don't camp that often and don't put it on rocks or needles or anything like that. I'm a side sleeper so the pad needs to accommodate that. I think I want a pad that's regular wide, since I love the wider pads but I don't necessarily need the extra length since I always curl up my legs slightly. I'm around 188cm tall and 90kg/188 lbs. I've deliberately chosen these pads and not others since the dimples seems to be the most comfortable on sleeping pads. I didn't like the Exped 3R with the vertical baffles and the therm a rest felt like an air balloon. The pads are all quite similar in terms of warmth. The Nemo seems to be the warmest and the Big Agnes seems to be more comfortable. Pack size I think the big Agnes is the best because it's a bit wider but not as long. It's the heaviest of them all though. The Nemo wide long was 140 grams lighter than the same size big Agnes. Sea to Summit sits somewhere in between. Currently I'm using a Nemo Astro Insulated which is actually quite comfortable but very heavy and not always warm enough at R2.6. It's also a big pack size. I do really like their stuff sack, pump sack, valve system and the quality seems great. This got me leaning a bit towards the Nemo. However the big Agnes was quite a lot more comfortable in store and I do appreciate comfort a lot. I find it difficult to guess which one is the best since you basically must try them out camping. That's why I need some help deciding what's important and which one can work the best. What pad do you use and like the most? And did you try any of the pads I named here?

Oh wow this is absolutely great info! I hoped there would be someone that tried them all but didn't expect this exact scenario. Okay so you'd say the S2S? I thought it's packed size was the biggest of them all and the surface was quite slippery. It's even less slippery than the Big Agnes? I'll have to think again then and maybe look into that one! Which size did you go for? In store it did feel like th BA pad's baffles kept me from rolling off though. The Nemo didn't have that

I'm going for the S2S. Seems like it's a lot more comfortable, cheaper (here) and not that much heavier or bigger in pack size. The R4.1 is also plenty and it should be a real R4.1 not colder

Lots of options if you're okay losing the self-inflating aspect. Thermarest Neoloft or Topo Luxe are two that immediately come to mind. Big Agnes Rapide SL is 3.75"

This is the one i have, like it very much. [Rapide by BA](https://www.rei.com/product/229190/big-agnes-rapide-sl-insulated-sleeping-pad)

[Big Agnes Rapide](https://www.rei.com/product/229190/big-agnes-rapide-sl-insulated-sleeping-pad?sku=2291900001&store=97&CAWELAID=120217890017712452&CAGPSPN=pla&CAAGID=147758267039&CATCI=pla-2023795263505&cm_mmc=PLA_Google%7C21700000001700551_2291900001%7C2023795263505%7CBA%7C71700000074421743&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=11437667263&gbraid=0AAAAAD_DTlzQwa1f5uMxrNy9BPKoLP3a3&gclid=Cj0KCQjwotDBBhCQARIsAG5pinOFRFLD0-bumx6rX426IpX-RPKra07lem39WY6jW8xGEl7kghCxrIcaAsN0EALw_wcB)

get the wider one, or the double wide. i use mine for bikepacking as well as car camping with the famdamily

Backpacking or a canoe trip? If canoeing you can fit a more robust pad. I backpack and in colder weather I like the combo of a cheap egg crate (High Sierra Ultralight Foam Sleeping Pad) and an insulated pad (Big Agnes Rapide SL), but with a good sleeping bag & warm clothes you can certainly get away with just the foam pad.

Dude I’ve been using a rapide for years, love that thing. It’s super thick when inflated, and it doesn’t have any of the loud baffling so if you move around it doesn’t rustle quite so much. With an R value of five iirc, I’ve slept on glaciers with a 20 degree bag and been really warm. I inflate mine rockhard and it’s only just had a pinhole leak for the first time this month (2yrs 2months of heavy usage). If you can wait for the REI “not a black Friday sale” it’s also pretty cheap for the quality

For clarity, I’ve probs used this for about 100 nights now, maybe a bit more, and I usually inflate it firm enough that the inflation bag pops off the valve bc of how hard I’m pushing air in. It’s finely built like a tank, is honestly pretty light, and super quiet compared to a lot of the other options. I’ve used it on everything from glaciers to rocky outcroppings, buffalo grass prairies, places with cacti, east coast backcountry with roots everywhere, and I never lose air, never get cold, and never feel the ground

Oh and this doesn’t count the multiple months I left it 70% inflated in my room under my bed as a second place to sit and sleep

I had a rapide sl but now I have a Nemo tensor which I find more comfortable and it's lighter

I've used my 2023 rapide SL (old version) down to 0°C and it has been outstanding. But -5°< and any snow/frozen ground I have felt cold creeping up from the ground, but in fairness I have had higher R-value with less comfort from Exped and felt the same. The nylon fabric of these pads gets so cold to the touch in freezing temps that as soon as you move you'll feel cold spots through your flattned down insulation regardless of R-Value in my opinion so I add a cellfoam on top or put my pad in a liner (often the S2S thermolite Reactor Extreme) when it's freezing. But I've also been looking for something similarily comfortable with a higher R-Value so I can leave the liner and cellfoam pad at home even in -5°> I think I will try the new Nemo Tensor All Season or even Extreme.

