
Samsung
Q990F
Value for movies and easy setup, but music falls flat.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
I recently upgraded to the LG S70TR and it's pretty awesome
I have limited experience but comparing my atmos soundbar with the up firing speaker and my friend’s actual stereo set up with ceiling speakers, it makes me think my atmos channel does nothing. I’m sure some bars with significantly more up-firing speakers can get a little bit closer to mimicking the sound, but at that point you are paying so much more to sound worse than just installing height speakers. Since you say you are using a fairly small room, your best strategy may be to hang some acoustic foam on the walls to cut down on the sound bouncing back at you, but leave the ceiling untreated so the atmos channel can reflect off the ceiling and be more noticeable.
I have the s70tr and I have no issues with the wireless rear speakers, they are wired to each other I believe, the sub is separately plugged in. I don’t know if the single atmos speaker is really worth it for the extra hundred dollars compared to the s60tr though, but I got mine on sale so it’s nice to have. Compared to my 2.1 Samsung it’s not as powerful/loud but for the price, to have rears and atmos, it was worth it to me
I was using the Samsung HW-T550, I upgraded to the s70tr when I bought a new tv that used earc and it started having lip sync issues. If I had the extra cash I would have sprung for a Samsung 5.1, but for the value the s70tr couldn’t be beat
I have the S70tr it’s decent but I think the klipsch is better. The wow orchestra just turns on your tv speakers as extra channels, I wouldn’t put it as a dealbreaker if you don’t want to stay in the ecosystem. Since you live in an apartment, the good thing about the klipsch is it’s upgradable, so you can start with the soundbar and get the rears and subs later on.
I have it, for the price I got it for it’s an amazing deal, the only other one I’ve seen in the price range for surround and atmos is the Hisense ax700 which has 4 upfiring vs the 1 large for the s70tr. Sound quality is good, the rears and sub are very immersive, not sure if I can tell if the atmos does anything but it’s nice to know it’s there. As far as I know the wow orchestra just adds your tv speakers into the set up, but the tv speakers don’t really sound the best standalone; it may sound better if they don’t push any bass through those, but if there is a better soundbar for the same price I wouldn’t let it be the deciding factor.
Lg has one for 349 right now. S70tr
Sorry, I meant Best Buy has an LG. I just bought that one for our living room tv. It won’t blow your hair off but it’s really good for what it is.
It's well worth it imo. I upgraded from an lg70tr which is a 5.1.1 system that came out last year to a q990d and its really night and day difference especially with dolby atmos content. The q990d is way way louder, i never turn it up past 30 and that's even too loud for my wife. Unless you have the budget for a true speaker set up this is probably one of the best set ups you can get especially for the value.
I have the LG NS70TR and am not happy. Voices sound very tinny. I have a post on this sub about this soundbar and got similar complaints. I've tried all kinds of settings. I'm going to return it. I actually had bought a Sony non 5.1 and I returned it and bought the LG.
LG S60TR or S70TR would be way better than any of these and you can usually get it for pretty cheap
i love my S95TR, it has phenomenal low ends that are deep but really tight- i genuinely don’t get the hate either! i’ve also had an S70TR and that was easily the best soundbar for under $500 that you can get (or the S80 when it’s on sale lol). there seems to just be a hate train for LG for some reason, i’ve tried many systems and it’s easily my fave
that’s valid- try the Cinema mode, and turn up the Subwoofer and Bass settings (if you haven’t already), i had that set that way when i had an S70TR
you’re much better off paying a bit more and getting an LG S70TR, i made that exact upgrade and the sound quality difference is game changing
the S70TR from LG has been the most solid sounding bar i could find for under $500- highly recommend!!
get a bar from a higher end company instead- the LG S70TR was a solid choice for the price when i had it, a little pricier but wayyy better audio quality than anything insignia. from what i’ve heard Hisense’s 5.1.4 bar is also pretty good for the cost
if you’re okay with surround speakers, i’d suggest the LG S70TR- the comments will probably flame me for recommending anything LG audio but i had one for a year before giving it to my parents for christmas and it was easily the best under $500 system i’ve ever used
as a previous S70TR owner (upgraded to the S95TR), i can easily say it’s an incredible value. probably the best setup under $500 honestly
if you can have rear speakers in your space, LG S70TR! if not, JBL Bar 500 MK2 or Samsung Q600F!
nobody will agree with me bc of the LG hate train but LG S70TR- it usually goes for around $350 (when it’s on sale at least) and is a 5.1.1 setup with high fidelity drivers (which is rare for that price) along with wireless satellites- an easy grab imo i’ve messed around with a lot of budget systems and this one was easily my favorite for under $500
by far my favorite sub-$500 soundbar setup has been the LG S70TR. sounds incredibly clean, and has a good app to help fine-tune it, and i think it’s available at Best Buy for $350 right now but i’ve seen it for less

Samsung
Q990F
Value for movies and easy setup, but music falls flat.

Sonos
Beam (Gen 2)
Compact value, but virtual Atmos and app issues.

Samsung
HW-Q990D
Powerful, immersive value, but poor music and buggy software.

Sonos
Arc Ultra
Immersive Atmos and bass, but pricey and poor for music.

Samsung
Q930F
Strong value for movies, but music and HDMI 2.0 limit.

Ranked #1
Sonos - Beam (Gen 2)

Ranked #1
Samsung - Q990F

Ranked #1
Sonos - Arc Ultra

Ranked #1
Sonos - Playbar

Ranked #1
Sonos - Arc Ultra