
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Reddit Reviews
Personally for a cot, I use a Onetigris Supranubis. Packs down small (smaller if I leave out the legs), it's very sturdy, and comfortable. Though it is a "firm ride" IMO, so I use a pad. For a pad, I started out with about the cheapest "backpacking" air mattress I could find on Amazon. But that one sprung a leak, so I upgraded to the Onetigris Dreamstar Single. That thing has been absolutely stellar. It doesn't pack down super small, but it's not huge either (about the size of a basketball). It's pretty heavy too, definitely not a "backpacking" mattress. Keeps me comfortable even down to REALLY cold temps under a 50\* sleeping bag with an army style wool blanket as a "liner", and wearing silkies and a sweater (down to the mid/low-30s, could go colder with a few adjustments). However, my son will likely be borrowing my Dreamstar for our upcoming trip next weekend, and I wanted a good (decent) backpacking mattress option, so I'm expecting a Hikenture 6.2R ultralight air mattress from Amazon to arrive today (hopefully). Like you, I don't anticipate using it frequently, and only in mild weather, so I wasn't going to spend Sea to Summit or Therm-a-rest money at this point. It's relatively lightweight, has a good R-value, is relatively "deep", gets good reviews, etc. It seems like a good value for me at this point.... If my kid gets into backpacking like I did (I was HEAVY into backpacking in my youth), then I'll upgrade, because they really are worth it when you're 50 miles into the back-country, and you just backpacked 12 miles and picked up thousands of feet of elevation... for a few days in a row... Those situations IMO demand the absolute best gear, and there's usually a reason it's expensive. Forgot to mention how I keep the mat from moving around on the cot: I use an old twin fitted sheet. Not terribly heavy, packs down small (inside whatever bag my mattress is going in), and adds a bit of comfort. It's not going to keep it in place SUPER well, but good enough for me. But I still have problems keeping my pillow on the cot...
- ditch the wipes for biodegradable - ditch the multitool, good knife is all you’ll need. I use mossy oak and they have withheld for years. - MSR pocket rocket has been a super small and great camp stove for me, these cheap amazon brands I would be cautious of. - do not get that sleeping pad. It’s cheap and will be extremely uncomfortable and only good for summer. I use flextail gear mummy pad and my wife uses Hikenture 6.2 r value sleeping pad. Both comfortable and warm. Hikenture is more noisy but easy availability and cheaper. - can’t speak on the tent but a free standing is better for new campers. - sleeping bag is going to be very bulky. Try to find a 20F ultralight bag. I can’t speak on specific brands. I use a 30F REI mummy bag and it’s been good but I’m in the market for a new one too. This Coleman will not fit in a backpack. Your biggest expense will be your sleeping system. Don’t cheap out here especially if you plan on doing fall and spring trips.
Naturehike Mongar 2p. If you really can get a Marmot Limelight for under $150 definitely get that over the Naturehike (DAC aluminum poles and a lifetime warranty are primary reasons). For a bag I would look for a deal on a Marmot Tressles Elite Eco. I have seen the older models on clearance for under $100. These pack down much smaller and weigh far less than traditional synthetic bags. If you can afford a down bag go for. Paria Outdoor Products Thermodown 30 or 15f. Otherwise if you are with used try to find a quality down sleeping bag. Cots under $75 go with a Naturehike, iClimb or Kingcamp cot with aluminum poles and legs. Aluminum cots pack down way smaller and weigh significantly less than steel. For the sleeping pad I would recommend a knockoff of the Exped MegaMat. Semi inflating mats are way higher R value than the junk Intex and Coleman air mattresses and way more comfortable. A budget alternative to the MegaMat would be th Stoic Cloud or Cloud Lux or the Hikenture semi inflating mat. These are 3-5" thick and feel like sleeping on a bed at home. Combine them with a cot and it's pure luxury.
I got the hikenture a couple months ago (I already had their pillow) but have only used it one night down to the mid 40’s. I was a bit cold overall but didn’t feel cold from the pad. So no complaints.
End of reviews
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Back pain relief

Top pick
Exped - MegaMat Series
Best for Couples

Top pick
Exped - MegaMat Series
Best for Maximum comfort car camping

Top pick
Exped - MegaMat Series
Best for Side sleepers

Top pick
Exped - MegaMat Series
Best for Winter camping

Top pick
Therm-a-Rest - NeoAir Xtherm Series