Much more of a backpacking pad. OP looking for a camping pad. The Rapide is comfy though.

The Thermarest NeoAir is indeed lighter. At just 12 ounces the semi-mummy arguably the best quality sleeping pad in this range and weight. But it's also not cheap. The NeoAir Xtherm is the cold weather version, R 7.4, and 16 oz. The Nemo Tensor Extreme is rectangle, R 8.1, and 18 oz. Both the Thermarest and Nemos are quieter than they were in the past. Also, the more you use them, the more quiet they get. Agree the Thermarest pump sack is the worst of the bunch, no question, but I've gotten mine to work enough. The Rapide is usually warm enough for most people 3 seasons, and the reason to buy it is indeed it's thickness, and the sides being raised. Agree the Exped 5R is good for most people. It's a simple, comfortable, rectangle. R 4.8, and 1lb 4 oz. That's certainly heavier than the Thermarest but $50 cheaper.

The Rapide is a very nice backpacking pad for someone who needs comfort. And it's about a pound lighter. A great deal on it's own. But it's just not as comfortable. The NeoLoft is over an inch thicker, has a much nicer surface, and just feels more plush.

Thoughts from an REI employee: Comfort often comes from a few factors, but don't apply to everyone. Thickness can help a lot. The Thermarest NeoLoft for example is very comfortable, because it's a whopping 4.6" thick, and a great surface. Some pads have some foam in them, not just insulation. This is kind of old school, the original Thermarests were like this. This can be nice and plush because you don't have to dial in the air amount quite as specific. Plus, if it loses air, you're at least sleeping on something other than nylon. The Thermarest Trail Pro comes to mind. A little heavy around 2lbs, so not for the UL crowd. But comfy. There is a lighter version called a Trail Pro Lite. They used to sell a terrific pad called a ProLite Apex, but it was discontinued and may not be coming back. Sea to Summit and a few other brands make pads with some foam in them that are backpackable. These are also (mostly) self-inflating, which is nice. The shape of the pad can also factor in. Some people love how most Big Agnes pads are raised on the sides, to help you stay in place, and not roll off the pad. Most of their pads are thick too, not as thick as the NeoLoft, but thick. The Rapide is a great seller. Other brands do this too. I mentioned surface, some have a really nice brushed surface that also helps keep you from sliding off, and from making noise as you move. The Neoloft as mentioned, but the REI Helix is nice like this too. Baffling is also a factor. Some love "dimpled" pads (like the Helix), some like "tubes" either horizontal or vertical. The choice is yours. Closed cell foam are not comfortable. They are not thick. They are not warm at all. And they are bulky. But they are inexpensive, light, and almost indestructible. Anyone who bought a Ridgerest back in the 1990s likely still has it, and it's probably in like new condition.

I upgraded my klymit static v2 to a big agnes rapide sl wide, and I’m very happy. I too, couldn’t sleep well on the klymit and now I sleep brilliantly on the big agnes. Twice the size and weight but it’s worth it to me.

I have the Big Agnes Rapide SL and I mostly love it. It is plenty warm enough for me with a 20° quilt. My only complaint about it is that it's loud. I toss and turn a lot and it squeaks with every movement. If I was going to buy another pad I'd go with the Nemo Tensor All Season.

Just a heads up for you about the Rapide SL. It's R value is no where near 4.8. Big Agnes is lying. You can google it to see the reviews. Also it's very loud. If neither of those things bother you then you'll enjoy the pad. It's very comfortable.

I used it on a recent trip. At elevation temps were between 0-5°C. I was very cold with a -6°C quilt. Then after we came down I had the best sleep of my life at around 12°C with the same setup. So it's a good quality pad and very comfortable. Just don't expect it to perform well in cold climates.

Yep, second this! I have the wide Rapide SL, regular length as I am 5'6" 180 female. I sleep on my back, side, other side, and stomach. It is so worth it, and it changed the game for me sleeping outside. I shouldn't have waited as long as I did to buy it. Eta; I love it so much my husband has one, and I'm about to buy my 10 yo son one too because they're just that good.

