For ultimate comfort and insulation while car camping : Exped Megamats.
We have been using ours for about 7 years know and they are still as comfy as ever.
For hiking/bushcrafting I have tried a lot of pads. Nemo, Sea to Summit, Thermarest and the one that stuck with me are the Exped pads. I am a side sleeper so those vertical baffles work much better for me. I recently switched to the Exped Ultra 6.5R mummy in LW for lighter backpacking (450g and a R Value of 6.9) and the Exped Ultra 10R LW (800g and R Value of 10.2) for winter camping.
The other pads have their place but they don't work that well for me for comfort.
It's hard to say tbh, I know some thinner pads can be more comfy than thicker pads because of the fabric. If the fabric is more stretchy the pad will craddle you and adjust more to your contour . I prefer the Exped pads because they are 9 cm, fabric is stretchy and have the longitudinal baffles, they are super comfy but also more expensive than the pads you posted.
I own both.
The Ultra is a thicker version of the Exped Ultra 5.
Exped has a new series of Ultra pads like the Ultra 6, 8 and 10. This now has reflective insulation and standard insulation, is lighter than the older mats and warmer.
CaptainYarrr
