
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Reddit Reviews
Just swapped from the Netatmo to the Logitech and I have to say, wow.
Our netatmo which i seriously regret buying still goes strong after 8 years. The sucker refuses to die.
Same here, had the Netatmo doorbell as a beta tester for over a year. Mine never gets direct sun, it has been rock solid for over a year and a half.
Get another doorbell. Theres many without a chime, for example Netatm, which can even connect to your dumb chime inside. That is if you have cables to the gate of course. PoE could also be good
I’ve been using Netatmo for 3 years now. I use it through HK only and disable the native app features. It’s wired which I think is a must and it uses an old chime box (or HomePod) to ring. Only negative would be no wifi6
Netatmo Video Doorbell. I’ve twice had to contact them for spares (moved, broke components) and they overnighted them for free, from France, because their customer support is that good.
Ich habe eine Netamo und habe immer wieder Probleme , hat jemand Erfahrung lohnt sich der Wechsel auf die Aqara?
We bought Simplisafe before we became Apple and HomeKit users. It doesn’t fully integrate with HomeKit but it does work with our 3 Yale keyless locks. We moved it to a new house and no longer have any cameras since the HOA has severe limitations on visible cameras, plus we have eaves that are 15 foot off the ground and no attic access our previous house we used Arlo mounted on wood siding. Now we have stucco. We did swap our 18VDC doorbell for a Neatmo. I wound not ever entertain the idea of using anything like Ring or Ecobee cloud based security. Far too invasive and Ecobee actually phones home all your hvac data, any smart switche data etc if you use its Alexa skill. I like keeping some things distinctly isolated. We have sensors for water leaks, smoke, CO, etc that are through simplisafe and can be seen on phones remotely. The smoke detector that a builder puts in is a dumb device that simply makes noise - if my home is on fire I’d like to know this when I’m not home. We also installed a Moen Flo that shuts off water if it detects abnormal use (during the drought and draconian Newsome implemented restrictions in California there were actual water thieves who would fill water tanks from people’s yards. Locking up the hose wasn’t effective - they brought their own.)Any alert goes to the app on our phones, as does the Meross leak detectors in our garage under the washer, refrigerator, utility sink and water heater. I’ve never found it necessary to combine all this into HomeKit or use a platform like Home Assistant. Good notifications on our phones work for us. We travel a lot in the summer, we are in a retirement community, there is virtually no crime other than people not cleaning up after their dog or parking overnight on the street - so we have no need of serious robust security. A combo of door and window switches, motion detectors and glass break sensors are all installed by the user in the home. Simplisafe monitoring is very reasonably priced. My only annoyance is the package detection on the Neatmo camera. It seems Amazon loves to hide stuff out of view. But that’s not a HomeKit issue,mits a delivery issue.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Extreme cold climates

Top pick
Reolink - Wired Video Doorbell Series
Best for Home assistant integration

Top pick
Reolink - Wired Video Doorbell Series
Best for Package theft prevention

Top pick
Reolink - Wired Video Doorbell Series
Best for Privacy and data sovereignty

Top pick
Reolink - Wired Video Doorbell Series
Best for Renters

Top pick
Reolink - Wired Video Doorbell Series