Another happy BA Rapide SL wide user here. I tried multiple pads, and this was the one to keep. Comfy (for side sleep too) and quiet.

It’s definitely subjective, but there are some design elements that contribute to a pad’s comfort. I have a bad back and I’m a side sleeper. I typically get 3-4 hours of sleeping on the trail. I’ve tried both the MSR neoair xlite and xtherm, Nemo tensor all season, Big Agnes Rapide and the klymit static V. I recently purchased the REI helix long wide pad and I’m now sleeping 6-7 hours on trail. I’ll gladly take the weight penalty for better sleep. Justin Outdoors has several sleeping pad review and comparison videos that are worth watching.

I have the Big Agnes Rapide and absolutely love it. I’m a side sleeper and it’s supportive enough that I don’t wake up with my hip on the ground and it works well with my quilt. The included pump sack inflates it in about 7 good fills and the deflation valve works well.

It's so funny, I hated the Rapide. I found it to be too thick and felt really unstable on it. I like the Tensor though.

I’ve had Thermarest, BA, Exped and Nemo Tensor and the Tensor is the best for me. Not as light as a NeoAir Xlite, but still respectable- I have a regular wide, more comfortable and I think warmer than any you mentioned. The REI Helix is also worth trying. Maybe buy both online and return the one you don’t like. If you don’t take it outside it would be considered a new return with tags and original packaging.

So it's a bit complicated with the Rapide SL. Basically the original was brilliant, that's the one everyone raved about and recommended. Then in 2024 they came out with a new version which was lighter and supposedly warmer, however they changed the insulation from synthetic insulation to layers of foil insulation (similar to how Thermarest do it) and it is markedly worse than the original. For a start the outer-most chambers are not well insulated leading to the edges of the mat getting noticeabley cold, and second the insulation foil regularly fails in the same way as the Zoom UL. So if you bought one prior to maybe mid-2024 you would get the old (good) one, but anyone buying them now is getting an entirely different mat that just happens to look the same. Very deceptive on Big Agnes' part. As for Nortent, totally agreed. I'm absolutely sick of the usual suspect YouTubers who get this shit thrown at them for free to shill to their followers. Nortent are one of the absolute worst culprits for it, and I wouldn't trust a word of what those YouTubers say about their products. There are a number of them I avoid now because practically every video is them just shilling the latest junk they've been given without having properly tested it.

Just a note on this, they completely changed the insulation in the mat in mid 2024 (from synthetic insulation to reflective foil) and since then there have been loads of issues with them falling apart internally. The problem now is that people looking to buy them see all the rightfully earned rave reviews of the pre-change version and think they'll be getting the same product, when they aren't.

The air pads are lighter and pack smaller which aside from comfort are the only things I care about. Mine came with a bag to inflate it which is super easy.

Big Agnes SL insulated

I bought it last summer. It’s only 4-something r value so not for winter camping, I don’t have a problem with being cold because I also use sleeping bags for colder conditions than I’m actually in.

20-something probably.

Not a space saver, but our best purchases as a couple (maybe ever) have been a Big Agnes Dream Island double sleeping bag and Rapide SL double wide sleeping pad. The double sleeping bag alone is awesome if you like to cuddle, but switching to a double sleeping pad massively improved our sleep quality…no one rolling off the pad or falling into a weird crevice. 1000/10 would recommend!!

Yup. Lol. The Rapide is what I have, now. I had originally bought the Tensor but exchanged it for the Rapide, so those two flip flopped in my.mind. thx!

With a thickness of 2.5", the Klymit Static V Insulated is uncomfortable for side-sleepers and somehow doesn't feel quite as warm as its 4.2 R-value implies. The Big Agnes Rapide SL has a thickness of 4.25" and is very comfortable for this 60-year-old side-sleeper. It lives up to its 4.8 R-value. It's also lighter than the Klymit. If the REI sale offers a 30% discount, the Rapide will cost $112, almost the same as a new Klymit V Insulated. Of course, there are warmer pads than the Rapide, but most of them are more expensive or less comfortable.

As a 60-year-old side sleeper, I was having the same problem. The Big Agnes Rapide SL solved the problem. I'm 5'7" and weigh 165 lbs, if that matters. I don't know how it compares with the other pads you mentioned.

