
Mount to Coast
H1
Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Seconded. I have the Altra Experience Wild 3+ and they're fantastic. Alternatively, if you're trails aren't super rocky and/or you don't want lugs on your shoes, you could have a look at the Experience Flow.
I only use them for hiking. These are the first non-waterproof trail shoes ive used before and the breathability is great, albeit of course leaves me vulnerable to water ingress. But should be fine when it's warm as my feet dried pretty quickly. Ive not long had them, so can't really comment on durability, except to say it appears ive caught the fabric on the top (near top lace eyelet) and its damaged the fabric. I can't comment on whether that is on me, but it's never happened before on other shoes. I also read that the sole wears out pretty quick (can't comment yet), but that is a tradeoff i'm willing to eat, given they fit so nice in the midfoot and i'm tired of shoe roulette trying to find something that fits. I have a wide forefoot, reasonably wide midfoot and narrow ankle so something like salomon, brooks, or topo is a no-go. Edit: On descent, can't say I noticed. I'd say they're not as laterally stable as my inov-8', but didn't get bruised toes or anything.
Altra Experience Wild 3+ this new version switched to Vibram soles. 4mm drop and more stack than the Lone Peaks, which I still wear on flat easy trails because they're like slippers. Standard toe box (still wider) for Altra, Lone Peaks have the OG. I also have Tarkine Trail Devil 2, Topo MTN Racer 3 and Hoka Speedgoats.
I've pretty much followed the same path as you and for over 100km: Tarkine Trail Devil 2 > Topo Mtn Racer 3 > Lone Peaks Although I think the LPs have the most forgiving shape and just this week, I got a pair of **Altra Experience Wild**, which are the standard Altra shape (LP are Original shape shape) but much bigger stack height and 4mm offset. They also take the Altra gaiter system, which I really like, so these may get to the top of the list- just need to get some runs in them. So, if you kinda like the LPs but want a bit more, these might be an option for you.
Ive had the 1,2 and now the 3+. The 3 or 3+ seems like the best version yet for me. The tread doesnt have any voids on the bottom and the heel was redesigned and feels very locked in with minimal front to back movement. The only difference between the 3 and 3+ is the rubber being upgraded to Vibram and the toe strike is bigger for more protection. Although it is less "rocker" style like the 1 and 2, i didnt notice that difference on my recent run in them. Having the extra tread protection on the bottom is worth it for me. Got sharp rocks 'round here.
Ive had the 1,2 and now the 3+. The 3 or 3+ seems like the best version yet for me. The tread doesnt have any voids on the bottom and the heel was redesigned and feels very locked in with minimal front to back movement. The only difference between the 3 and 3+ is the rubber being upgraded to Vibram and the toe strike is bigger for more protection. Although it is less "rocker" style like the 1 and 2, i didnt notice that difference on my recent run in them. Having the extra tread protection on the bottom is worth it for me. Got sharp rocks 'round here.
Altra Experience Wild 3+, 4mm drop, Love these shoes
exp wide 3 has a 4mm drop, so closer to other standard drop brands, not really low drop. i wear exp wild 2’s and altra olympus 6 & 275 which are true zero drop. i’d give yourself a couple of hours per day & building up - if i wear the ew2’s for 5 days straight my first day in oly’s gives me some pain in the top of my foot and top of fib, but just for a day. some people new to the altra toebox width can benefit from toesox to pack it out - you may be experiencing some growing pains, give them a solid go before you chuck em out
I had several shoes of the 2 and am now running in the 3. Very roughly, I found that the foam in the 3 is softer, more reactive, which makes runnign much more comfortable. I also feel that Vibram (and I think we alkl agree on that) increased the grip of the shoe. I prefere the new laces as they do not open so easily anymore during a run. However, I had to figure out how to tie the shoes because initially, running in them led to severe pain in my ankles. Figured out I have to leave the upper most part a bit more lose than I'd intuitively do. Overall, I prefer the 3.

Mount to Coast
H1
Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.

Altra
Lone Peak Series
Spacious toe box, but cushioning and durability are polarizing.

La Sportiva
Prodigio Series
Great technical grip, but unstable for some, with sizing issues.

Nike
Pegasus Trail Series
Versatile for non-technical trails, but poor on wet, technical.

Mount to Coast
T1
Lightweight, cushioned; but lacing and underfoot protection are issues.

Ranked #1
Salomon - Speedcross Series

Ranked #1
Hoka - Speedgoat Series

Ranked #1
Mount to Coast - H1

Ranked #1
Salomon - Genesis Series

Ranked #1
La Sportiva - Prodigio Series

Ranked #1
Mount to Coast - H1