Altra - Lone Peak 1.5

I’ve worn LPs of various models since the LP1.5. They are quite different shoes and it’s very individual whether they work at all for people, and whether a particular model works at all for people. I liked the 1.5 and the 2.0 but could not even get the 3.0 and 3.5 to fit comfortably in the store (let alone on trail)! My favourites since have been the 4.5, the 6 and the 9. In general, they all have zero drop and a moderate (but not barefoot) stack height. As a result they give reasonable ground feel and reasonable protection. Generally speaking, they also all have a relatively wide forefoot and midfoot and an average heel width. But these have all varied a little between models, to the extent that 2 models wouldn’t even fit me in the store let alone after a foot-swelling, long day on trail. In the last few years (with my advancing age!) I have found that for day and week long hikes I still prefer LPs, but for multi-week, on-trail, hikes I now prefer Timps for more cushion and less foot fatigue. If the trip is going to involve more off-trail then I still prefer LPs for better ankle stability. Ultimately, only *your* feet can tell you if they are a good fit for you. No review or hiker-survey or Reddit post can tell you that! The same with Topos or Hokas etc. I’ve yet to try any pair of Topos that was even comfortable in the store *for me*. Same with La Sportiva, Hoka and others. That doesn’t make those terrible shoes - they are just terrible *for me!* Likewise, the fact that some of the LPs over the years have suited me well doesn’t make them the best shoes ever for everyone - they are just good (and sometimes ideal) *for me!*

I have an older model and what a fun discovery it was that they don't grip on smooth floors. I really like they're finally doing black on black though.

Super big feet here. My problem is super wide, but also size 15. I am on my third pair of Freet Flex. Used to use Altra Superior but newer models got thicker and narrower. I do have a pair of older Lone Peaks I use without the inner sole to give me more space.

Take the insole out of the shoes. I'm literally right now wearing an older version on Altr Lone Peaks with no insoles. If the ones you bought were a little tight, they should fit perfect.

I like the Altra LPs. I've got both regular and WP versions over the years.  It's true, tread life is limited; I've moved them on before I otherwise would due to tread reasons. And their tread on their regular (and older) models just isn't the same as a good vibram sole. (I look forward to trying the new vibram model once I find it on a clearance rack...)

Don't use shoes you haven't done plenty of hiking in if you're changing types. So, get those new ones soon and start training in them. Muscle use will be different!! (FWIW, I'm a fan of Altra's Lone Peak shoes. Unless I'm on snow and need mountaineering boots for crampons, I use LPs. They've taken me up Helens more than once, and all my other hikes for years.

I also live in the PNW, and strongly disagree about waterproof. Waterproof is appropriate in snow, but otherwise the shoes accumulate too much sweat to stay dry anyway. I do the vast majority of my hiking in Altra Lone Peaks, and do indeed where the older pairs around town once the tread has worn down more than I want on the trail. The waterproof LPs I have our actually almost entirely for in town use during the wet weeks. I also have single and double mountaineering boots from Lowa, for the trips that will take me over snow or in below freezing temps for a long time.

That's my point, my WP LPs are pretty much for in town use. Even if it's raining, I'd rather hike with regular trail runners. But my feet sweat some in any WP shoe, so there's that...

I use Lone Peaks, but they aren't the most durable ever. I expect to replace them once a year or so, and I'm waiting on clearance sales for the new vibram soled ones. But they work really well for my feet and body.

I'd second this recommendation. I have both the regular Lone Peaks and the water resistant version. No heel lift, plenty of space for my toes but not sloppy. Good traction on rocks too. I hike 8-18 miles most Saturdays and these shoes are comfortable right out of the box. I don't ever worry about "breaking in" a new pair. When the old pair reaches about 300 miles, I buy new and start wearing those.

My husband is a 13EEE and the Altra Lone Peaks (regular) fit him well.  They also have an extra wide version of some of their shoes. 

I have a pair of Danners that I love (I'm actually wearing them at work right now) but I don't hike in them. They're very comfortable and durable but they are so HEAVY compared to synthetics. Unless I'm hiking in serious snow/slush I opt for Altra trail runners. For snow/slush I have an old pair of Merrells. I couldn't even tell you the model other than they look kinda like LL Bean duck boots if they came in gray synthetic.

I have similar experience. My Winter Gore-Tex Lone Peaks have lasted for at least four winters, as the soles remain intact under my spikes, and the top is worn down, not fully water-resistant anymore, but no holes. And my current summer Lone Peaks are 600+ miles and the top is intact, and the lugs are slightly worn out. But this is a Vibram sole which cost extra $15 at REI. There isn't much foam in Loan Peaks, and I could care less if it's compressed.

2x Lone Peaks, 1x Superiors. 2000+ miles

Generally I'm getting at least 700-800 miles. Last year I did 2000+ miles, and two pairs of Lone Peaks were completely done for, and one pair of Superiors is still OK. Strengthening arches takes a lot of time, but eventually it worked for me - I no longer need cushioning, all I want is that small rocks and such do not bite my feet. I'm much heavier than you. YMMV of course, and what worked for me might not work for you.

same here, and that's a massive strain on my ankles. to go easy on the ankles, I'm always running in zero drop low stack shoes: Lone Peaks and Superiors. also I'm strengthening my ankles almost daily: 15-20 minutes of single legged balance excercises and calf raises. it's incredibly boring, I'm doing that while watching some movie. it works, I'm running completely pain-free

Personally on more technical trails I prefer lower stack, not more cushioning - it's way easier on my ankles, especially on steep downhills. And after some strengthening, and after working on my running form, I don't really need much cushioning any more. So while generally I run in Lone Peaks, I go for Superiors for my most rugged runs.

Fellow wide Lone Peak wearer (though in women’s) and I made the mistake of switching to Olympus 275s for my first 100 attempt since I thought more cushion would help me. Olympus and Olympus 275 are known for being roomy, but by mile 30 there was no room for my little toes and by mile 40 my arches were screaming. I DNF’ed at mile 54 and could barely get the shoes off. I’m sticking with the Lone Peaks from now on, no matter the terrain.

Boots are too hot for me and I need my shoes to dry out (sweat) as much as they can during my stretch and water breaks thrughout the day. So I personally stick to trail runners. I also don't want to wear out my knees earlier in life than I have to, so the less weight Im lifting, including on my feet, the better. As for which trail runners, I prefer Altra Lonepeak, the non-waterproof ones. I have wide feet so I like the toe box. I tried some of Altras other models and didnt like them as much for one reason or another. However, feet are so variable from one person to another, in more ways than just width. (height of arch, heal to toe ratio preference for knees, etc.) If you are going to try trail runners, I recommend visiting a running store and having them help you find a good shoe for your particular feet and needs.

I have the Altra Olympus and the Lone Peak. The LPs are more comfortable to me. The tongue and laces doesnt dig into the top of my foot like the AO's does. Granted, not every foot is shaped the same. So not everyone has this problem. (No, it's not a lacing issue on my part.) Next, the cushion in the AO is pretty dense. So, it doesnt do much more for me than the LP does.

I’m not a fan of zero drop running shoes. I had one pair of Altras and won’t buy another. I guess I’m not allowed to share my shoe opinions on a post asking about shoes without getting downvoted. 🤷‍♂️