I don’t use one now because I’ve gotten a bit more comfortable sleeping on my back this past year. BUT back when I was a side sleeper I loved the Big Agnes Rapide SL Regular Wide. Quilted baffles were so comfy and it was THIQUE. Slightly weighty, but who gives a shit about UL if you can’t sleep and recover. Also wasn’t AS warm as Xlite, but not a big diff. Combined that with a similar two pillow method + sleep mask and ear plugs to Aromatic’s and I was OUT. Now I use a neo air xlite in shoulder season and a closed cell when things have thawed out because I sleep on my back more. I also second quilts. My Katabatibc 30 degree is toasty down into the 20’s and gives hella weight savings + roominess.

Yea. Thats what I mean by car camping. I only camp off my motorcycle so if I’m going on a long trip where storage space is crucial, I’d pack my big Agnes rapide sl pad. It’s not as good but it packs down to the size of a large water bottle. If I’m going on a weekend trip, the exped goes since I don’t need the extra space for meals and more clothing.

It’s the best one I’ve used so far for side sleeping. I move around a lot. It’s the only one I haven’t felt like I was hitting the ground when moving to my side. I also have a rapide sl that’s great but I still touch the ground when putting an elbow down or sitting on my butt. The only downside to the megamat for me is it doesn’t pack down small and I camp off my motorcycle. If I was travelling by car, it’s a no brainer imo.

I love my Big Agnes Rapide SL. I have the wide version.

I just got Big Agnes Rapide SL for my partner and I at REI sale.  We are both side sleepers, and we tried all of the popular suggestions at REI and found the rapide to be most comfortable. 

This is the way! #1 pad I recommend, get the 25x72

I was torn between the nemo and the rapid sl but this had a higher r value

Great chart. Wish there was something like this when I was shopping. Currently use a Rapide, and it is wonderfull! 3bdrs and several other trips and I have been super happy and I sleep like a baby. If only I could find a decent sleeping bag....

I just got my Big Agnes Rapide SL delivered today and I'm stoked. Wide-long.

I actually cross-shopped these three pads earlier this summer, and tried each one of them. My thoughts below: Packed size (smallest to largest): \-Nemo \-S2S \-Big Agnes Actual measured weight (lightest to heaviest): \-Nemo \-S2S \-Big Agnes Comfort (most comfy to least comfy): \-S2S \-Big Agnes \-Nemo I settled pretty happily on the S2S. It's significantly more comfy (IMO) than the other two. The other two have a slippery surface that makes the last 1" on each side unusable since you slide off it anyway. Even the Big Agnes, with it's raised outer baffle, doesn't help as much as you'd think since it's so slippery. For reference, I'm a side sleeper and move around quite a bit throughout the night. The S2S surface has more friction, is quieter, and just isolates movement overall a little bit better than the other two. I couldn't compare/contrast actual warmth since I've only taken them summer camping.

LOL, yeah I dove pretty hard into upgrading my sleep system this year. I tried the rectangular reg/wide in all pads. I settled on the S2S and love it. I used the Nemo several nights as well as the S2S several nights. The S2S is way ahead of the Nemo in terms of comfort, with only a slight penalty in weight. Packability is pretty similar, with a slight nod to the Nemo. You may be thinking of the previous gen S2S "XT" pads, which were not very packable, slightly heavier, colder, and maybe louder? The new "XR" version is fantastic. Big Agnes was another step up in bulk and weight, and I just couldn't justify either when the comfort wasn't as great as the S2S (which surprised me). I never camped with the Big Agnes, only tried it at home.

I have the Big Agnes Rapide SL and I adore the thing. I’ve been fine in temps in the teens (Fahrenheit) with a 0° rated bag and overquilt. Before that, I had backpacked with an old Klymit UL V from massdrop (anybody remember massdrop? I miss that) and it was decent, but I had no idea that I could be sleeping on a CLOUD. I can sleep on my side on the Rapide. I can sit up without my butt bones touching the ground through it! I love love love it and it’s so quiet compared to other sleeping pads. I share a tent with my SO and I toss and turn like crazy so I wanted something quiet. I haven’t tried the other pads and I normally wouldn’t give a rave review because I did get the sleeping pad for free full disclosure, but I really am SO happy with the sleeping pad. It is nearly impossible to get it back into the stuff sack tho. And it takes a LOT of pumps to fill it.

I use a Big Agnes Q core deluxe insulated for winter and a Big Agnes SLX for summer. I’m a bigger guy and also a side sleeper, and it keeps me off the ground. I’ve tried using a hammock, but I just don’t sleep as well as being flat on the ground.

big agnes rapide is the most comfortable, nemo tensor the second.

I have the same pad and I sleep extremely well on it on my back. In any position, really, which is pretty amazing since I'm an exclusive back sleeper in my bed. The shoes for head elevation is something I will have to try.

It’s very subjective. Especially if you’re not a kid anymore. I tried a bunch and I love my Rapide. I layer a thin CCF pad on top sometimes. So comfy. I’m a pretty active sleeper and I like the raised side baffles. Haven’t tried the neoair, but it’s usually got great reviews for comfort.

About the same height and weight I think Used to use a Big Agnes Rapide SL, mega comfy Switched to a Thermarest xlite nxt as it's lighter, it's about 90% as comfy but a fair bit lighter to carry Side sleeper also, if you're not worried about the weight the Big Agnes is the one to go for imo

I’m about the same height/weight as you, and also sleep in pretty much any position but prefer my side so a thicker pad was a must so my hips didn’t compress the pad to the ground. I ended up buying a Big Agnes Rapide SL, the wide version, and it’s been nothing but amazing. Highly recommended!

Yep. I know it’s not the lightest, but bad sleep is the quickest way to ruin a trip for me so I’ll take those extra ounces. If you have an REI or some other store that sells pads close by, swing by and try one out in the store. They should let you blow up any pad they have.

I think the R-value is like 4.8. That being said, I don’t do much super cold camping without my hot tent. I’ve definitely taken the Rapide when it was just below freezing out and never had an issue, to be fair I was probably over bagged for the weather though.

This. I’ll die on the Rapide SL wide hill. Damn the weight, that thing is comfy!

You’ll be very happy with that pad. I love mine, definitely get the wide. You would be surprised what five extra inches of width will do. Used mine for two nights this past weekend in just below freezing temps and was comfy as can be with a cheap 20° bag.

The big Agnes rapide double wide.. slept many of nights with my partner. Comfortable for us and not as much movement as an air mattress

We have this and I love it. Did not pay that much. Got it pretty discounted on sale. https://sierradesigns.com/backcountry-bed-20-duo/?srsltid=AfmBOooX41Hnz3atKHDrSC9E1TdFInnPWH5lsC3OUlhR77HGyEeMgKxH With big Agnes tent floor pad. Also got on sale. But you can use the double quilt with 2 individual pads. https://www.rei.com/product/233244/big-agnes-rapide-sl-insulated-tent-floor-sleeping-pad?sku=2332440001&store=73&CAWELAID=120217890017713188&CAGPSPN=pla&CAAGID=147758269919&CATCI=pla-2023795263505&cm_mmc=PLA_Google%7C21700000001700551_2332440001%7C2023795263505%7Cbrand_flag%7C11306272688&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=11306272688&gbraid=0AAAAAD_DTlwy5TXLjD16ca979TOJoStT4

The Rapide is fantastic but personally i don’t find it quite as warm as it claims to be. It’s very, very comfortable though.

The Rapide SL is really excellent. My partner and I have both been using them for quite a while now and I think it’s the comfiest pad out there. I’m also a side sleeper. I tend to agree it’s not quite as warm as it claims but I still use it during autumn and spring. However I do tend to sleep quite cold so that’s a factor to bear in mind with my opinion. I have the Sea to Summit Etherlite XT (my mid winter mat), which has a similar construction to the XR, and it’s also a very, very comfortable pad. The XR is the newer version of it and looks like an excellent pad and will be perfect for year round use. They are extremely lightweight for that kind of warmth. The Sea to Summit pads also come with little velcro stickers that keep your pillow in place, if your pillow is covered in fuzzy fabric (they’re made to lock Sea to Summit’s own pillows specifically but any fuzzy fabric pillow would work) which is a feature I really love. Broadly speaking, the pads with a “cushioned” build like the Rapide and the Etherlights, are the most comfortable for most sleepers, but they do weigh slightly more than horizontal or vertical baffle pads. For me, as an increasingly creaky 40 something, it’s worth the extra weight for a good night’s sleep.

I’ve slept on my Rapide up to about -5°C or so at which point I found I didn’t feel super cosy.

The problem with the Rapide is that, despite being a brilliant mat, someone who sleeps in the recovery position may find themselves getting a bit of an unpleasant surprise when moving into that position because of the (odd) lack of insulation in the side baffles.

I haven't used the new Nemo Tensor AS, but I do own an Exped 5R, BA Rapide SL, and an old regular Tensor. The Exped is definitely the most comfortable of the three--something about the vertical baffles just feels better, especially as a side sleeper. The material feels nicer/sturdier too. It's also a bit quieter than the tensor or rapide. One downside though is that it's pretty thick when rolled up, so it does take up decent space in my bag.

This should be a top comment. I have an old big Agnes 3.5 inch insulated and sleep on my side. My hip touches the ground for a second when I roll over, but then comes off when I get the rest of my body all the way down. I think that’s what you’re going for with air pressure.

Big Agnes. Get a wide. Bonus points if you pair it with one of their bags, as they work well together.

We have a big Agnes double pad and a single pad that combined cover the floor of our tent. It works for the two of us + toddler + dog pretty well. In our big tent we put those two things on top of some folding cots from Walmart.

Be wary of uninsulated air mattresses in mild temps.  I bought 2x Big Agnes insulated pads for my twins, along with the BA kid’s sleeping bags for our twins. This is more of a backpacking setup, but works great for car camping and living room camping.  The bags have a sleeve on the bottom so you can slide the pad inside. Helps keep them in the bag and on the pad - again - cause the cold ground can give them a chill. 

The only pillow i've ever found comfortable was the REI Co-Op Trailmade pillow. It's a non-inflatable pillow stuffed with memory foam squares. So it's definitely heavier and takes up more span than inflatable pillows, but after trying several brands of inflatable I just needed something different. I don't see it for sale anymore, so not sure if they still make it. If you aren't hiking in, and size isn't an issue, I would just use your home pillow. For me the big thing for side sleeping/stomach sleeping is a good mattress. If space isn't an issue a foam mattress would be best, there are a bunch of \~$50 tri-fold 4" memory foam mattresses on amazon. But these take up a HUGE amount of space in a car to transport. For backpacking I use an inflatable Big Agnes insulated pad, but those are like $150. If you aren't backpacking, amazon has several options for cheap inflatable camping mattresses, but you will probably need to buy or borrow an air pump to fill them, as they don't come with them usually. For the sleeping bag I've found I can sleep in any style as a stomach sleeper. Mummy style bags just kind of stay with you, so when you curl your legs up, the bang stays mostly form fitted. If you are sleeping on your stomach, do you sleep in "tiger pose" where you have one leg bent up and the other straight? Mummy bags can make sleeping like that difficult. Big rectangle bags would let you sleep in "tiger pose" with one knee up and the other leg straight, which is how I sleep at home. If you are going with a non-down warm sleeping bag, you can always bring a secondary blanket too, so you don't have to splurge on a super expensive 20 degree bag or anything.

Big agnes for the win. I had two of their insulated inflatables, and they were the best 2 pads I ever had. But got holes I could not locate despite weeks of trying. I'm ready to get another, even if it only lasts a couple seasons

Big Agnes pads are some of the toughest out there as far as I can know, yet I have gone through three because of punctures. Each time the holes have been so small that I can't find them without getting to a hotel and submerging them in the tub. The company is great about replacing them, but I've gone back to foam mats.

75l gregory bag, big agnes inflatable mattress (comfy)

I started on the old school thermarest shortie, then a full length, then switched to a big agnes inflatable--which i liked but went through two of them with bad valves. Switched to a nemo a couple of years ago, and love it. It's a little "crinkly" sounding, but otherwise well worth it. Good choice :-)

Big Agnes are the best

I have a big Agnes pad. Inflatable and not sure exactly what specs, but any inflatable pad is going to have some noise imo. I love mine. I’ve had it for 8 years, which feels kinda unreal for an inflable. Never had an issue with it and definitely put it through the gauntlet- camped in the desert a lot, cowboy camped, camped on rocky areas. Never had a leak. Love it and feel like it’s worth the price tag

I'm late 20's and I've never had a decent sleeping pad until this year, I got myself a big agnes inflatable pad off of ebay, my god I'm actually comfortable sleeping.

I have a pretty basic Big Agnes sleeping pad that's probably R-3.5 or something like that. I've used it for several trips in Washington and Oregon in the summer. Being cold from below was not a a problem. I think R-1.5 would be OK in the summer, the ground warms up quite a bit during the summer. A more insulated pad would only be necessary if the ground is frozen during the day. What probably matters most for you is size, weight, and comfort - it needs to be thick enough so you don't feel the ground through the pad. I would also look at how difficult it is to inflate. The one I have has a terrible valve that seems to be designed to be as inconvenient as possible. You have to blow into it, but there's a bit of resistance to air coming in, and the valve is such that it's hard to tell if it's open or closed. I'm attaching a piece of an old bicycle inner tube to make it possible to use a bike pump. Some pads have a built-in hand pump and that would be useful. I can't offer a recommendation for a specific product since I haven't bought one recently, and the one I have doesn't seem to be available any more.

Funny, I just spent last night sleeping on a Big Agnes pad with a very slow leak, after having just patched a slow leak in the same pad.

Big Agnes is the best I’ve found. Pricey but well worth it.

Have you considered a camping cot? There are a lot of ultralight options now which are about the same price as a good sleeping pad for side sleepers. The only difference being is the weight, you’re looking at around 1.5kg for a cot bed which would be double the weight of a sleeping pad. For me, the extra weight is worth it for the comfort. For context I’ve tried Therm-a-Rest, Big Agnes and Nemo mats. If I’m going for comfort, the cot bed wins every time.

Big Agnes and sea to summit checks all your boxes. Small/compact, uses vertical baffles to prevent that bouncy castle feeling and provide actual support

It's very simple if it blows up with air and inflates - at SOME point it's gonna get a hole in it. That's life! The whole air mattress thing started with Therm-a-rest's and they were pretty tough back then, now with everybody sporting hard-on's for "ultralight" gear its gonna get worse. Same goes for actual air mattress, you can sleep on them but if you're not in Texas or Arizona yer still gonna freeze your butt off. Here's why ....... People these days buy inflatable pads for the comfort, but you really need them for the insulative qualities they actually provide. Don't believe me go sleep on the actual ground one night. When you crawl in to your sleeping bag you actually crush the down or syntho fill in the bag so there is no insulation there under you and the cold even in summer can seep right in. You need a pad under you to keep you off the ground ..... the best ones for that are still the cheap blue ensolite foamy's you buy at the cheaper stores but yes, for comfort they suck. There is a yellow thicker brand called Zotefoams Evazote and they got up to an inch thick but I haven't seem them for years but they were good quality and tough and CAN'T deflate ! So ultimately if you want comfort you need to go buy a big chunk of open cell white foam four inches thick and 7 feet long like you see in hobby stores - mega comfy and the size of a house! But now you can't pack it anyway so you're back to the blow up pads - and that's it. You can go to stores and look at stuff like Futons and crap but they don't pack well ! Heck even Ikea makes a folding mattress but again good luck carrying it around, right? Pick one but they WILL get a hole in them at some point however you can try to limit that with a cot. I've used them for years and its nice. I'm gonna suggest a Cabella's Lounger Cot but they are $350 bloody bucks and the same goes a real camping pad, something like a Exped Megamat itself is $400 bucks by itself. The two cots I wanna get are gonna cost me $405 bucks so add in two decent pads like Expeds and they're $500 .... great huh? It's nuts at a thousand bucks! I actually might just go get some memory foam cut at an RV store and use that. They can't deflate and its about the same bloody price as these inflatable ones, granted it won't be near as packable and portable but both my Thermarest leak, both my Big Agnes pad leak, even the TWO Coleman air beds leak, you can't win. My tent is 210 sq feet and 10 feet tall so I don't need backpack-ability either ........

I went from a Klymit to a Big Agnes. Night and day difference. 

Plus one. I have a therm-a-rest Xtherm, two cheap Amazon pads (they didn’t last), a Big Agnes, and I’ve tried the foam pads (they’re not for me). Exped seems to have the best tech. Their pads are quiet, comfy, reliable, and I love the synthetic down on the inside

Big Agnes has valve issues, mine didn't even last 3 uses

I had a Big Agnes for a decade. It sprung a leak on a trip this time last year. I found the leak on a seam and called to ask about repairing it. They asked for a pic, which I sent as well as a pic of the valve cut off (per their instructions) and my new pad arrived in a few days. No charge. I’ll never buy a pad from a different manufacturer again. https://preview.redd.it/qcc2h29uz8ve1.jpeg?width=5712&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4a5db870df20331f504fddf587c14258a32a7250

Bought my Big Agnes pad for $100 at REI ten years ago and still going strong. Not a single leak. I’m a side sleeper and it’s pretty comfy. 

I've used my Exped for 500miles. I've never had a problem with it. Personally, I would only buy Exped or Big Agnes sleeping pads because they're the only ones I've never seen leak. Anything by thermarest is trash.

I'd say it's at the very least quieter than my Big Agnes that I used most recently. In all honesty at 390lbs every thing is noisy when I toss and turn, but I wouldn't say it's extra noisy or anything. As far as better than self inflating, I'd say yes by a large margin. That being said, I've also got to admit the last self inflating pad I regularly used was probably 10 years ago. I'd assume tech has come a long way since my last self inflating pad but I don't know for sure. I never had one that would ever keep me completely off the ground the entire night. there were always high and low spots and not much insulation back then. If you do go that route at the very least I'd try to find the thickest pad in your budget. Also on noise, maybe a pad cover like the Thermarest Synergy may help as well. I'm looking into that as a little extra protection from dog claws but I'm sure it would dampen noise too.

I have an exped and multiple air mattresses, and I still prefer my Big Agnes. Warm, roomy, supportive, compact, affordable.

The premium REI pads are your best bang for your buck. I had the big Agnes but ended up buying the cold weather REI

As I side sleeper, I have found some of the Big Agnes pads to be very comfortable, and quiet. I've been through several different types and brands of pads over the years (decades) I like that the sides are higher on the BA pads, which keep you from rolling off the mat. It's not that they are super high to physically prevent you from rolling off. It's the subconcious thing that when you feel that extra height, your brain does it, even when asleep. The 25 inch wide pads are much better for side sleepers. I'd go with a 30 inch wide, but they only make that width in a few long pads. For biking, you may not mind the extra ounces for the 30 inch wide, long pad. I have one, and wish I could cut it shorter, but afraid to do so, for fear of not being able to seal it properly. None of the name brand pads are inexpensive. The new Therm-a-Rest NeoLoft looks good, and has many good reviews. If I didn't already have a few BA pads, I'd be tempted to buy a NeoLoft. The next time I'm at REI, I may try one, just to see.

If you want small the mega mat isn't the answer. I use a Big Angus pad and I am happy with it. I couldn't imagine sleeping on just a foam pad though

I also have one of these and loved it initially. After two months on the road it is now failing almost every night. I’ve exhausted the patches that came with the pad and it’s now covered with third party gear repair patches. I am ~75kgs and I don’t over-inflate it. I paid good money for this thing and it is absolutely not worth it.

Nemo or big Agnes pads!

Big Agnes. Im a side sleeper and also started with a Klymit like you and found it inadequate. My big agnes is only a little heavier but it's about four inches thick when fully inflated, which is great.

A lot of it depends on how you sleep. I’m a side sleeper which means they all suck, but it’s better than nothing even if your hips end up touching the ground (especially when it’s cold). The biggest differences are weight and durability but overall sleeping pads are things I pretty much exclusively pick up on sale. I have a couple of Big Agnes pads from several years ago that are tough and do the job- my wife sleeps on her back and hasn’t had complaints

Having a family of 4 can confirm individuals is the way to go. We’re all rocking Big Agnes pads. The kids are using big Agnes bags which have a pocket for the pad and keeps them from wondering around at night.

Spend money. Get a good quality mattress, this is not the place to go cheap. Restful sleep is important for recovery. The most expensive air mattress is still cheaper than a hotel for a night. I use a Big Agnes. It's 4 in thick, 25 in wide, 76 in long. I can inflate it quickly with the included pump sack, it's gets firm and hold air throughout then night. It has a 4 R value so it insulates well. I sleep like I'm in a bed. This was the single biggest upgrade to my gear and the best value (although it wasn't cheap). Anything you find on Amazon will be crap quality. Buy from a reputable brand. Check out outdoorgearlab.com for reviews. They are the Consumer Reports for gear.

The big Agnes pad is really nice and very comfortable, I do think it's R value is over stated though.  On nights where its around freezing or just below I've found myself getting rather cold.  I know my sleeping bag is fine because it's always coming from the ground often I'll toss some clothes under my legs and it helps to stop that issue.  I will probably invest in a better R value pad for the winter/shoulder seasons 

I suggest individual sleeping bags or quilts for colder weather. When I purchased sleep bags, I looked for a comfort rating that is the same or lower than lowest expected temperature. A 20f sleeping bag may have comfort rating of 30 or 40 degrees. To sleep well in 30 degrees, look for a 10 degree bag or quilt. A pad with R5 or better rating. The REI Helix is liked by many because it’s close to R5 and it’s lightweight. Big Agnes pads, I have 3, tend to sleep cold so I discount their R values. I have used a quilt plus an additional fiberfill blanket in colder weather. It worked well, but I first tried it car camping when I knew I had a back up system (more blankets) available. Recently I purchased a 10 degree quilt for temps down to mid-20s. It’s still in the teens at my house with lows in single digits. I like quilts but it did take some time to learn how to use mine well and stay warm. For the novice, a sleeping bag is a wise choice. Once you digest all the comments here, settle on a budget, and get a better idea of what conditions you will experience, consider making a new post over in r/backpacking with greater detail.

I’m a back sleeper with a big Agnes pad and would recommend from comfort pov.

Perhaps you are over inflating it? I was having a problem with my big Agnes and let out a bunch of air and it was much more comfortable. Now I inflate it to just enough so my hip doesn’t hit the ground when I’m on my side.